Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Poly Fill test

Posts

Poly Fill test

#1

Poly Fill test

john lucas

Bill Hale sent some polyfill for me to try out. I did a quick test yesterday and filled crack in a dried cherry rough out. It's interesting stuff. It is black. It mixes water thin but starts to thicken in about 45 seconds so you need to work fast. I wasn't sure how long to wait until turning so I waited overnight.

It seems to turn easily and filled the V crack all the way to the bottom.

I am running a test on it tonight. I took some flat boards and spaced them about 3/8" apart and filled the gap with the Polyfil and another with thickened west system epoxy and another one with 5 minute epoxy. Tomorrow I'll plane and sand them down flush to see how they work with cutting and sanding tools. Then I'll try to flex the boards to see if any of the 3 have any flex. Then I'll break them apart to see how strong each one is. Maybe I'll learn something from that. I'll at least have a comparison.

Re: Poly Fill test

#2

Re: Poly Fill test

Carole Valentine

John, while you are at it, take note as to whether any bubbles form in the poly (like they sometimes do in epoxy) and how well it buffs and finishes.

Re: Poly Fill test

#3

Re: Poly Fill test

John Lucas

Carole That's #1 on my list. This patch was kind of small. There is a small area that doesn't look like a bubble but more of a crack, almost like it opened up while drying. It is not as hard as epoxy but so far doesn't seem to polish up to the same shine. I'll have to try more to really understand it. It pours much thinner than some epoxies (West Systems with no thickener is as thin) but it starts hardening faster than 5 minute epoxy or Inlace. It doesn't seem like it bubbles as bad as Inlace but I'll know more later.

Here is the cherry bowl that I patched with it. I still have more finishing to do on the bowl but wanted to get a quick shot of it to show the patch.


Re: Poly Fill test

#4

Re: Poly Fill test

Carole Valentine

Bowl is nice. When you finish it, how about a macro shot of the filled area?

Re: Poly Fill test

#5

Re: Poly Fill test

Texian

Anxiously awaiting your test results. And where can I get some of this stuff? Sounds like a good product.

Re: Poly Fill test

#6

Re: Poly Fill test

Bill Hale The Wood Spinner

Hi John

Thanks for doing the testing. You can sand in a couple of hours no problem I am hoping to have some testing information on the clear, colorable , this afternoon. Poly Fill should flex better than epoxy or CA I think. The testing information showed great bonding an a med flex. This should be great for bonding mixed woods. I am going to try making a thin laminated cane. I made the samples large so people would share and try some off the wall stuff along with just filling. Take some to your next turners meeting

Again thanks for the testing and reporting on my Poly Fill

I still have some samples so send me your Name, Address and I will ship to you.

Re: Poly Fill test

#7

preliminary tests

john lucas

This is interesting stuff. It cuts kind of like a cross between plastic and rubber when using a carving tool. It doesn't feel as hard as plastic but it polishes up to as much shine as you want. It sands well but differently than epoxy. Epoxy is harder than wood and will often be proud of wood when you sand if you use a soft pad. The polyfil seems like it's softer, at least when you sand it. It sands sort of like Cocobolo for lack of a better description.

It doesn't bond as good to plywood as epoxy does. I could not tell how flexible it is. I made my test pieces too thick. It turns well but only with very sharp tools. Scraping seemed to work well but not as well as epoxy. I tried threading it just to see. Epoxy took a good thread, polyfill didn't. This tells me it's a little softer.

More testing will come as time allows. I don't have any Inlace to test it against. I'll get some and build a bowl to test all 3 fillers when I have time.