Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Collaborative Work

Posts

Collaborative Work

#1

Collaborative Work

Jennifer Indy.USA

Collaborative work is a totally different way to work and make things than most of us are used to. For the most part I've always thought of collaborative work in the sense of I'll turn a bowl and you decorate it. Or she'll turn a top he'll carve and paint it. This sort of collaboration is wonderful when it works. Just look at some of the stuff Bonnie and Jacques come up with and the sweet collaborative piece that Ruth and Carole and Barbara and Mac posted are wonderful examples of what I call �pass it on� collaborative work. When Mike Stafford sent me a box to decorate it was painfully nerve wracking to think that I might goof it up with my burner. As it turned out it came out just fine, but Mike and I didn�t design it together or labor together on it. Clay and I have been wanting to do some collaborative work and quickly discovered that our two styles of work really don't compliment each other all that well. It was sort of a bummer to discover this. His work is torched and grouted and stands on tall towers that rise out of craggy rocks and mine is a bit more refined with squiggles, curly que's and swirly stuff all over them. This is the first piece that we've collaborated on. His rock tower and my little decorated bowl. While it's not bad, it doesn't show a true sign of collaborative work to me. Collaborative means "to labor together", so we decided that rather than plop one of my bowls on one of his rock towers again we would try to work together to come up with a complimentary style that imparts both of our methods of work in a cohesive piece. To work together to make some things that have a new look for both of us but still has a sense of both of our styles. It will be a challenge but we'll have fun trying to figure it out. I encourage anybody who is interested to try some collaborative work no matter if you do a pass it on collaborative or work from sketches together to come up with something from the ground up. It's fun and challenging and may get you thinking outside your safe zone. I think it would be a blast to be involved with a class on collborative work.

Jen


Re: Collaborative Work

#2

Re: Collaborative Work

fgvanatta

Looks to me like this piece worked out quite well. I like it.

Frank

Re: Collaborative Work

#3

Re: Collaborative Work

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Jennifer,

I think this one works pretty well. You didn't really ask for a critique, but I'll offer a small one in that your piece seems elegant and refined while Clay's part is more rustic and raw. Not sure how that helps, just an observation!

I think that one of the great aspects of having someone who is also artistic and creative would be the prospect of working together on a piece. Exactly like you say, not you do your part and I do my part and then we merge them, but let's do the parts together and see what comes out of it. I look forward to seeing what you two come up with and am envious of your journey!

Thanks for the Friday pics,

Mike

Thinking about collaborations in Apex, NC...

Re: Collaborative Work

#4

Re: Collaborative Work

bowlman

Jen,

You're right ... it just doesn't work. Pass it on to me and I'll hide it from the world.

Re: Collaborative Work

#5

Re: Collaborative Work

Don at Central Illinois

I have to agree with you, it doesn't work completley. It is just one of your wonderful bowls sitting on one of Clay's wonderful formation, but, in this case, two wonderfuls don't make a fantastic. When you two, design and then complete, I'm sure it will be fantastic. Both you and Clay, come up with things, I don't even think about. Make sure we see a 'true collaberation'.

Re: Collaborative Work

#6

Re: Collaborative Work....have to agree

Ruth Niles

your individual styles don't work in this piece. Maybe you're too close? Try doing a piece and mailing it to Clay but don't peak at what he does with it!!! 8) Seriously, Bonnie doesn't watch Jacques carve, right?

By the way, at the Gainesville show and after posting our "Alice" piece, I got a few emails from turners saying they'd like to get in on a collaborative piece like ours. I believe you have to decide if you're looking to do a "fun" piece like we did with "Alice" or an "art" piece like what you and Clay might do or the Kline/Vessery work.

Personally, an "art" piece would put too much stress on me, the "fun" collaborative was perfect. You also have to decide if each person keeps it x amount of time or it gets donated. That's not as easy as it might sound especially when we are spread around the countryside.

I'm all for doing it again with...whoever....and just posting pictures of the results pleases me just fine.

Re: Collaborative Work

#7

Re: Collaborative Work

Carole Valentine

Nope. Doesn't work for me either, Jen. Looks like the pedestal was a handy place to stick the bowl while you did something else and that they are totally unrelated. You both have tremendous talent, but the talent doesn't jive in this particular case, IMHO. The two of you need to sit down with a drawing pad, two pencils with erasers, and just brainstorm - and a bottle or two of wine would probably help release any creative inhibitions! :D

Re: Collaborative Work

#8

Re: Collaborative Work

Jennifer Indy.USA

Thanks for all of your comments everybody. Mostly I just wanted to generate a discussion on collaborating. Even though this one that Clay and I did isn't the result we wanted we're looking forward to making more. That's the key I guess. Just make more stuff and you'll get there. Ellis if you're listening....we were thinking it might make for an interesting contest to have some sort of collaborative one. Just a thought.

Jen

Re: Collaborative Work

#9

Ellis Walentine

I'm listening

Ellis Walentine

I agree that collaborative work might make a great contest. Now all I need is a sponsor and some judges. Suggestions welcome.

It might be interesting to involve ancillary arts and crafts besides woodworking, too. Candy and I used to collaborate occasionally, with her painting floral designs etc. on pieces that I made.

Thanks for the nifty idea.

Ellis

Re: Collaborative Work

#10

Re:I don't believe it's the best combination....

JamieDonaldson

..of colors in the separate pieces, and that fails to blend the elements together more than the design of the elements themselves. For several years my late wife and I collaborated on many bowls and she added basketry to my turnings. This was 1 of the most complicated pine needle jobs she added to a honey locust bowl.