Parting tool question...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I'm looking to get a standard (i.e. not a thin) one. What to get?
Regular, diamond, fluted?
PM, Kyro, M2?
Scott, perplexed as usual 
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Parting tool question...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I'm looking to get a standard (i.e. not a thin) one. What to get?
Regular, diamond, fluted?
PM, Kyro, M2?
Scott, perplexed as usual 
Re: Parting tool question...
Richard Allen
Diamond is great for parting without the parting tool binding, but you need to make sure the tool is sharpened so the point remains at the wide point.
The fluted tool tends to cut cleanly. The fluted parting tool I am aware of are all of the thin variety. You sharpen the non flute surface.
A "regular" parting tool say 3/8" thick can be used to part deeply (in widening passes 7/16"). You can also use a wide parting tool roll beads and use the sides of the parting tool as a spear point scraper or even as a shear scraper.
Parting tool tend to be limited use tools. When used as a parting tool, high on the spinning wood, the edge tends to stay sharp a while. When used straight on as a scraper the tip tends to dull quickly. M2 steel is a good choice as you can sharpen without losing temper yet save money over the more expensive metals.
Re: Parting tool question...
John K Jordan
One of my fluted parting tools is not a thin style. It cuts cleanly and quickly. I'm in Colorado at the moment and can't check the brand.
I also like the diamond shape. I like the non-fluted flat edge not only for parting but sizing, making tenons, cutting recesses for chuck jaws, and for a variety of detail work.
JKJ
Re: Parting tool question...
Bill -- Jacsonville NC
Started out with and still use my Sorby diamond-parting tool. Any brand of M-2 HSS, diamond-parting tool will work for general spindle and bowl turning.
Have added M-2 HSS, Bedan tool, thin and regular parting tools. You can make your own fluted parting tool.
Re: Parting tool question...
Ken Vaughan
I love these questions because the answer generally is - depends on what you want to do =
for sizing cuts in spindle turning it is really hard to beat the diamond shape, and the flutes on that specialty version tend leave a score where I do not want it later. (I know I can cut over size - but that defeats the purpose of a sizing cut)
I am learning the bedan, and have a P&N 3/8 parting tool and that is good for some work such as tenons.
Generall all around -- diamond is hard to beat
Hi Bill,
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
You said "You can make your own fluted parting tool."
Any tips on how?
Scott, who likes making his own tools.
Thanks!
Thanks everyone!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Being a nubie to turning, I thought they were only used for cutting off turnings from waste ends.
Boy, I have a lot to learn...
Re: Parting tool question...
Barry Irby
The Local turning club recently had Jimmy Clewes in for a demo. He insisted the regular flat sided parting tool was the thing to have. Said the diamond shaped one tends to move to side. Claims it would turn the end of a spindle into a cone if you are not really working at it.
I can not figure out why a diamond parting tool would do that any more than a flat sided one. Seems to be something beyond "physics".
I have a diamond one and really like it. Also have a thin one I made out of a piece of "woodmizer" Bandsaw blade. Great when you need a thin one.
Another thought
Barry Irby
And old kitchen knife might make a pretty good one. Grind the sharp edge down to flatten it and sharpen the business end so that the thick edge is at the cutting point.
Re: Parting tool question...
john lucas
I agree Barry. I have both flat and diamond parting tools. I prefer the diamond. It cuts deeper before having to make a clearance cut and seems to cut with less effort. I don't know why it would cut a cone unless you don't sharpen it correctly. I frequently use it to face off a piece and keep it perfectly flat. I wouldn't think you could do that if it forced you to cut a cone.
Another thought, Ahhh yes,
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
But Isn't that the way one makes a "thin" paring tool 
Re: Hi Bill,
Bill --Jacksonville NC
This procedure works with diamond or regular parting tool. Basically put your parting tool on corner of your grinding wheel push lightly until have small tits or vee on the end of your parting tool. Looks just like fluted parting tool you buy when finished.
Yes must turn the grinder on, use a tool rest or free hand.
My Bad, you did say "not thin", but...
Barry Irby
just start with a thicker knife. Perhaps a machete or a sword. Hmm? A Samurai Sword should make and excellent parting tool. Considering its intended purpose part wood should be no problem.
Re: Hi Bill,
Richard Allen
I am not as talented as you are.
When I tried this method of making my own fluted parting tool I was less than impressed with the results. The fluted parting tool did not cut as cleanly as I had expected. In fact the cut was more ragged than my sharp regular parting tool.
Years latter when I purchased a fluted parting tool I found the tool to cut clean.
Re: Hi Richard,
Bill --Jacksonville NC
Richard not sure talent has anything to do modifying a parting tool. Far too many people have done it. Yes, my parting tool cut cleanly after modifying. Like you not that impressed, re-sharpening restored my parting tool to normal.
Samurai Sword
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Sweet! Excepting I'd never... Excalibur on the other hand...
I have a certain love for Hatori Hanzo steel... 
If wrong my spelling is, forgive my spelling.