Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

Posts

The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

#1

The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

charlie belden

There are pieces that written words and still photographs can't adequately convey to a reader or a viewer of a photograph or two.

Three examples of this shortcoming I've encountered are:

- pieces with actual movement

- pieces that make sounds

- pieces with subtle/nuanced "surface treatments"

It's the latter I've just come acrossed - with laser pyrography.

Of the other types of pyrography I'm aware of, the most subtle/nuanced use is being utilized by carvers, specifically bird decoy carvers. These folks do amazing shading by controlling scortching and fine line cross hatching and fine parallel pyroed lines to accentuate actual low relief carving, or creating the illusion of depth that isn't actually there. Other forms of pyrography are used to either texture surfaces or outline shapes on a surface. All of these techniques are limited ultimately by the scale at which the pyro tool can effectively discolor (char) or remove (vaporize) wood.

A laser "pyro tool" on the other hand has the ability to work at 0.003" diameter scale, about 1/256ths of an inch. AND its depth of cut/burn can be controlled to the same amount of precision/"fineness". With this tool, surface treatments and designs can be done on/in wood which can only be seen with the piece in hand, and the light bouncing off the surface at just the right angle. You have to get close and either move the piece, your eyes' vantage point or the light source to see what is, in fact, there.

With photos, you can effectively hide some scratches and minor imperfections - and that�s kind of handy ; ). But with fine details - you WANT people to see - there�s a problem. If you show a close up detail picture, you lose the context of the detail area. If you show the whole piece - you don�t see the details. In order to get the whole effect of the piece you have to have it in your hand, or be close enough and able to move around it - if you can�t actually pick it up.

Early solutions to these shortcoming are in their infancy - YouTube videos, with sound, 3D scanner, 3D virtual pieces, free software to create or just view virtual pieces, 3D �printers� that can make actual 3D models - you can hold In your hand and look at - and play with. The tools are here, some still primitive, some unafforable - yet.

We live in interesting times - especially for folks with what are now considered Wild Hare Ideas.

Are YOU doing things that can�t be adequately experiences using words and still pictures?

Have YOU found ways around the �normal� methods of showing your work - on the net?

Care to share?

Re: The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

#2

Re: The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

fgvanatta

The simplest example of what "words and pictures" can't convey - one that we can all relate to - is a simple turning, like a bowl or vase. Pictures can't adequately convey the "feel" - heft, surface texture, whatever - of one of these pieces.

A good reason why many turnings can't really be appreciated unless you can actually hold them in your hands.

Frank

Re: The Shortcomings of Words & Pictures

#3

And THAT's a Catch 22

charlie belden

I left out the tactile and heft (or unexpectedly light) qualities of the piece - which require holding it to experience. But there's a Catch 22 with having people handle the piece - the possibility of damaging it, or its finish. Some pieces have to be Look But Don't Touch - Andie Wolfe and J. Paul Fennell for example. Pieces with multiple, come apart, come apart parts and things with highly polished finishes are also examples of Look But Don't Touch.

What I'd like to have is something that would let you see and maybe hear the piece - without actually touching it. Feeling the piece - without touching it - I suspect there are ways of doing that as well - though never providing actual hands on sensations.

I like to make, and play with, pieces that are intended to be handled. Making that a design criteria may cut down on possibilities - but the trade off is something I can live with in the stuff I do.

More examples - and ways around limitatins?