Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Robo Hippy - Coring Question

Posts

Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#1

Robo Hippy - Coring Question

Bartimmo

Robo Hippy,

At what height do you set up the McNaughten tool? Do you want the gate height set so that:

1. Tip of the tool is equal to ceter point of blank

or

2. Tip positioned slightly above center so that once the coring begins the middle of the coring blade is inline with the center of the blank

Thanks,

Edward

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#2

Steven Antonucci

Hijack: I made a funnel with the the middle knife

steven antonucci

progress, I suppose- no chuck ripping, blank flying mess, but nowhere near the area I thought I was cutting...

Frustrating with a capital F.

S

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#3

Re: Hijack: I made a funnel with the the middle kn

Barry Irby

Steve, I am not an expert on this, but I struggled with it like most of us. I made an aiming device that allows me to see where the knife is going to go.

First, be sure your knives are properly shaped. Draw a series of circles on a piece of paper or cardboard so that the concentric circles are about half an inch apart. Lay your lives on the the pattern and see if the knife will sit flat and stay "between the Lines". The knife should be a smooth (fair) curve that is a segment of a circle. One of mine was correct but the other two were clearly sections of ellipses. Had to bend them. Made a huge difference.

Now, tighten the set screw on your post so that the head does not swivel on the post.

My Aimer is a piece of clear plastic sheet. Its about six inches by thirteen. (It was a scrap) It has a line bisecting it into two "squares". I clamp the long side in the chuck so that the line represents a continuation of the shaft. Just put it between two of the jaws, not in them. There is another line perpendicular to the first that is about half and inch from the face of the jaws. This represents the inside of the bottom of the bowl. With an erasable marker draw on the dimensions of the exterior of the blank All you need is the diameter and the depth. Bring up the tool post and set it so that the knife runs between two of the posts but also runs against two. The two posts serve as a "straight edge" and by keeping the knife against them, you can aim it. It will predictably slide along the posts and the tip will go to the same place along the same line every time. So, Slide the post toward the tailstock until the tip is about to enter the "bowl". Slide the banjo in and out to position the tip whatever distance you want from the outer perimeter.Then rotate the post so that the knife slides in and comes to the center line where the inside of the "bottom" of the bowl should be. Lock the banjo and the post. Remove the plastic liner and install the blank. You can leave the post locked, draw a line on the ways to locate the banjo, move it out of the way and then put it back. This is much easier to do than to describe and if I weren't so lazy I would go take a picture of it. I have a sleeve that goes on the shaft of the tool post that sets the height so that the tip arrives at the center of the bowl. Its a piece of a plastic pluming coupling I cut to the right length and removed the interior rib. This makes all this sliding and pivoting easier.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#4

Re: Hijack: I made a funnel with the the middle kn

Carole Valentine

Dang, Barry! If I had to go through all that every time I used the system to core a bowl, I would just say forget it! LOL I just look down on the mounted blank, lay a blade on top and if that one doesn't follow the curve I want for the core I pick another one. While I'm looking, I note the approximate angle of entry I need . Works for me.

To answer the original question, personally I set the blade so the TIP (point) it is just a hair above center at the end of travel. When you set it, be sure you have the blade pulled up against the top of the restraining yoke.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#5

Re: Hijack: I made a funnel with the the middle kn

D. Hansen

I do as both the previous responders. Tip just a bit above or at center using a piece of pvc as spacer for further coring. Also one of the videos probably Mahoney (sp) is to enter the blank perpendicular (90 degrees) to the face of the blank. That sometimes requires shifting of the post later on.

To see where your knife is and has gone remember that the tip is an extension of the center line of the handle that is unless it has been bent. I bent a piece of 1/2"X 1/8" aluminum bar at 90 degrees. One leg is the length from the front of the handle to the tip. The other leg is the max height of my lathe swing. When I want to see where the tip is I place the "height" leg against the face of the handle where the knife goes in the measuring leg then is at the tip of the blade.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#6

Steven Antonucci

Horrifically deeper than I site?

steven antonucci

Casting aside from past issue getting the bent knives to work at all, I am struggling with the placement of the gate post. I basically put it about an inch or so from the blank to allow the knife to enter the cut perpendicular to the wood.

