Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Suggested tool for carving

Posts

Suggested tool for carving

#1

Suggested tool for carving

Dinyar Chavda

I want to carve out sections (mostly rectangular) in hollow vessels that are not thin--they will probably be about 1/4" or thicker (think of Bud Latven's work, except non-segmented, and, also, thicker, or Bin Pho's squiggles, but rectangular and in thicker wood). What tool and cutters would you recommend for doing this?

Thanks

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#2

Re: Suggested tool for carving

charlie belden

Since you're working with quarter inch or thicker, I'd skip a high speed air driven turbine and small bits and go with a dremel or better yet a biger motor and more torque that a Foredom and its cousins provide, along with some straight cutting bits, their size depending on the scale you want to work with. Flex shafts can handle a range of shank and cutter sizes. A RotoZip might work too, though the range and size of bits is limited.

Once you've roughed the opening, a whittle knife will let you square up the corners. Do the cross grain cuts first and overcut a little so when you make the with the grain cuts you'll be less apt to split the wood at the ends of the cuts.

Now if you have an opening bit enough, a jeweler's saw and blades will cut out most of what you want. Drill small holes in the corners of your rectangles - thread the jewler's saw blade through one, tighten it in the saw frame and saw away. Again, clean the corners up with the whittling knife.

Now if you had access to a laser engraver / piercer . . .

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#3

for thick wood-patience

john lucas

Dinyar My favorite tool for thick wood and delicate or accurate carving is the flex shaft. I like the Foredom but in reality probably any of them will work. Woodcarverssupply has one of the largest selection of tools. I use a Dremel a lot but on thicker wood it just doesn't hog the wood off fast enough and your limited to 1/8" shank. This size vibrates too much when hogging wood.

I would start with a drill. You can buy a handpiece for the Foredom that will take up to 1/4". Punching through the wood seems to take forever with the various cutters and a drill goes through quickly. However it can tear out on the backside. If this is a problem drill smaller holes to start with.

I like the Fast cut carbide mini monsters for getting rid of wood with at some degree of control. Part#629523 is my favorite all around cutter. These cut fast and clean but don't come in the smallest sizes so if your openings are small they might not work.

Next to those I like the Kutzall burrs. They have less tendency to tearout the wood but leave a finish that requires more sanding. I start with the course and then clean up with the fine to reduce the sanding time. They do clog on some woods but can be cleaned with a torch.

For cleaning up sharp corners I use a knife (chip carvers) or if the wood is too thin and I'm nervous about breaking it I use riffler files or jewelers files. They come in various cut quality so buy the fine if all your doing is cleaning up. The diamond files work well if the cut is very light and you just want to reduce sanding time.

If all you need to do is remove a little just wrap some sandpaper tightly around a piece of wood with a corner whose angle matches the corners you need to cut.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#4

meant to post link- good place to buy from  *LINK*

john lucas


http://www.woodcarverssupply.com/

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Suggested tool for carving

Richard Allen

Drill, drill bits, copping saw. 1/4" is a LOT of wood to "carve" away. Wood that thick can be cut out instead of turned to dust.

If you are sure that carving is the way you want to go there are electric die grinders such as the Makita GD0800C die grinder. These are much higher powered than the flex shaft machines. You can attach 1/4" shank bits and destroy wood quickly.

A trim router or a rotozip tool can work with 1/4" thick wood.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#6

Steven Antonucci

Agree with the others

steven antonucci

Not a question of what tool, but which tools you need to have to accomplish the various tasks. Personally, I like doing most of the work with hand tools because I hate all of the dust my Dremel makes (and the whine too!)

I also have a much larger burr (Kutzall 1" ball) that I power with a die grinder (air)... lots of dust...fast...noisy...

steve

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#7

Re: Suggested tool for carving

Barry Irby

I know nothing about this, But that has never stopped me before.

I just got a Multi tool. Mine is a Bosch, but similar to the Fien. Has a blade that oscillates back and for about an1/8". Several widths of blades available and you could probably cut one down if you wanted to.

An interesting tool. Will easily make a plunge cut through wood, but does not cut your finger. Don't have much experience with mine, but it might provide a different approach. I think you would have to make an overlay guide, tape it to the vessel and plunge the blade in right beside the guide.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#8

Re: Agree with Multimaster

Steve Criscenzo

Since your holes are rectangular, I think a tool like the Fien Multimaster would do a good job (as long as your holes are large enough). I use this tool quiet a bit for fine cuts and I have even modified a blade to make a smaller cut. Good news is that the patent has expired for the Fien and there are several others on the market and the price has come down.

Steve

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#9

2 more suggestions *LINK*

john lucas

Below is a new bit that woodcarverssupply sells that might be interesting since it both drills and cuts.

One of the problems you will have is the bit following the wood grain. On slow speed grinders (under 50K) the wood will try to pull the bit in. This is really a pain and takes a lot of hand control to keep it from doing this. It is tiring. Bits like the Kutzall tend to do this less but they don't remove wood as fast or as clean.

If your holes are large enough try an air saw. It's amazing how easy this is to control. You could get incredibly close to the final size and shape with this if the hole is large enough. About the only problems is it's air hungry, noisy, and vibrates a lot. It works fine if you keep it to short sessions to let your hands and compressor relax. Grizzly calls it an air body saw part #H8214




http://www.woodcarverssupply.com/searchprods.asp

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#10

Sorry, the link doesn't work

john lucas

Try doing a search on woodcarverssupply.com for part # 627030

Whatever you do avoid going to this place at all costs. At least if you value your wallet and credit card limit. Not only is it in one of the prettiest places in Tennessee it is impossible to leave without buying something. Usually a lot of somethings.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#11

Re: Suggested tool for carving

Carole Valentine

I have a tool coming that I may or may not have wasted my money on...called an Electro-file and it includes small recip saw blades as well as various files and sanding paddles. We'll see if it does what I want it to. I believe it has a 1/4" stroke, which is longer than I would like. Should be here Tuesday and I will try it out and let you know. I have found that rotary type tools are very hard to control sometimes if you have distinct grain in the wood.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#12

Just recieved an order from them!

