Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

Posts

Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#1

Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

Jim Rutten

Is there a video on you tube or anywhere else that demonstrates the technique of shear schaping the inside of a bowl with a scraper held at 45%? Thanks for your answer.

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#2

MrRules

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

MrRules

I believe Lyle Jamieson covers this on his DVD's, Bowl Basics The Easy way, and you might find a description and links to some film on his website. Bill Grumbine's DVD, Beyond the Basic Bowl, also teaches this technique. Good luck.

Stu

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#3

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

john lucas

Jim I don't know if there is a video anywhere. It's quite simple. Tilt a round nose scraper to about 45 degrees and then cut with the lower half or lower 1/3. If you hold the handle higher than the cutting edge it's less likely to catch. I lead with the handle so the so it's ahead of the cutting edge. This is much like having the handle higher than the cutting edge when the scraper is flat.

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#4

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

robo hippy

First, a fresh burr on the scraper. I usually use the one straight from the grinder. A burnished burr does give a slightly better cut. You can use the Veritas/Lee Valley thing that you screw down to a work bench, or a triangle one that you can pick up just about anywhere. It is almost impossible to raise a burr with the round burnisher. With the scraper at 45 degrees, take very light pulling cuts, pulling from the bottom towards the top of the bowl. I know this is backwards from the normal cut, but it is so light that it doesn't really make any difference. It will take several passes to remove any tear out and/or tool marks. I do use my left hand as a steady rest on the outside of the bowl, especially when working near the rim, and more so on larger bowls than on smaller ones as the rim is rather flexable. Male sure to round over the rim of the bowl first becasue that rim, if left square is like a small razor saw. Use the same amount of pressure that you are using on the scraper. Too much pressure is as bad as too little, or none at all. I generally use the inside, or swept back to the left side scrapers, but the round nose ones will work as well. I lower the handle a bit for my cuts. Do work at, or below center on the tool.

I think there may be some thing on the Sorby web site showing it with their multi tip tool, but I prefer the standard scrapers. Much more heavy duty.

robo hippy

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#5

Round Burnishers??????

Greg Haugen

Reed,

Why do you say "It is almost impossible to raise a burr with the round burnisher"? I just did a search on Lee Valley, as well as Woodcraft, and found more round burnishers than triangular. I use a round burnisher for raising burrs on my scrapers that I use as basically micro-hook tools. Never had an issue and it's a cherished tool. Your statement provoked me to do a search for technical data from woodworking resources. I didn't find anything favoring triangular burnishers-quite the opposite actually.

I'm just curious as to your feedback on round burnishers?

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#6

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl *LINK*

Greg Haugen

Jim,

I haven't seen Lyle's Bowl DVD yet. I have both of Grumbine's and would highly recommend both.

I don't use scrapers on bowls. The techniques I use came from Mike Mahoney, Stuart Batty, and Trent Bosch. Depending on the bowl and it's details-it will dictate which "bits and pieces" of the techniques I'll use. But one thing that stands true no matter is the short, stubby ground bowl gouge that is used on the interior. No scrapers used and an excellent finish is left. It's very versatile. If you're curious, I'd recommend Mike's DVD (one with Stuart) and Trent's bowl DVD. Mike calls it "the bottom feeder" gouge. I use a similar grind on a 3/8" (1/2" american) gouge.


Mike's Bottom Feeder Gouge

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#7

Re: Round Burnishers??????

robo hippy

In flat work, you use a round burnisher on your card scrapers. The triangle ones are for the goose neck ones or rounded ones. Mostly, I think, because it is hard to clamp them to some thing firm so you can use your round burnisher and apply pressure. It is done with the scraper hand held. I tried to burnish an edge with my round burnishers on my turning scrapers, and didn't have much luck. Just couldn't get much of a burr. I just didn't want to buy the contraption from Lee Valley. When I tried the triangle burnisher, it worked. My guess it that it has a smaller surface area, and you can put more psi on than you can with the round burnisher. I figured that this is why Lee Valley came out with their burnisher for the turning scrapers, which has a post to lever against for more pressure. I think our steel is a bit harder then the card scrapers used in flat work. It works for me.

robo hippy

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#8

Re: Round Burnishers??????

Greg Haugen

That's interesting.

The resources I've read and have been taught that triangular burnishers are for straight, flat edges since they'll produce galling on rounded curve edges. The Lee Valley jig was created to take the "error factor" out of the angle since the angle is preset in the angle of the pin and the turning scrapers are a far cry to the complexity of cabinet scrapers. A rounded burnisher concentrates more force on the edge and is one reason that turning companies (Crown and Hamlet) are offering a round burnisher only, if they're offering a burnisher at all, for the harder steel of the tools. Round burnishers can scallop the edge if used too hard or unevenly on softer steels. Here are a couple of links for some good articles.

www.woodworking.org/WC/Channels/scraper.html The section on burnishing is good.

www.joewoodworker.com/scraper.htm Talks about using anything from screw drivers to a car's valve stem as long as it's polished and hardened.

Your triangular burnisher works for you. After your statement I was just curious as to your feedback. It seems triangular burnishers are becoming scarse, more and more rounded models are being offered. When I had some hands on time with Alan Lacer, we worked with scrapers and burnishers. He had an old triangular burnisher and I bought a new round one (Hamlet) from him. It seemed odd but I asked about the differences. He just said that was an old one he had for a long time, I raised a burr with mine and loved it. As one article says, it doesn't matter which burnisher you use, for the most part, as long as it works for you.

Just curious. Thanks for the feedback.

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#9

Re: Round Burnishers??????

robo hippy

Well, I was doing it all wrong, and it worked for me. There is a huge difference in the burr depending on how much pressure you use, and the angle of the burnisher. I do like it at about 5 to 10 degrees to the bevel. Too much angle, and it hooks over. Too much pressure and too many strokes, and it hooks over as well. By hooks over, I mean you turn a burr that is more like a breaking wave, than a standing edge. With my grinder burr, I can ride the bevel across the bottom of my bowls (inside/swept back to the left side, coming more to a point than a tip that is rounded over). With the burnished burr, I can't make that cut. I also prefer the grinder burr for roughing my bowls. It is as durable, and can be very aggressive. I may have to try the round burnisher again. When I use the triangle one, I use the point of the triangle. Very little pressure is needed.

robo hippy

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#10

Re: Round Burnishers??????

Greg Haugen

Reed,

You're not doing it wrong, you're making it work and I think that's great. There's always more than one way to do something. I've always read your posts and thought, "I'd like to see him do this some time-it sure sounds interesting." Maybe I'll get the chance some day to see you demo or have a class.

I've heard you talk about standard scrapers and burrs. Have you ever used a negative rake profile on any of your scrapers, as far as an application to bowls?

Re: Shear scraping the inside of a bowl

#11

Re: Round Burnishers??????

robo hippy

I had a Raffen spear point scraper that I converted to a negative rake scraper. Just don't find them practical. the burr is so fine, it doesn't get a chance to cut before it is gone. I know some people like them, but they don't work for me. It is intended to be used flat on the tool rest, and I will never use a scraper on the inside of a bowl with it flat, except for roughing cuts. For finish cuts, I have it at a 45 degree angle. When flat, especially near the rim, it will cause the rim to vibrate, some times to the point where you get a big catch and explosion. Gentle touch only.

robo hippy