I am siting the tragectory by looking down on the blank with the knife above the bowl blank and positioned as if it was at the end of the blade. When I sited this last one, I thought I would have a 2" bottom. Instead, I had a hole that went into my tenon...

McNaughton really needs to include better instructions on usage with the tool. Even if it wasn't anything more than a URL pointing to their website, I'd be happy.

Steve

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#7

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

robo hippy

On larger bowls, in the 12 to 14 range, I have the tip as much as 1/2 inch above center. By the time you get to the center of the core, you will be close to center height. There is a lot of play/flex in this system, so if you start at exact center, you will be below center by the time you get there. So, before you mount (I never do this because it is one of those things I do like adjusting speeds) you can put the knife in the tool rest as far as it will go, and lift up on the handle to see where you are height wise. I do use a stop collar on the tool rest as well.

Try to remove the stub that is left when the core breaks out. You will be amazed at how much the blade moves.

As to aiming, I cheat and use the laser. Most of the time I am pretty close, but the laser lets me know if I need to correct. Before I had it, I would put the tool rest/gates in place, and hold the blade/handle up over the gate and bowl to help me aim. Then most of the time, I would aim a bit shallow.

I seldom enter the wood at 90 degrees, it depends on the bowl curve and the blade Small curve, almost all the time, medium curve blade which I use the most, almost never. It doesn't make much difference. I do grind the tips down square as I don't really like the spear points, and it makes the cutting surface smaller.

As to figuring out where you are by remembering the tip is in line with the blade, It is always pointing to the center of the bowl, but for me figuring out if I am above or below the bottom of the bowl was the hard part. Laser is much easier.

robo hippy

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#8

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

adrien

As an expert funnel maker, it seems to me the important issue is not the height of the tool, but the angle at which it approaches the wood.

If it points toward the outside of the piece at entry, you gets a funnel. It's gotta be pointing towards the center.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#9

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

robo hippy

A couple more things here.

Kel has been told by many that his instructions are at best rather sparse. This has been going on for 10 years that I know.

One problem with using this system is that it tends to drift to the outside of the cut as you go in. I used to think that this was just the nature of the system. In part it could be blamed on the longer blades which have more flex than the Oneway or Woodcut systems. I also used to think that in part it was because it isn't on a fixed pivoting center. While those factors may add to the problem, I think it has more to do with the blades themselves. They are stamped rather than cut from round stock. If you lay them out on a circle index thing (the plastic ones from Craft Supplies) you will notice that the bends are very inconsistent. On a little closer inspection, to me, the points seem to go straight for the last half inch or so. I would guess that this is because the point isn't in the form when the blade is stamped. If you tweak it in slightly (I have my gates/support fingers locked down tight, but the support T still rotates) it will cut fairly true. I still aim for more shallow rather than perfect most of the time.

The drifting is the major cause of the blade binding in the cut, and having to open up the cut more. The other cause is shavings clogging up the kerf. I did notice that my square tipped blades eject the shavings a lot better than the spear point.

One point where Mike Mahoney and I differ in our teaching approaches is that he feels that a turner should be able to feel and see where the blade is going. I think that there are a rare few who can do this, and most of us won't ever get that sensitive. That is why I advocate the laser pointer. McNaughton makes one. It mounts on the set screws for the blade which I didn't like, so I had mine welded to the handle. Randy Privet of Monster tools makes one as well. It lets you know exactly where you are, so if you are going too deep or too shallow, you can correct before you get all the way in. For a while after I got it, I depended on it to show me where I was. Now, it is more for assurance as my aim has gotten a lot better. You can also, if you have the laser set up, use the Kelton hollowing blades in the handle with the laser, this is free hand rather than a captures system, and I like the Kelton hollowers for roughing my hollow forms. You will need inserts if you want to use all of the hollowers.

