Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

Posts

I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#1

I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

GaryG in MD

but two things have come together to make me do it.

The subject is negative-rake scrapers.

I bring it up now, not only because I may end up using one on the inside of that extremely abrasive red oak bowl, but because of the Dale Nish answer in his "Ask Dale" Q/A column in the current issue of Woodturning Design.

In his reply to a question about negative-rake scrapers, Dale says to "ride the bevel"! I always thought that riding the bevel on a scraper was a real no-no that would lead to an instant catch. He says it leads to "tool control not available with a regular scraper which does not ride the bevel". I have great respect for Dale and his years of experience, but I would like to get some feedback here before I try that technique.

Unfortunately, he does not say if he's talking about spindle work or cross-grain, and if the latter, he doesn't say if he's talking about the outside or the inside. I suspect there are some very important differences that one should be aware of before trying that technique for the various cases. He also talks about working "above center" to rub the bevel with the tool flat on the tool rest, but, again, he doesn't mention the circumstances. Seems to me it would make a huge difference and lead to some potentially dangerous problems if done for the wrong situation. I NEVER work above center on the outside of a piece, regardless of the grain orientation, except with a skew on spindles.

So, what's the deal? My obvious question is: do YOU ride the bevel when using a negative-rake scraper, and if so, under what conditions? And when not?

...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#2

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

John Lucas

I read that. I have tried grinding off the burr and rubbing the bevel on scrapers. I don't see the point unless it's simply trying to reach into an area with more control. If you come off the bevel you open yourself up to one heck of a catch. If I'm rubbing the bevel, why not just use a bowl gouge which might have a more acute cutting edge. Since some woods and some plastics actually scraper better than they cut then wouldn't this defeat the reason for using a scraper. I'm as confused as you are.

Of course Dale was an expert long before I even learned to turn. It would be wonderful to sit down with him and ask this same question.

I understand the reasoning for the negative rake scraper. It allows you to hold the tool at a more comfortable level angle and still have the cutting burr lower than the tool so you don't get a catch. Stewart Batty's negative rake scraper has been ground on the bottom bevel so the edge is very acute. This is more like using a skew on it's side. The drawing the Dale used shows the bottom bevel at just a little under 90 degrees. Much more acute than that and you would have to hold the tool way above center to rub the bevel.

I don't know, brings up a lot of questions.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#3

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

robo hippy

I am glad that I was not the only one confused by that. I can't see how you can rub the bevel on a negative rake scraper without dropping the handle. I doubt that it would catch, mostly because of the shape of the whole thing, and the burr is so fine, that if you tried to cut like that, the burr would vanish in miliseconds, as opposed to seconds under normal negative rake scraper use.

As to helping out the inside of your red oak bowl, my method, especially on dry wood would be to wet the inside (spray bottle, or wet sponge/rag/whatever) with water or oil, let it soak in for a bit, then cut out the wet part using the most dainty cut you can. I prefer a scraper, at a shear angle of 45 degrees or steeper, with a burnished burr. It can be done with a gouge as well. With a scraper, it is a pull (from the bottom up to the rim, which I know is backwards, but it works because of how light the cut is) cut. round over the rim, both inside and outside first to prevent cutting yourself, use left hand as a steady rest, and gently pull. Really pretty easy to control.

robo hippy

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#4

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

GaryG in MD

Well, I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who is confused. Note that Dale says to use the burr too, along with the bevel. Seems like that gives two different cutting edges at different angles. I just don't understand...

John, You're right -- it would be nice to sit down with him and have a long conversation. Since we can't do that, I'm going to take the conservative approach and just use it in the traditional way -- no bevel. As you say, I like the tool because you can keep it level on the tool rest -- with a normal scraper, going below center on the inside of a bowl (to get the handle high) is not a good idea (!), and I don't like setting the rest super high.

Some people do use skews as scrapers, but I don't understand the advantage -- it seems to me that the more metal you have to support the cutting edge, the better. OTOH, I guess maybe it's to preclude exactly what Dale is advocating -- to get the bevel OUT of the way on pieces with smaller curvatures. Your further thoughts? ...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#5

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

GaryG in MD

Robo,

Thanks for your thoughts on the neg-rake and the oak bowl.