Carole Valentine

I wouldn't dare go in there in person. It would be worse than visiting the vendors area at the World Carving Championships!

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#13

Richard Allen

Re: Suggested tool for carving

Richard Allen

The "electro-file" works. It is slow and as with most tools experience will improve your results. To cut wood you need to do two things, rip the wood fibers and remove the wood fibers. The very short throw is fine for ripping the wood fibers but not so good at removing the waste.

There is a tool called a band file which is usually an air powered tool. Makita has an electric version (Makita 9032) as does Milwaukee (6101. There are three different widths available (1/4", 3/8", 1/2"). This tool would be good for cleaning up the hole once the bulk of the wood is removed.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#15

Re: Suggested tool for carving

John Jordan

Duragrit.com

John

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#16

Re: Suggested tool for carving

Gil Jones

Any opinions on the Proxxon and/or Automach reciprocating, electric carvers?

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#17

Re: Suggested tool for carving

John Jordan

I have a couple of automach carvers, and have worn one out. Much better than the Proxxon, but neither is what one would want to cut out sections as Dinyar asked about.

John

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#18

Thanks to all

Dinyar Chavda

Thanks, everyone, for all your suggestions, some of which have led to more questions.

First off, I should clarify that I used the word "carving" in a loose sense---I want to make

holes (sort of rectangularly-shaped, maybe elongated elliptical) in the hollow vessel.

Charlie, when you talk about "straight cutting bits" you're not talking about routers, or

are you? I assume that you're referring to bits like the one at

http://www.woodcarverssupply.com/MONSTER-CARBIDE-3_4-CYLINDER/productinfo/629027/

Is a jeweler's blade better than a regular woodcutting fretsaw blade? And, no, I agree with

your implicit statement that it would not be cost-effective to invest in a laser for this!

John, thanks for the hints re drilling--it has been a problem in the past, and I never

thought of starting with a smaller drill (By the way, to me, "patience" is a 4-letter

word!). Do the carbide cutters last? What do you use the 627030 in--your Foredom? I guess

I'll skip that trip to TN that I was planning!

Richard, I'll look into using my trim router for this, although I'm not sure I can control

it enough on a curved surface and with changes in grain.

Barry and Steve C, what are the competitors to the Fein/Bosch which are less expensive? I

see that there is a Dremel which falls into this category. Steve, which blade did you

modify to make a smaller cut?

Caroline, I'll be interested in your reaction to the electrofile. Richard, what saws do you

use in your electrofile--I was under the impression that it was meant for sanding, and not

for cutting, but your experience seems to be different.

John Jordan, were you referring to the carbide cutting wheel that's shown at

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaBmUAaZppU ? Do you recommend any size as being most

useful? Do you use the cutting wheel or the combo cutting/shaping wheel? How careful do

you have to be to make sure that it does not break by twisting?

Again, thanks everyone.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#19

Change to previous message

Dinyar Chavda

Please ignore the question re the competitors for the Fein/Bosch MultiMasters--I found a bunch of them. Has anyon on WC use the HF ones--they have both a variable speed and a fixed speed, and the reviews I have seen are pretty positive overall. Can't beat the price.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#20

Re: Change to previous message

Steve Criscenzo

I have not used the HF Multitool. I was in the local HF store the other day and saw them on display. You are right, the price is great and the accesories are far cheaper than the Fein.

The Fein is a great tool and mine has been rock solid for many years but given the cost difference I would certainly look at the alternatives is I was buying a multi tool today.

I took the Fein wood cutting blade that is about 1" wide and has fine teeth and ground off about half of the width so there is about 1/2" left. Works good for making straight cuts in thin wall vesels.

Steve

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#21

Re: Change to previous message

Barry Irby

I am with Steve on this. I also saw the multi tool in HF but have not tried it. I got my Bosch tool at Lowe's on closeout and It is a battery powered one. Given a choice i doubt I would have bought the battery version. The charger was bad with mine and Bosch sent me a new battery and then a new charger. (No complaint there, excellent service.) Its just that the batteries have a run time of about 18 minutes and recharge in 30. If "cordless" was not important, I would go with corded. I have a bunch of cordless tools. Love the tools, hate the batteries.

The blades were shockingly expensive. Ten to nearly forty dollars each. Seemed outrageous to me. So, I went to HF searching for cheaper blades. They have them, and I bought some, but have not used them. Someone here posted that they don't last long. Neither did the ones that came with my Bosch.

Bosch will use most anybodies blade. Something to look for.

I have seen two Dremel units in use by others and they liked them.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#22

Re: mutifunction tool--Suggested tool for carving

Dinyar Chavda

Several people mentioned a multifunction tool like the Fein. Going from the sublime to the ridiculous, HF has their variable speed MF tool on sale for $69.99, which, with a 20% off newspaper insert coupon, nets out at about $55 (the single speed is for $34.99 less 20% off). I know the caveats about the Chicago Electric tools, but in case you're interested, the price can't be beat.

Re: Suggested tool for carving

#23

Ken Vaughan

Re: mutifunction tool--Suggested tool for carving

ken Vaughan

Have a Fein -- have tried the HF attachments and will say from the experience that this is a place where you will get what you pay for.

Durable and problem free have been the watch words for my experience with the expensive Fein multitool.