You can start with the tool rest back a bit from the bowl, but I have it at a point where I hope to core all the way in without having to move the tool rest. The blade may twist a small bit, but only briefly, and it is some thing that if you are not used to it, it is a bit scary, but I don't even notice it any more.

robo hippy

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#10

Steven Antonucci

Should the core "finish" at the back of the blade?

steven antonucci

Interesting point on the flexing. I assume you start high and then get to center, but I wonder if I could start on center, and then come up a bit (lathe off, of course) about 1/2 way through?

I feel a coring session coming on with my new found knowledge!

S

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#11

Steven Antonucci

How do you use the laser if the knife deforms?

steven antonucci

just wondering how that works, since the laser won't deform with it? can you also post the grind on the square tip? I think I get it, but before I go messing with stuff...

S

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#12

Re: How do you use the laser if the knife deforms?

robo hippy

Steve,

One, you can start at center, go part way in, then raise the tool rest. I prefer to set it at final height and go from there, rather than adjust as I go. On small bowls it doesn't make much difference. On bigger bowls, if you start at center height, you will be below center height when you get to the bottom, and we all know how scrapers react if you have a catch while working below center on the inside of bowls, and all coring tools cut as scrapers. Also consider that the blade is vertical, and the kerf being round, if you are below center, the blade will bind on top and bottom as it tries to fit into the curve, and the curve is a lot smaller at the bottom of the bowl.

If your blades have deformed, which can be caused by a major catch, and/or by heavy use, it is a twisting bend. Grip the handle end in a vise, and get a big Crescent/adjustable wrench, or monkey wrench, and apply torque in the opposite direction. It will bend back into shape. Lay it on a flat surface (I knew the table saw was good for some thing) to see if it still rocks, and adjust more as needed.

I am not skilled enough on computers to post pictures, or even take pictures (another 'round2it' project). The tip is like the top of a triangle. I grind the tip down to the base. The spear point was Mike Mahoney's idea. It is best suited if you want to cut a blank totally out of the bowl. This is most important when coring burl, end grain, or crotch wood as the fibers don't run straight, and if you try to break it out, you can rip through the bottom, even if it is over 1/2 inch thick. Been there, done that, more than once. One thing that helps you cut it all the way off is to be at center height when you get to the bottom. With experience, you can feel when you are below center. You can raise the tool rest. For me, grinding the tip off square reduces the shaving size from 1/2 inch plus down to 3/8 inch. I did hear Greg Jenson (US Kelton rep) talking about how the spear point folds the shaving in half and it easily ejects from the kerf. Well, it is Murphy's law for me as they open up for me and clog it up a lot faster.

robo hippy

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#13

Thanks

Bartimmo

Robo Hippy - Thanks for the recommendations and details. It is always the little nuiassense that make the difference. These are the things we do without thought after some experience finding what works best. For a newbie these are gold.

During my first coring I was using the medium kerf blade, which I was unable to get it to fit into the middle gate on the tool post. I ended up using it in the large gate. It sure looked easy on the videos... It wasn't until I brought out the small kerf blade to core the last bowl that I had a relatively easy core and realized exactly how it should work and feel. The outside (left side) of the medium kerf blade was slightly concave so that at the top and bottom edges were binding against the gate. A couple of quick passes over the belt sander and the problem was eliminated.

Edward

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#14

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

Carole Valentine

Actually, I found the "Guide to Coring" instructions that came with the Mark 8 system to be pretty comprehensive. I just went back and read them again and that is pretty much how I do my coring and I have no problem, except with the occasional nasty piece of wood. There seems to be much more detail than there was in the instructions with the original coring system. It goes through each step: assembly, blank prep, setting up the post and knife, aiming and then the actual coring. Probably the biggest thing for me when I was learning was the discovery that I needed to just relax and let the tool do the work. It doesn't need to be forced (in fact sometimes you may need to hold it back a bit.) And trying to force it to take a curve that you did not set up properly at the start will certainly lead to difficulties. I have found the system to work beautifully, as designed, with no modifications. And the more you do it, the better you get at aiming so as to get exactly what you want out of a blank.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#15

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

Jeff Willaford

When I first started coring a few months ago I thought there was something missing from the instructions as I had varied success/failure. I scoured the forums and purchased Mahoney's video and also Robo-Hippy's video. I even called Steve Russell with questions about coring. Everything I found or saw basically echoed the Kelton instructions for sighting and for use or technique each with their own personal touches. That was when I realized there was nothing wrong with the instructions that came with the tools....I was dealing with the dreaded 'operator error' a.k.a. 'learning curve'.