In Dale's answer, he talked about working above center -- that's how he gets the bevel rub with the tool horizontal on the rest. He didn't say if he meant on a spindle or the inside of a bowl. Working above center on the inside of a bowl is "safe" because the tool has air space to move into, rather than wood, so it shouldn't self feed, but on the outside of a spindle, the reverse is true. I guess there's one way to find out.

I hadn't thought about "softening" up the wood with a liquid -- I'll have to think about that. You're right about using the scraper at a shearing angle, of course, but that has always made me nervous when working on the inside of a bowl -- one little mistake with that unsupported edge, and WHAM. Unfortunately, there's only one way to learn! One trick to make it safer is to use a spindle roughing gouge sharpened upside down so it rides flat on the tool rest, fully supported, but the cutting edge still has a bit of a shearing angle. I've been meaning to get another one and try that. Maybe this is a good time... ...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#6

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

adrien

Makes sense. With a negative rake, the tool angle is just the opposite of a standard scraper blade.

The bevel then conforms to the inside of the bowl. (As if a scraper were upside down.)

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#7

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

robo hippy

I use scrapers for my heavy roughing on bowls, both inside and out. In this case, the scraper is flat on the tool rest, slightly below center on the outside, and slightly above center on the inside. I never use the scraper flat for a finish cut, except some times going across the bottom. Never near the rim of the bowl: screach, howl, kapow, pieces every where.

For the shear cuts, always with an inside scraper (swept back to the left), so the cutting edge is below the centerline of the tool. If you work up near the tip, the tool and rotation of the bowl put your grip at a mechanical disadvantage, and it can slam down. If you want to try it, slow your lathe down, and be gentle about it. It isn't really and different from the same cut done with a gouge, and I feel a lot more comfortable using it on the inside of the bowl than I do a gouge. Really does a nice job of getting out tool marks, and tear out. Saves me one grit of abrasives most of the time.

I do ride the bevel of the scraper on one occasion. As a finish cut for the bottom of the inside of the bowl. I use an inside scraper that comes more to a point, almost like you cut a gouge down the middle. Cutting takes place on the tip, not up higher on the blade. It cuts like a bowl gouge with an 80 degree bevel. The high shear angle makes a nice clean cut.

robo hippy

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#8

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

GaryG in MD

Robo, Thanks -- you have provided a lot of food for thought here! ...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#9

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

GaryG in MD

I'm sorry Adrien, I don't understand your reply.

The 'bevel' angle of a negative-rake scraper, relative to the outside world, is basically the same as that of a normal scraper if the tool is flat on the rest. The difference is that the angle of the top of the tool at the bevel is different -- the angle where they meet at the burr is different -- blunter.

I would never consider working below center on the inside of a bowl -- that's an instant catch because the tool will "self feed". ...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#10

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

adrien

Thanks for the heads up. I bet I've gotten bigger catches than you. Agree not to scrape below center. But I do think top of negative rake bevel matches shape of inner bowl wall.

Since I've never done it, it's purely theoretical for me.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#11

diagram

GaryG in MD

Adrien,

You may be right about the catches, but that abrasive red oak bowl was one of my first rough outs many years ago, and it has evidence of some pretty bad tool use! I think the fact that the tenon was half ripped off is also pretty telling evidence -- even if it was in sap wood!

Here is a drawing of the negative-rake profile, as redrawn from the diagram in the "Ask Dale" article. Note that the angle of the bevel in both tools is the same, with respect to the horizontal. Only the angle of the top of the cutting edge is different. There are very different stories going around about the burr -- some say "no burr" and others, like Dale, say you have to have a burr. It would be nice to get a consistent answer on this, but, hey, we're woodturners, and we all do it our own ways! ...Gary

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#12

Re: diagram

Carol Reed

Thanks, Gary. A picture truly is worth a thousand words. Now I am beginning to understand this whole discussion.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#13

Dull scraper??

