Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Thompson tool wear

Posts

Thompson tool wear

#1

Thompson tool wear

john lucas

This is a 2 part discussion on tool wear and sharpening. Many months ago Doug asked if anyone could measure how much of a tool is ground away with each sharpening. Well I can't answer that because I don't know how long I've owned my 1/2" bowl gouge or how many times it's been sharpened.

I know I've had it over 2 years and It's my favorite tool so it gets used a lot and consequently sharpened a lot. I sharpen it mostly on the Oneway Wolverine jig. Rarely do I hone it with the diamond hones although will sharpen the flute using a diamond fish hook hone when I need a really sharp tool. I have been using 100 grit white wheels at 1725rpm for sharpening these gouges.

A few months ago I purchase another 1/2 bowl gouge to be sharpened like the Michelson grind. It dawned on me yesterday that I could match the flute length and have some idea how much tool has been ground away. Of course this does assume that Doug had been grinding the flutes the same length for the last few years and only he can answer that.

I was amazed by how little metal has been removed. I do use a very light touch on the wheel and with my wooden jigs for setting the V arm of the Oneway my sharpening is very repeatable. I would guess just about as little metal as possible is removed each time I sharpen.

As you can see in the photo it's only a little more than 1cm. That's not very much considering how many times this thing has been to the grinder. The lower tool has only been sharpened a few times. I think that's pretty amazing considering that early on in my turning I ground away most of a gouge in year or so.


Re: Thompson tool wear

#2

Re: Thompson tool wear

Bill Howatt

Pretty good alright but I imagine you have a better "touch" than a lot of us.

I consider a gouge to be a consummable and while I don't want to needlessly grind it away, I don't expect it to last forever. Pretty poor turning if you don't grind your gouge sometime.

I think using the Vari-grind instead of free-handing I grind away less of the gouge.

Bill

Re: Thompson tool wear

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Thompson tool wear

Mike Stafford

John, I do not have a new tools with which to compare my current Thompson gouges however I am prone to believe they do not wear/dull as quickly as my other tools. I sharpen a lot and like you I have repeatability with my jigs so I am not removing very much steel each time. I can tell the difference immediately when I sharpen my tool by how easy it is to pick up a fine cut and maintain it i.e. keep the edge in the cutting line.

Sharpening is very important to me because when I use a dull tool my sanding time increases. I don't dislike sanding but I don't want to spend any more time doing it than I have to.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#4

Re: Thompson tool wear

Bill Neddow

John, I believe I am having the same experience. I used to go through at least one 5/8 inch bowl gouge a year. I turn a lot. I sharpen a lot, as I hate turning with dull tools. But, because I sharpen often, I only have to lightly touch the tool to the wheel. My 5/8 inch Thompson bowl gouge is almost 4 years old -- and at the rate it is wearing, it has about twice that length of time left to live.

Glad you brought this to my attention. Now I realize I will have money to buy more Thompson tools at Hartford. Good investment.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#5

Wait a minute

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Your doing something wrong... try a very course wheel then use lots of pressure and that flute will down to nothing in less than a year.

It is amazing how well the edge holds up.

Hartford will have handles... finally :D

Re: Thompson tool wear

#6

Re: Wait a minute

john lucas

I forgot, you need to sell more tools. My suggestion then is to sharpen about every 10 minutes and use a 60 grit wheel. Of course when the tool is about half used up it's too short to be really useful so buy 2 more. One as a backup. (how's that Doug :) )

Re: Thompson tool wear

#7

Re: Wait a minute

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Hartford will have handles... finally :D

Would you please explain, Handles?

Enquirer minds need to know.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#8

Re: Wait a minute

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

The handles will be aluminum/weighted and looking at the final design a bit over done... those Haas cnc's are to much fun. The only thing to decide is the color and that's 90% set.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#10

Re: OK, Doug how much and where?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Scott, I'll let them out around the symposium in June.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#11

Re: OK, Doug how much and where?

Gordon Seto

We have seen some of the prototypes at the last Club meeting. I personally like the black color version, very sexy. Of course, some like them naked or in different color. I don't know whether Doug has made up his mind yet besides anything but red.

The handle shape is unique. It won't roll off the table and comfortable. Doug said they will be in various lengths and customizable with lead shot at the rear.

Can't wait to lay my hands on the final products.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#12

The symposium!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Sounds a bit scary to me... :)

Will you have updates on your website?

Scott, all this is very new to me.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#13

Re: The symposium!?!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Scott, the national symposium (mid June) is scary... 1,500 older people converge on one city and talk about wood and tools for three days. This is not like Vegas, what happens in Hartford is talked about all over the world. All kidding aside it's nonstop for three days and fun... it's almost to much fun... LoL.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#15

Re: Soundslike fun 

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Two years from now it will be in CA.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#16

Sheezz John

Jorge Casta�eda

You sure have a lot lighter touch than me. I don't remember in years, but my first Thompson was a 5/8" V and at the time I was just a few over 400, that is serial number, last year when got yet another DT gouge, I had to notice that, 300 bowls later, it was 1" shorter. I was using a shop made jig, and was using the gray wheels that came with the grinder;that prompted me to get something better, I got the Kelton one and a set of blue wheels. I wish I got all that from day one.

Now think I should replace the 40 and 80 grit blue wheels with something finer, maybe keep the 80 as coarse and get a 120.

Thanks for making me think

Jorge

Re: Thompson tool wear

#17

Re: Sheezz John

John Lucas

I was really surprised myself. As often as I sharpen I thought I would surely use a lot of steel. It's not like I baby the tools and certainly don't run them until they won't cut before sharpening. It could be that because I sharpen often it takes almost nothing to refresh the edge. I do have a light touch but there have been times when I didn't feel like I hit all the edge and would go back an hit it lightly again. I thought I was removing quite a bit of metal.

The only reason I started with 100 grit wheels is that what came on one side of the grinder so I bought another one that was 1" wide for the other side so I could leave the V arm on one wheel and tool rest on the other wheel and not have to change the angles.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#18

Re: Sheezz John

Jorge Casta�eda

"so I could leave the V arm on one wheel and tool rest on the other wheel and not have to change the angles. "

That makes a lot of sense, Thanks!

Re: Thompson tool wear

#19

don't like lead...

GaryG in MD

I am unhappy to hear that the new tool will be filled with lead. Lead is a very poisonous element. I will not buy a tool filled with lead. I would prefer to see the handles filled with steel shot. That's what I use, and it works fine. If more balance weight is needed in the tail, it could be a carbide insert/plug. JMO, Gary

Re: Thompson tool wear

#20

Re: don't like lead...

Gordon Seto

Don't know what Doug is going to use as the weights. "lead shots" is just a generic term I use like Kleenex is equivalent to tissue.

Re: Thompson tool wear

#21

Gosh no... it will be filled with steel shot...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

I did child proof the end cap because you know someone is going to eat the shot so a wrench will be needed to remove the cap. If someone wants to use this handle for anything besides woodturning that's their problem. If one of these handles show up on a hospital x-ray I'll post it on my site