Honing, diamond or ceramic
ted evans
What would you get, Spyderco Pocket Stone or DMT Credit Card" Diamond Sharpening Cards for honing skews, parting tools etc? Thanks for any suggestions.
Ted
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Honing, diamond or ceramic
ted evans
What would you get, Spyderco Pocket Stone or DMT Credit Card" Diamond Sharpening Cards for honing skews, parting tools etc? Thanks for any suggestions.
Ted
Re: Honing, diamond or ceramic
Rob Wallace
Hi Ted!
I have been using one of Alan Lacer's Diamond honing stones for several years, and it continues to perform very well for touching up edges, and bringing back the edge of gouges during demos when I have no grinder available. Although somewhat 'pricey', I think it is well worth the investment to have a radius-edged diamond hone. The grit of Alan's hone is 600 ("fine"), if memory serves. Note that the Lacer hone is NOT the same diamond hone sold by Craft Supplies (although they mention Alan in the description of their tool.) The CS diamond hone does not have radiused edges.
I did get a nice ceramic hone from John Jordan last year at the AAW Symposium in Albuquerque - it also does a good job keeping an edge "alive" if the tool is touched-up frequently.
Although I've had one for quite some time, I only use a "credit card" diamond hone for sharpening the McNaughton Center Saver Coring knives. I much prefer a slip-style honing stone over a credit card style for general woodturning tool honing. If asked to choose diamond vs. ceramic, I think I would go with diamond.....although I have no empirical data to justify that choice!
Turn safely!
Rob Wallace
Re: Honing, diamond or ceramic
john lucas
If I could only have one, diamond. I like the ceramic hones, especially John Jordan's which is great. They have one downside. If you drop one it shatters. As long as your careful they are great. Ceramic stones cut cleanly and quickly. You do have to clean them occasionally. I use comet cleanser and water. It cleans the metal out so they cut like new. The diamond hones eventually wear out also but do last a pretty good while.
Re: Honing, diamond or ceramic
ted evans
Thanks Rob and John for your thoughts. The Lacer hones look great but me being a hobby turner, cannot justify the cost. Craft Supply has free shipping so will probably go with the diamond credit card hones. I have the small triangle shaped ceramics that I have been using but did not know how they compared with diamond hones, also wanted something with a little more surface area.
Thanks again for you input.
Ted