Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Attempt at black

Posts

Attempt at black

#1

Attempt at black

Carole Valentine

My latest attempt at an all black piece. I have a new appreciation and awe of people who can get a perfect black finish on a piece and then photograph it to boot! Not only is it hard to photograph, but I am amazed at the finish imperfections a camera will bring out on an all black piece that I cannot see when I am looking at it in hand! Maybe the next time I should try photographing in between coats of finish. Holly, black gesso and Krylon Matte finish. Camera angle's a little high...sorry bout that.


Re: Attempt at black

#2

Re: Attempt at black

Molly Winton

What a beautiful piece Carole. The finish is lovely. Photographing black is very difficult, especially smooth black.

Re: Attempt at black

#3

Beautiful!!

Gil Jones

Re: Attempt at black

#4

Re: Attempt at black

John Jordan

Carole, that looks good-a nice piece. Did it look bad to you when you first dyed it? They usually look pretty patchy and awful before the finish. You can use 4/0 steel wool and then rub it with a paper towel, or just the towel-each will be a little different. If you don't like the look, just spray another coat. I almost always rub with the Bounty towel, I like the look of it.

I've done a couple of black pieces this week. Try photographing it with a white piece next to it.

John

Re: Attempt at black

#5

Re: Attempt at black

Jeff Willaford

Attempt ? I'd say success and a great success at that.

Re: Attempt at black

#6

Re: Attempt at black

Carole Valentine

Thanks Molly, Gil and Jeff.

John, It looked pretty bad after the first coat! My first thought was "Well another one for the burn barrel!" LOL I did not thin the gesso enough and had some brush marks. I thought I had gotten rid of all of them with 6/0 steel wool and another coat of thinner gesso, but the camera glaringly disagreed with me. I don't have anything to spray dye with so that's not an option for me unless I use a can of something. My camera would go apoplectic on me if I tried to shoot a white piece and a black piece together!

Re: Attempt at black

#7

Re: Attempt at black

charlie belden

A successful attempt I'd say. And the photographer's pretty good too!

What I saw is a nice ceramic vase, somehow glazed to an almost semi gloss gun metal gray black, and am interesting pattern carved or sculpted into it.

Then the wood turner's eye looked at the piece and thought - judging from what I can see, the walls of the piece seem quite thick. But the ceramic look popped my eye back in that direction - and it then would look strange if the part I could see - and by implication - why I could not see - were thinned down to 1/8" or so.

But the turner's mind wondered if the piece would crack since the walls seem too thick. And if the walls were thinned down to 1/8" - the piece wouldn't look right.

But being a ceramics piece . . .

Interesting - and a very nice little ceramic vase - with a really interesting "glaze".

And the photography is quite good either way.

Re: Attempt at black

#8

Re: Attempt at black

Carole Valentine

Actually, the walls are just a hair over 1/8". The carving was an after thought so I had to be extremely careful not to go too deep and go through the wall. It was a bit nerve wracking.

Re: Attempt at black

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Attempt at black

Steve Kubien

My goodness, this is just beautiful. It looks, I don't know, soft, like it wants to be picked up. Yummy.

As for the black, you could try India ink as it is very thin to begin with. I have had zero overlapping marks with it. India ink will raise the grain so after knocking it back down you may have to dye it again. Rubber gloves are a must with India ink!

Splendid stuff!

Steve

Re: Attempt at black

#10

Re: Attempt at black

Texian

Beautifully successful attempt Carole. And can not guess the size.

Re: Attempt at black

#11

5 1/2" high

Carole Valentine

Thanks. Should have stated the size.

Re: Attempt at black

#12

Get Out!!!

Jennifer Indy.USA

Carole this is so dang sweet! It's beautiful!

Love it, Love it!

Jen

Re: Attempt at black

#13

Re: Attempt at black

charlie belden

Undercutting the rim must've been "fun" if the walls are 1/8". THAT would take some turning talent and skills - and guts.

Nicely done!

Re: Attempt at black

#14

Re: 5 1/2" high

Texian

Thanks Carole. Just found it on that other forum. Very pretty piece. Makes me want to buy some flat black paint, but I can't carve.

Re: Attempt at black

#15

Re: 5 1/2" high

fgvanatta

I think it's a very striking piece - and well photographed.

Frank

Re: Attempt at black

#16

Really awesome....  I love it, too!

Ruth Niles

Re: Attempt at black

#17

Re: Get Out!!!

Donna Banfield

I need to pull out my thesaurus to find words that haven't already been used! You did a fantastic job on the turning, coloring and photography, IMHO. Well done!

Re: Attempt at black

#18

Steven Antonucci

Looks pretty darn black to me?

steven antonucci

How many coats of gesso, and what did you grit did you sand the surface and the gesso to? I want to compare notes to a piece I did in white last week...

Steve

Re: Attempt at black

#19

It's your fault, Ruth!

Carole Valentine

You made me do "the next one" in black when I was considering black for the lime piece. ;)

Re: Attempt at black

#20

Re: Attempt at black

Ned Bulken

beautiful, simply beautiful.

The photograph is superb too!

Re: Attempt at black

#21

Re: It's your fault, Ruth!

Mac Ray

Very nice piece Carole,now that you have taken a nice piece of white holly and turned it black,lets see you take a piece of ebony and turn it white........the gesso is hard to get smooth enough for a finish like this....if you can find a source for the old formula that has a clay base instead of the newer acrylic base,it will sand much better.......and smoother...you wont have to fight it.......I really like this one...........good job!

Re: Attempt at black

#22

Thanks everyone

Carole Valentine

Steve, I think two coats of gesso. Don't remember the sanding sequence and I don't write those specifics down since what works for one piece may not work for another. All I can tell you is that one can cause nearly irreparable damage to gesso by using too coarse a grit. For that reason, I start on an area with a grit much higher than I think I will need until I get to the one that does the job, then complete the sanding working back up through the grits.

Re: Attempt at black

#23

Re: It's your fault, Ruth!

Carole Valentine

Mac, it was not "nice white holly". It had ugly green streaks and muddy gray all through it! I have a lot of the stuff so I will probably will be doing more black pieces. :\

Where do you get the old style gesso?

Re: Attempt at black

#24

Re: It's your fault, Ruth!

Russ Fairfield

Carole, this is a beautiful piece of work that can stand on it own anywhere alongside of the best of the best. The lines and proportions of this one are excellent, and it shows you have either been doing your homework, or you have a natural eye for the "fair curve".

Form and curvature are all important with a black piece because there is no wood grain to take our attention away from a bad line.

Do I see the beginning of a whole series? May I also suggest working with the exact opposite - white?? Whatever you do with it, it is a good theme to develop, and I encourage you to do that.

I also encourage you to get this one out to where the larger world can see it. The Instant Gallery at the AAW Symposium would be a good start. Who knows what good things might happen?

Re: Attempt at black

#25

Re: It's your fault, Ruth!

Carole Valentine

Thanks, Russ. I do have some designs for a white piece (as well as some others) milling around in my head. They are not quite formed yet though and I have found that I can't hurry them up! The ideas will be baked when they are baked and no sooner. LOL

I won't be going to the Symposium so the IG is pretty much out.