Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Drying wet wood....again

Posts

Drying wet wood....again

#1

Drying wet wood....again

Jim Canning

OK I have tried boiling my ruff turned bowls in water, soaking in alcohol, stuffing them in paper sacks (Nebraska for bag), sealing the end grain and barking at the moon (my wife suggestion)! Nothing seems to work, I still get about 35% that crack. I've tried putting dried coffee grounds or stone inlay with epoxy in the cracks and I don't like they way most of those look. I turn the edges below the pith and try to keep the thickness of the ruffed out bowls to 1" and even from top to bottom.........what am I doing wrong?

I don't like throwing woods away so I will try anything that is cheap because I am cheap....why do you think I am posting this here and not going out and buying a book or a video that tells me what to do?

Jim Canning

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#2

Steven Antonucci

Try less than an inch

steven antonucci

I had a lot of cracking. 10% is too much in my opinion if the bowls are larger (>10") and I think you can go as low as 3/4" It's basically 1-2 more cuts before waving the chicken, but 25% less material to contort.

steve

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#3

I'd Highly recommend John Jordan's DVD

Greg Haugen

I'd highly recommend John Jordan's "Aesthetics and Properties of Wood" DVD. I can be cheap too at times, but I'm lazier than I'm cheap-I'd spend some money so I don't have to work as hard or if I'm throwing out my work.

A few things that are often missed-just troubleshooting

- Balanced grain creates equal stresses, unbalanced grain creates unequal stresses and often cracks. Don't cut it for the biggest bowl possible, cut it for balanced grain.

-If you're returning a bowl if you're going to error, make the bottom a little thinner than the sides. It will help the sides to move with less stress in the base. Never have the bottom thicker, you're asking for trouble. If you have a cracked bowl, bandsaw it half and try to troubleshoot if it was a wall thickness error or something that caused it.

-Don't use pre-cracked wood, cutting 1/2" off of the end of the logs is not enough to get rid of the end checking. I'll usually cut 2" to 4" off of logs, if I need to do more I'll cut more. I'd rather have a smaller balanced grain bowl than a larger cracked bowl.

-Turning to finish while green can be a beautiful effect with the wood's distorations, etc. Turn it thin, and keep it cool with limited to no air flow, basement floors or boxes works well, and let it dry.

-Wood that is shocked by temp or humidity changes, is cracked wood. A newly turned green bowl should not be put into a dry, low humidity setting.

Try to troubleshoot what went wrong when something goes wrong.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#4

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Here's an idea. Use different wood. Some wood really wants to crack and it will drive you crazy trying to prevent those woods from cracking. Dogwood and cherry are beautiful, but they are examples of wood that is born to crack.

On the other hand, Bradford pear is just about crack proof. Persimmon is both beautiful and stable. Sweet gum warps but won't crack on you with minimal care. In my experience, the usual protective measures -- keeping away from moving air, wrapping in paper or rags, semi-sealing the wood with sanding sealer or waxes, etc. -- all seem to work for walnut and maple.

Surprisingly, distressed wood is much less likely to crack than sound wood. Wormy persimmon is wonderful wood -- the worm channels provide protection from cracking. Hypoxylon infested oak is another favorite, both for the beauty revealed and the stability. In general, if I can catch a piece of spalted wood just before it gets too punky, that wood seems less likely to crack.

So, try some different woods. Stop torturing yourself.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#5

Brian McKearney

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Brian McKearney

What time of year are you roughing your bowls? I have had the best luck roughing my bowls in the summer (basically any time from now until Octoberish) and I let them dry in my shed. My theory is that the summer months (at least here in New England) are more humid, and keeping the blanks out of the house tends to subject them to the humidity and they tend to dry more slowly. This seems to give me a better success rate for no cracks.

Also, where do you store your blanks to dry? I would expect that your house (even the basement) would be a lot drier than a shed for example. I have a pellet stove in the basement/workshop and if I were to toss a freshly roughed blank on the floor in the winter months, I would expect it to crack pretty quickly because it would dry so much faster.

Depending on the species, I may or may not seal the end grain. I usually have fairly good luck with maple just roughing the blanks and tossing them in the shed. I roughed out a few cherry blanks yesterday and decided that it was best to coat the entire blank with Anchorseal as I expect the cherry to move a lot more than maple. I could be wrong on this, but I decided to play it safe since I don't get a lot of cherry in this size (the bigger bowls were 14"-15").