Russ Fairfield

Most woodturners use dull scrapers.

Most woodturners will be offended by this statement, but it is true. It is true for woodturners, just as it is true for cabinet scrapers. We all try to use them long after they have lost their sharp edge.

Stewart Batty says that the burr on a scraper is good for only 15-seconds in most wood. I disagree because it may be closer to 30-seconds, or a full 1-minute if the wood that is easilly cut; but I can see his point. It can be less than 15-seconds for hard and brashy wood, or wood that has sucked up some silica from the soil.

Sharpen your scrapers more often, use up the steel, and they will cut much better for you.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#14

Negative Rake scraper - my version

Russ Fairfield

No, it is good to get your questions answered, or at least discussed. Negative rake scrapers are not new. I learned to grind them that way in a pattern shop in the early 1950's, and our goal was to alway achieve a smooth surface on the wood without using sandpaper. No, I'm not as old as Wally, but close.

This is a sketch of what I use for a negative rake scraper. It was described in my article on scrapers in the AAW Journal in about 1992. It has the advantage that the bevel has been moved to where it can be slid on the surface of the wood below the cut. The angle of the bevel is determined by how high I want to hold the handle above hoprizontal. Something like a 95 degree angle with the top of the tool shank works best for me. Then I add about a 10 degree nagative rake on top. This makes for about a 105-degree angle at the cutting edge.

The large angle makes for a very strong burr, and the front bevel can be used to hold the wood in place while it is being cut. I use this one for way down inside of the bowl and cutting across the bottom to get a smooth surface without any waves in it. I also use it across the face of a platter for the same reason. The bevel can be slightly rounded to make a better match with curvature of the inside of a bowl, and get that area just below the burr on the wood.

This next picture is for all of those who believe that we should never ride along the bevel of a scraper. I do it all the time and I always get shavings that look like this. It isn't an agressive cut, but it leaves a smooth surface on any wood. The burr on this one can be made with the grinder or a slip-stone. The only difference is in the smoothness of the wood it leaves behind because the slip-stone make a smaller and smoother burr.


Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#15

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

As has been said, the negative rake scraper has been around for some time but very few turners were aware of it and of it's benefits.

Stuart Batty is credited with re-introducing the neg. rake. If you've ever watched Stuart use it, he does not ride the bevel.

Stuart grinds the tool at around 60 deg. on top and bottom. It can be more or less. He says that M2 steel isn't hard enough to hold a burr for than 10 or 15 seconds. M4 or A11 are better. He recommends using a coarse wheel to get a good burr. The burr must be there. As soon as the burr is gone the tool will start pulling end grain fibers. The tool should be used flat on the rest and with the handle nearly level, which means that it's not rubbing the bevel. It's used with a very light touch.

I've used my neg. rake successfully on quilted maple when nothing else would work. Heavily quilted wood tends to pull out little chips as the grain changes direction almost constantly.

Wally

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#16

Barb Siddiqui

So...

Barb Siddiqui

what we have here is one expert who rides the bevel, and one expert who never rides the bevel on a scraper. Seems to me the effect of the scraper will Entirely depend on the quality of the sharpening, then. Repeated sharpening.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#17

Now that makes sense

john lucas

Russ I can easily see how that would work. Are you still putting a burr on it? When I first read about bevel rubbing on a scraper they suggested removing the burr and polishing the top. That may have been for turning things like Blackwood and Ivory, my memory isn't that good.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#18

Re: So...

Russ Fairfield

Barb, sharp is the most important attribute of any tool, and it may be more important for the burr on a scraper because it is so small and fragile.

Sharp tools always cut better than dull tools, and the sharper they are the better they cut. Scrapers are no different. Think of the burr as a very thin and small cutting tool that is supported by the mass of the larger steel under it. When that burr is sharp, the scraper will cut like a surgeon�s scalpel. When it is dull, it has the cutting qualities of a rock. Because that burr is so small, scrapers have to be sharpened more often than other tools.

