Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

legal advice

Posts

legal advice

#1

legal advice

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

I have been invited to demonstrate wood turning at a local city arts and crafts fair. I was happy to do it until I received a contract from the city hosting the event which asks me to sign that I would be held liable for any injury or damage of any kind that could be related to my demonstration. The contract is extremely one-sided and holds me responsible for just about anything and leaves the city totally harmless no matter what. I called about it and explained that wood turning is inherently dangerous and that I didn't particularly care to be responsible in the event that something goes wrong and some kid looses and eye! I was told that the city would not alter their contract in any way but that it would set up safety barriers and the like to minimize the risk. I'm of thinking to tell them NO WAY, but I know that others have done it and the risk is small. What do you think?

Re: legal advice

#2

I wouldn't touch it ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

with a 10 foot pole. I don't like "oneway" streets.

Ed

Re: legal advice

#3

Run Far, Run Fast!!!!

Dave (PacNW)

Re: legal advice

#4

Bill Blasic

Re: legal advice

Bill Blasic

Eliot,

It is not a risk worth taking! If your serious or excited about demoing look into some liability insurance. I pay around a $150 a year. I also have a Lexan shield in front of the lathe and the optimum word there is Lexan (Our club had a near miss using plexiglass). I usually do a lot of tops when demoing and the looks on the faces of the kids when given a top is instant payment on that insurance policy.

Bill

Re: legal advice

#5

Re: legal advice

rick pixley

I'd make it a club sponsored event..Then you'd probably be covered under the aaw...

Rick

Re: legal advice

#6

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

even with an 8 foot Hungarian!!

What has been described is a "strict liability" deal so if the hypothetical injury is not actually caused by the turner, but occurs merely because the demonstration is taking place, he's liable. Like if the defective "safety barrier" collapses onto a kid in a stroller leaving it with permanent spinal cord injury and a quadriplegic for life. The contract, if you read to the end will require the turner to have insurance in a significant amount which will also include the municipality as an "additional insured" making the policyholder responsible for the town's attorney's fees and defense costs when the child's appointed law guardian sues.

Such an insurance policy could easily cost 4 or 5 figures if you could find a company to write it.

Re: legal advice

#7

Re: legal advice

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Eliot, I have an insurance policy for my business that covers, among lots of other things, work at other sites other than my primary place of business. Even with that, I would not care to test it against something like this contract from the city. You have limited resources, the city has the resources of all its taxpayers. Maryland is a virtual police state compared to some of your neighbors, so if something were to happen, it is going to be Eliot all by himself against a stacked government. I add my voice to "I wouldn't do it", and that comes from demonstrating for 15 years now without a single injury to me or anyone else.

Re: legal advice

#8

Steven Antonucci

What's your upside?

steven antonucci

So you have been invited to demonstrate-what's in it for you? I've done stuff like this in the past, and I've never been paid for it. While there is very little risk of something horrible happening if you are a competent turner and manage the risk properly, what do you stand to gain by doing it?

Politely declining is always an option...

S

Re: legal advice

#9

Re: What's your upside?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

Well, the sentiment here is to stay away, and I will. But they are offering me $300 for the three hour demo. I honestly don't do these things for the money , and I will miss turning the tops , etc. and giving the stuff to the kids. You see, I have done this sort of thing before; the difference is that this time I got this onerous contract in the mail from the city of Rockville, Md.

Re: legal advice

#10

Question for legal beagles

Ray - Middletown, IN

If you are there by their invitation and they are sponsoring the event how can they refuse to accept any responsibility? Of course the old adage kicks in "you can't fight city hall".

Ray

Re: legal advice

#11

I'm no legal expert....

Barry Irby

don't play one on tv and probably don't qualify as a beagle let alone a legal one, but it does seem that since you are there at their invitation and it their event, you should be covered by their insurance. I think they are trying to squirm out of covering you and your fellow demonstrators and make you double up on their coverage. I still would not touch it with a 20 foot pole. (A 20' pole is what you use for not touching something you wouldn't touch with a ten foot pole, twice.)

Re: legal advice

#12

Re: Question for legal beagles

Bill Howatt

Your question makes a lot of sense. Unfortunately, it could cost a lot of cents from your pocket to argue the position in court if necessary.

IMO, the legal system is another system that is great in theory but the reality is without deep pockets you are at a major disadvantage no matter how right you are.

Bill

Re: legal advice

#13

Steven Antonucci

Keep the lathe speed down and go for it!

steven antonucci

Since they are paying you for it, you can do it with minimal risk. (probably should be doing that was anyhow...)

Keep the lathe sped down, and the wood small and you've got almost nothing to worry about. I turn with 4 kids running through the shop all day long, and I am super cognizant of the fact that the risks are minimal because I have developed enough skill to avoid most situations.

If you are smart about what you do, why miss the payday? May also be a way to pick up a commission or two...

Steve

Re: legal advice

#14

Dick Hines

Re: I'm no legal expert....

Dick Hines

Don't let the door on your way out. Just say NO!!!!

Re: legal advice

#15

Re: legal advice

Bernie Weishapl

I had that happen to me. Same type of paperwork where I assumed everything but they were the ones putting on the show. So I asked my lawyer about it. He told me why don't you just put one bullet in a gun and spin it. My lawyer drew up some similar paperwork and told me to see if they would sign mine. I took it down and told them they much sign mine and then I would sign theirs. That was the end of the discussion.

Re: legal advice

#16

Re: legal advice

eliot d

Thanks to everyone. I just called and said I would not do it. Actually, I said that I would if they took out that legal clause; but I know they won't. It would probably be fun to ask THEM to sign up to what they are asking me to sign and to suggest that they then do what they feel is necessary to minimize the risk. But who needs all that hassle?

Re: legal advice

#17

Re: legal advice

Larry In Lima

Run, don't walk. I can't see that this benefits you - at all. All liability - and a lawsuit waiting to happen. Don't do it. FWIW

Re: legal advice

#18

Re: legal advice

Peter Lamb

As a former trial lawyer and long time turner my view would be if you can't figure out a safe way to do a demonstration then you probably should not do it. On the other hand I have done many a demo without injury or insurance.

Peter

Re: legal advice

#19

Re: legal advice

Bill Hale The Wood Spinner

Peter

Are you set up as a Corp, LLC or any other protection? I just did an LLC andwas told that would give me personal protection. The Corp has little assets.

Re: legal advice

#20

Re: legal advice

Peter Lamb

Bill,

No LLC no corp. As a defense lawyer most of my legal life I don't think it helps much. If someone gets hurt some darn plaintiffs lawyer may sue all in sight the LLC and its principal. The real answer is to be super careful and don't run the lathe very fast. That way there is little energy to hurt anyone!

Peter

Re: legal advice

#21

Just be broke like me- who's going to sue me ?

John Lucas

There wouldn't be any profit in it. :) I had a good friend who taught Rock Climbing (and was the one who got me into it). Someone asked him if he had insurance. His reply was like mine, He said, sure they can sue, what are they gonna get, my backpack and shoes.

Re: legal advice

#22

Re: Just be broke like me- who's going to sue me ?

Peter Lamb

I'm with you John!!

Re: legal advice

#23

Re: Just be broke like me- who's going to sue me ?

Russ Fairfield

John, you aren't as penniless as you think. If you lose, the injured party and the lawyers can take everything you own, your house, your vehicles, all of your tools, cameras, and most of your paycheck.

Re: legal advice

#24

Russ    All they would get are the bills 

john lucas

Re: legal advice

#25

Mike Stafford

Can't get blood out of a turnip.....

Mike Stafford