Then I fell back on what I think of as two of the basic rules of turning... (1) If the tool isn't sharp...forgetaboutit... and (2) Life's too short to turn crappy wood. (Thanks John Jordan).

I made sure my blades were sharp by trial and I discarded the idea of 'practice wood' and went to the good stuff. Coring is now a much smoother process and my aim is improving. A laser helps me with that but is still just a reference.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#16

Re: How do you use the laser if the knife deforms?

George Van Beynen

Robo, do you use the laser in the vertical position as Craft Supply shows or horizontal, parallel to the toolrest?

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#17

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

Dick Strauss

The quality of the McNaughton coring system is a little disappointing IMO. I've run into several manufacturing problems. The knives don't follow a curve (as pointed out by Reed). The knives are also not manufactured to the same thickness. One knife actually fits nicely in between the turret posts, while the other two knives in the set are thinner by up to 0.020" (depending on the area of the knife). This doesn't sound like much but the thinner knives can shift from side to side and twist in the between the posts. I have to wrap the posts with shim stock every time I want to use these knives. Unfortunately Greg Jensen and KM didn't respond to about a half dozen attempts to remedy the situation years ago.

This system was purchased several (maybe 3-4) years ago. I hope that McNaughton has fixed some of these issues with their current production.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#18

Inexpenaive laser and my success

Ed Larson

The picture below shows an inexpensive laser that I made for the McNaughton system. I also show a drawing that I made to help guide me in coring the blank. I used the sharpest curved blade for all cuts but the entry angle was different for each cut as depicted by the black arrows in the lower left of the drawing. I also drew lines on the blank showing the approximate bottom of the bowls. The laser and the drawing were very helpful in making a succesful core and getting me up the learning curve.

After the experience shown in the pictures, I've succesfully cored four blanks in the last two days using the laser as a guide primarily to judge the depth of the knife, I did not need to make the drawing though. Some keys steps for me: Sharp knives, banjo at an angle to the ways (not perpendicular) to get more griping surface, clear chips offen, slow feeding of knife.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#19

Re: How do you use the laser if the knife deforms?

robo hippy

I use the laser in the vertical position. Never thought to use it in the horizontal position. The photo in the Craft Supplies catalog actually show it set up wrong, unless they corrected it. The bracket is made to sit off to the side, and the vertical post can be adjusted up and down depending on the size of the bowl you are coring. I found it more convenient to have the bracket welded to the top of the handle, and cut the vertical post to maximum height of what I would ever core.

robo hippy

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#20

McN Coring Mark 8 Instructions  **Link**

Dick Strauss

For those interested, here are the Mark 8 instructions:

http://www.kelton.co.nz/browsers/mcnatn_sys_m8_guide.pdf

Keep in mind that your system may not have all the same components on the turret head. However, the instructions do seem to be much better than those supplied previously.

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#21

Ellis Walentine

Dick, please create a profile...

Ellis Walentine

... so you can post links here without moderation. Read the FAQ files so you understand how it all works.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#22

Re: How do you use the laser if the knife deforms?

George Van Beynen

Thanks Reed!

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

#23

Re: Robo Hippy - Coring Question

robo hippy

I will post more about this on a new thread later, but am very tired now, and have the local Saturday Market to do tomorrow, it isn't supposed to rain. Kel called me up and we chatted. I did check out his new instructions, and they are a big improvement over the old ones I got 10 or more years ago.

Got to sleep now, not even going to play the guitar tonight. Well, not much.

robo hippy