As for the difference in whether we ride the bevel or not, I think that at a microscopic level, we would see no difference in how the burr is cutting the wood. If the results are the same, then the wood is seeing the same tool. Everything else is just a difference in how we make that burr, support it, and present it to the wood.

Something that many woodturners either forget or have never learned, is that a scraper is what I call a �finesse� tool. It cannot be forced. When we force the scraper into the wood with heavy and aggressive cuts, it will fight back and give us torn grain, damaged wood, and frightening catches; and the harder we push it, the worse will be the damage. However, when we let the sharp scraper cut at its own rate, and we don�t force it into the wood, we are rewarded with some of the smoothest surfaces that are possible with any turning tool. The problem is that most of us are too impatient to let the scraper do that.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#19

More on bevels and burrs

Russ Fairfield

John, to answer your question, it depends on the shape of the burr. This is how I see it, and I am sorry to have written a book about scrapers and burrs. Others will have a different opinion. Woodturners usually do.

The size and the shape of the burr will depend on the heat generated at the grinding wheel. Steel tries to run away from heat. If there is a lot of heat with an aggressive grind, the burr will curl back over the top of the tool as shown in the photo; and the more heat the farther back it will curl. This tool will have to be presented in the traditional �handle high� to make it cut. There is no other way to get the sharp edge of the burr into the wood.


For a negative-rake scraper, think of grinding another bevel on the tool so as to tilt that curled burr to make it closer to being at a right angle (90-degrees) with the top of the tool, as shown in the photo. Different folks will use different angles, but it's all about controlling the location of that burr, its size, and the supporting steel under it.

How steep that top angle has to be depends on how much heat is generated at the grinder and the resulting curl of the burr. An agressive grind with a coarse wheel will make a burr with more curl, and require more top rake to tilt the burr forward. I use less top angle because there is less curl in my burr. That is the only difference.


If the burr is made with little to no heat, it will be more like that shown in the next photo. It will be a smaller burr, but it will be somewhere between in-line with the bevel, and straight up from the top of the tool, as shown in the next photo. This burr can also be made on the grinding wheel, but it is easier to make with a slip-stone because there is no heat with the stone. That means the tool can be used with the handle from level with the lathe to lower where the vevel is on the wood, and the burr will still be presented to the wood so it will cut. This is the burr I am using in the bevel-riding cut shown in the previous message. It is a smaller and less agressive burr than the one shown in the 1st diagram.


We could also opt for a no burr and use the scraper as a bevel-riding flat topped gouge, or a skew chisel with a large 75-degree angle and only one bevel. The problem is that tools with large angles don�t leave very good surfaces on the wood.

The advantage of the burnished burr is that it is very predictable and easy to make. The burr is always straight up, with no curl, because there is no heat. We can also control the size of the burr to make it as agressive or mild as we want. Many woodturners prefer this burr because it is easier to make a burr this way than spending the time at the grinding wheel learning about burrs and how they cut the wood. I don�t use it because it takes too long to maintain the burr, and after a couple of burnishes, I still have to go back to the grinder to make a new bevel that I can burnish. I can also do the same thing with a grinding wheel or diamond stone, and those give me more options for the shape and size of the burr.


Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#20

Barb Siddiqui

That makes a lot of sense

Barb Siddiqui

As always, thank you, Russ, for the detailed explanation.

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#21

thanks Russ-good reading

John Lucas

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#22

Thanks, Russ

Carole Valentine

I think I am finally starting to understand!

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#23

Steven Antonucci

And then they sand with spent sandpaper :-)

steven antonucci

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#24

Re: More on bevels and burrs

Doc Green

Excellent, Russ! This explains why using a scraper with the handle high sometimes makes it more aggressive and more likely to catch. The devil is in the burr.

I heard somewhere else that with some woods, green dogwood, for example, it is best if there is no burr at all, which is to say that it should be removed after grinding the scraper. I was trying to smooth the bottom of a dogwood bowl one time, and no matter the angle I held the tool, it would grab. Removed the burr and it calmed down.

Thanks again. ~Doc

Re: I hate to open this can of worms again, ...

#25

thanks for your comments, Wally...

GaryG in MD