Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

Posts

How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

#1

How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

charlie belden

How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

. . . before you abandon an idea - or - modify the idea drastically in order to get the piece done?

While turning a pedestal for the Wishes Box that Jennifer?s Wishes Bowls inspired, it occurred to me that a hidden lidded box in it ? to hide ONE last marble ? might be fun. I like doing lidded boxes so this seemed to be a good idea. But it also would add more risk ? the fit of the lid is easy to blow.

As I began hollowing out the box part it occurred to me that instead of having the hidden marble roll around inside - and give away the secret - I'd make the marble the pupil of any eye that would be staring at you when you opened the box. The marble would sit in a concave hemisphere and the adjacent surface would be a convex hemisphere, rolling down as it approaches the side of the box. That meant turning part of a dome - inside a turned box- that's about 2" in diameter.

Well it's easy to turn a bead - on the OUTSIDE of a piece ' so it shouldn't be all that hard to do part of one - INSIDE the box - right?

WRONG-O, WRONG-O.

The tricky part of rolling a bead is near the end of the roll, when the tool goes from basically horizontal to basically vertical - up against an adjacent surface. That's where The Dreaded Spiral Cut lurks, waiting to cause a GOTCHA.

Must've been a small army of Dreaded Spiral Cuts hiding in this piece of wood. And they seem to collaborate with The One Last Cut demons - to maximize the damage they can wreak.

Recovering from a Dreaded Spiral Cut attack requires reducing the size or shape of the bead ? or in this case - half of an eye ball - inside a small box. And that meant getting the eye ball deeper in the box - where there's even less room to maneuver the cutting tool.

So after FIVE attempts - and five Dreaded Spiral Cuts - I'm seriously considering abandoning the Eye Ball idea and just hollowing out the box so I can finish turning the pedestal.

But my Little Voice keeps saying things like "If you painted the eye ball, maybe do some little red veins too - the surprise effect would be so cool!?" And I keep saying "But I could ruin the piece!". This Craftsmanship of Risk thing thing is a royal PITA.

When YOU are faced with a situation where the Craftsmanship of Risk Factor threatens completing the piece - do YOU go for it and keep trying - or - at some point are YOU more sensible and chose a simpler path to your destination?

Re: How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

#2

You can do it Charlie. I have faith!

Jim Rutten

381 times is the correct amount of times to try before you give up. You have 376 times to go and by the way, don't listen to that little voice that says you can't do that. Think about all the success you have had in incorpoating movement into turning. You WILL make it. As the line from the movie "Hook" goes "I believe".

Re: How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

#3

Here's the "challenge"

charlie belden


As you can see, the wood has a "marble" look, which goes with the idea of marbles. The profile is a compromise between the goal of using the spalting patterns and the goal of an aesthetically pleasing shape. I don't have any more of this spalted wood on hand so I have to finish this box - one way or another - soon - since it's a Mothers Day present.

When faced with situations like this - do you at some point go with an alternative you KNOW you can do - or try, try and try again - 'til you get it - or destroy the piece?

Re: How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

#4

Steven Antonucci

Try using something else.

steven antonucci

I have a lot of wood, and some that I define as special. If I didn't know exactly how to do something, I'd be using some of my "figuring out" wood. If it doesn't work out, i scrap it and grab another piece.

As far as how many times I will try something, the answer is best given by Master Yoda:

"Do. Or do not. There is no try..."

It is a mindset that you will achieve what you want to achieve, even if it means that you have to develop some prototypes to figure out what you don't already know. You are not failing if you are learning...

steve

Re: How Many Times Do YOU Try . . .

#5

Re: Here's the "challenge"

Bob Macgregor

If it is a Mother's Day present, doesn't that give you over 360 days to finish it?

I'm just askin'...

BOB