Brian

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#6

Re: Drying wet wood....again

woodspinner

Hi Jim Living in Southern Az is about the worst place in the world to try to dry crack free. I rough any time of year and depending on Diameter from 3/4 for 10 in to 1 1/2 for 24 in stuff. Aftre rough the pieces go into plastic tubs with lids. When the tub is full I start opening the lid daily and removing all the pieces and check for start of cracks. If a crack put CA on it. Dump any water out of the tub and dry it. Put the pieces back for another 24 hours or so. I do skip the weekends as those belong to Edna. About 5 or 6 weeks of this and I start leaving the tub open for 4 to 6 hours daily and at the end of about 12 weeks they are stable and ready to finish. At the finish I remount and re round the spigout mount on the bottom. I then pigout mount for the balance of the work I procede to remove most of the excess inside and out and let the pieces rest for a few days prior to final finish. I believe this rest helps eliminate stress cracks.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#7

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Carole Valentine

You must not have the same Bradford Pear we have here!!! The stuff turns like butter but all that I have had will self destruct in a heartbeat with jagged cracks deep inside that you don't find until you uncover them with a gouge.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#8

Odd

Barry Irby

I have turned a number of pieces out of Bradford Pear. You are right, turns like butter, BUT I did not experience the cracking. I just used a pieces to trun three platters. It was a short half log that had been sitting aroudn inside or years.

OTOH, I am beginning to think oak stands for O A Krack.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#9

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Terry Scott

I just turn it thin 2mm and let mother nature do her thing the punters love the organic un- evenness.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#10

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Carole Valentine

Well a piece of wood doesn't stand a chance of sitting around your shop long enough to even THINK about cracking, Terry!

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#11

Re: Drying wet wood....again

john lucas

Carol I have the same problem here. Internal wind checks that follow the rings. You don't see them until you've already wasted time turning the piece. I have yet to turn a full size piece from Bradford Pear.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#12

Re: Drying wet wood....again

john lucas

Jim As near as I can tell each person has to find out what works in their area and with a particular species. I have always had problems with Cherry.

Here's what has been working for me although I haven't had another batch of cherry to try it on.

First I rough to around 10% but even on 20" bowls I don't leave it over an inch. I'll lose some to excessive warping but I can usually shorten those. Most bowls are 3/4" or less depending on size. I leave the bottom the same thickness or even less. The bottom of the bowl warps less so you can leave it thinner. This allows me to still leave a tenon on for remounting but I can leave the bottom the same thickness as the sides. That and the lip were where I had the most checking so I pay extra attention to those area.

I'm going to try someone's suggestion of not leaving a sharp edge because I looked back at my cracked cherry and all had a sharp edge on the rim. This would try faster because of how thin it is.

I put Anchorseal on all end grain and sometimes cover the complete lip and the complete foot. These are the two areas where I've had the most problems. I cover the endgrain both inside and out.

I store these blanks on the floor of the shop for at least a month or more. That area is the coolest, moistest,(made up that word) and has the lest air movement.

After a month or so I move them up to a shelf in the shop. I've seen people who have actual storage areas with shelves in a separate room. That will never happen in my shop, too crowded.

I'm I really want to save a special piece, after roughing and sealing I will put it in a paper sack for the first month or so.

Like you I have had way to many problems with checking bowls. I simply don't have the best places to store them and have had to come up with the above method to solve my problems. So far pretty good success.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#13

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Drying wet wood....again

Barb Siddiqui

Interesting discussion. I've been used to dealing with orchard fruitwoods and having a high rate of degrade upon drying, but much of the recently harvested silver maple I prepared and set aside to dry is now cracking after the pith was removed. It is all limb wood and I expected some, but I am losing most of it to having to cut smaller piecework from it. Disappointing after all the back breaking work I'd done.

Re: Drying wet wood....again

#14

John.....

Barry Irby

Phil English is a member of our club. He turned and sold a lot of bowls. He always turned the chuck foot off and left the blanks very even in thickness and round bottom. He said the cracking always started in the chuck foot.

I have had luck leaving the bottom a little thin and the rim thicker.