Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Replicating a shape

Posts

Replicating a shape

#1

MrRules

Replicating a shape

MrRules

I recently purchased some "Corn Holders" from PSI and tried to turn handles to insert the holders. I had great difficulty making the two holders the same even with the use of calibers. What methods do you experts use to replicate a shape? This is a pretty simple project but looks a little goofy when the handles don't match.

Stu

Re: Replicating a shape

#2

Re: Replicating a shape

George Guadiane

A man is sitting on a New York City street corner playing his guitar when a stranger comes up and asks, "How do you get to Carnegie Hall?"

Looking up briefly from his guitar, he replies, "Practice, man, practice."

That is what the experts do, and what we less than experts do.

When you can turn three or four in a row that are acceptable (not perfect), you will have improved your turning skills by a significant amount.

I thought I was a pretty good turner a couple of years ago and an antique restoration guy asked me to make 13 pieces to replace missing decorations on a screen door. one smal round bead and one long tapered bead. Michelangelo probably spent less energy carving David... But I got it done well enough to get paid, but still not to my satisfaction. It made me a better more patient more humble turner.

You picked a good project, I hope you have great success!

Re: Replicating a shape

#3

Re: Replicating a shape

Carole Valentine

Stu, don't know how complicated your handles are, but in the past I have made half-profile templates out of cardboard or thin plywood to replicate spindles. Draw lines on you workpiece to indicate peaks and valleys (beads and coves) and go from there. It does take practice. Personally I sort of have to sneak up on it, taking very fine cuts when I start getting close to profile.

Re: Replicating a shape

#4

Re: Replicating a shape

Barry Irby

George and Carol are right. Practice, Practice, Practice. Sneak up on it. Use patterns. I made up a phrase, Every piece is a practice piece for the next piece, but EPIAPPFTNP does not have exactly the same impact a DAMHIKT.

Figure out what you want the handles to look like and make patterns. Then make a bunch of them. Make more than you need. Pair them up. You could make them of different woods and then pick a pair of each. That way if the different pairs don't match, it won't matter much. In fact they could be very different and look great.

Another thought is to not make any of them match at all. Go for contrast.

Also, don't be afraid to leave the ends on them so that you can put them back on the lathe. That way you can turn one, try to turn its mate and if you must, put the first one back on the lathe and return it to match the second one. Once you get them nicely done, part off all the ends at once.

Re: Replicating a shape

#5

Steven Antonucci

I'd have fun with it

steven antonucci

Personally, I couldn't make 2 of the same thing if I tried. I could get close, but I'd always know.

Why not make them entirely different so it doesn't matter? They could relate, but in an ecclectic way?

Otherwise, you need to make 100 to make 10 that match...

S

Re: Replicating a shape

#6

MrRules

Re: I'd have fun with it

MrRules

Sometimes as you are in the process of asking a question the answer seems to come to you. I was thinking about templates, even kept some pieces of cardboard for such a task, and I even thought about shaping them in pairs before parting off. The practice, practice, practice part is something I always think about and I think I am getting better but my eye doesn't seem to want to make duplicate shapes. I have had better luck making salt and pepper mills that have similar shapes but have never tried to make duplicate shapes. I will get back to the practice mode but I also like Steven's idea of making them all different. The idea is to get a set of functional corn holders so the matching part has no significance. Thanks for the replies and suggestions. I have visited many boards but this seems to be the busiest and best for good suggestions. Thanks again.

Stu

Re: Replicating a shape

#7

Re: Replicating a shape

Keith T

I would suggest drawing the profile on heavy stock, then cutting it out. Use this as a gauge to shape each piece. Use calipers for determining the critical dimensions, then use the gauge to determine final shape.

Re: Replicating a shape

#8

Re: Replicating a shape

John Jordan

Get really big ears of corn, and they'll be so far apart it won't matter. :)

As already suggested, practice. You should not need templates or such.

John

Re: Replicating a shape

#9

Re: Replicating a shape

Doc Green

What I've found helpful is to mount the original next to the blank I'm working on so that a side-by-side comparison can be made with minimal eye movement. My understanding is that this is a common practice used by folks who must make a lot of duplicates. In fact, the Mustard Monster has built-in mounts to hold a long spindle for this purpose.

What I'm trying to say: Mount the blank on the lathe, perhaps between centers. Then rig up a fixture to hold the original right beside the blank, on the side opposite the tool rest.

My rule: If it looks right, it is right. Forget the calipers.

Hope this is clear. ~Doc

Re: Replicating a shape

#10

Re: Replicating a shape

Russ Fairfield

Maybne you should be using calipers instead of "calibers". (smile)

Seriously, turning two of anything takes practice, and some folks will never get it right. Meanwhile, you can make a template as Carole suggested, rought turn the wood with whatever you are using, and finesse the shape with a small scraper and sandpaper.

The other option is don't worry about them being matching pairs, or in a set of anything. Make the differences obvious and nobody will see them as a mistake. I remember an Andy Rooney dining table that had 4 different legs.

Re: Replicating a shape

#11

Re: Replicating a shape

Texian

Had a very similar experience George. The customer needed 3 "copies" of the original. I made 5 pieces, 4 of which were pretty close. The customer seemed extremely pleased and more than willing to pay, even though I could see the small differences among the pieces. Gave them all five for the quoted price for three, so they could pick the ones they preferred. Just copied with pencil marks and dial calipers.

Re: Replicating a shape

#12

Re: Replicating a shape

John Lucas

I use Keith's method. I do a lot of duplicates for antique furniture and even though I can get really close with calipers and my eyeball I find a cut out pattern really helps fine tune the shapes. I can set it on the piece and see exactly where it's off. I found this much handier when my turning skills weren't there. With a skew on it's side I could duplicate almost anything. These days I use the skew or spindle gouge in the normal mode and cut to the line.

Re: Replicating a shape

#13

Re: Replicating a shape

John K Jordan

If you make a profile drawing with a dark marker on a piece of heavy white paper or card stock and mount it close behind the work, you can stand back, close one eye and get the profiles to match very closely. Of course, you still need calipers to get the base diameter right.

I have also cut out a template from card stock and held it up to the turning when the profile was critical, as in these face profile mugs. I actually made two templates (neither shown in the photo) - one a tiny bit larger and less detailed to get the shape close, the other the exact shape.


JKJ