Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

CPM-10V has found its match...

Posts

CPM-10V has found its match...

#1

CPM-10V has found its match...

GaryG in MD

With a measurement between sharpenings of several inches, not minutes, I'll say it all in just three words -- dry red oak.

Never again will I do "twice turned" with this stuff -- green to finish or nothing!

Can you imagine how the M2 works?

I should switch to carbide for this.

...Gary

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#2

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

Russ Fairfield

Dry Red Oak can be hard, but being that abrasive is more from where the tree grew than the species, and how much silica it drew up from the soil with the moisture. That can happen to any wood, not just Oak. Some of our western Big Leaf Maple is really bad about being abrasive.

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#3

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

John Jordan

Yep. And if it's abrasive, it doesn't much matter what the steel is. :)

John

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#4

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

GaryG in MD

True, true. I think I posted some time ago about having some similar trouble with a hunk of walnut, but I could at least get one pass down the side with that. Here, I can literally go only a couple inches between sharpenings. Very annoying.

And yes, I know about the fireplace :( , but this was one of the very first "big" (for me) 12" pieces I ever roughed, many years ago, so I have a psychological investment in it. I got a perfect grain balance, so, for me at any rate, it's worth trying to save. It's got some serious dig ins on the inside from when I was still learning tool control -- they make me smile now (they didn't then!).

Truing up the outside was bad enough -- I really dread the second hollowing. I don't normally use a scraper any more, but I suspect, after the gouge, I'm going to have to finish up with one on this. I've converted my large round-nose scraper to a negative rake, and that may end up being the "finishing" tool, since heavily sanding oak just makes waves.

The "soil" here is heavy red clay -- totally full of rocks of all sizes. Maybe that's where the silica is coming from.

I'll let you know how (or "if") it turns out. ...Gary

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#5

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

GaryG in MD

I could get maybe twice as far with the A-11 as with Crown M2, but, in this case, that's not far. Definitely calls for carbide. I might try my Hunter #5, but I don't think the small (3/8") cutter is ideal for this -- a #4 would be better, but I don't have one. If I do try it, I'll probably have to buy a new cutter after this! :O

Really sorry to hear/see about all your terrible flooding down there. Glad you were able to save your work. Your generosity for the relief effort is very kind.

...Gary

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#6

Re: Try the Easy Finish Tool

Steve Criscenzo

I have the Easy Wood Tools Finishing Tool. It has the round carbide cutter. It may cost you a cutter but I find it works well. I keep one cutter that I use only for the final finishing pass.

Good Luck

Steve

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#7

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

John Lucas

Gary I have some ballisters that came off the dorms here at Tech. They have an incredibly thick coat of layers of paint. I make lamps out them to donate to auctions that benefit the students or local PBS station. I can't even make one pass down them with a gouge (even thompsons) without having to sharpen, sometimes 2 or 3 times. Once I get through the paint it's just redwood so it cuts easily. I use massive dust collection and masks because it's probably lead based paint.

I use the Hunter tool on the last one I did and it cut it quite easily and didn't seem to dull the tool much. It's not as sharp as brand new but still cuts regular wood quite cleanly. I will try the EZ carbide cutters on the next one to see how they do. I expect them to cut much faster than the Hunter tools but the surface will probably not be anywhere near as clean and require more cutting and clean up with regular turning tools.

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#8

Paint....

Barry Irby

I was going to make something out of wood that had been painted and someone here pointed out that the titanium oxide used in modern paints is really hard. Don't know about the lead oxide, but I have no doubt about the titanium stuff. That might be your problem. I cleaned mine up before running it through any of my machines. Glad I did.

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#9

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your thoughts, John. All good ideas. I haven't got an EZ because I'm not fond of scrapers, but this might be a case where it is the best tool for roughing this highly abrasive oak. Just what I need -- more tools! :D ...Gary

Re: CPM-10V has found its match...

#10

Re: Try the Easy Finish Tool

GaryG in MD

Thanks Steve. It sounds like this is the perfect application. Good thinking about using two cutters -- keeping one for finishing -- I'll have to remember that. ...Gary