Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Order To Chaos

Posts

Order To Chaos

#1

Order To Chaos

charlie belden

In an NPR interview with Stephen Sondheim, Terry Gross asked Sondheim if he was influenced by jazz. In his answer he used the he provided what I think is an interesting definition "art is finding form in chaos".

This might apply to what we do.

In any give piece of a tree there appears to be things going every which way - often interlocked or wavy and bubbly. And we take that bit of chaos, constrain it on an axis - and spin it - often it wobbles as it spins. Then we take a sharp piece of steel and to those unfamiliar with turning, appear to apply its cutting edge to the spinning wood in what looks like a suicidal act of a crazy person - twisting it, pivoting it - wood flying - body bobbing, weaving, swaying. And from what must surely seem chaotic, a form appears and the beauty of the wood is revealed - and a piece results which sings, or a almost dances, maybe tells a tale or pulls at heart strings - form found in chaos.

Or maybe it's just a piece of wood we've danced with as we hummed or sang or whistled.

Re: Order To Chaos

#2

Re: Order To Chaos

Betty

Charlie,

I enjoyed reading your thoughts on linking woodturning to chaos from an interview you heard on NPR, an interview about jazz. I can see that in some manner we turners are putting in order something chaotic. But I'm wondering if a tree (or wood) would be consider chaos? It seems to me that trees and wood are ordered and maybe cutting a tree down is a chaotic activity. But once we've done the cutting, then we need to create something in order to restore order.

I think of the process of making my turned and carved sculptures as taking something that's already lovely and ordered (the completed turning), then creating chaos (the initial carving, which is quite messy), then restoring order to the chaos to end up with a finished turned-and-carved sculpture. I guess I think of trees in the same way. As they grow, they are bring order to chaos, turning all sorts of things into an orderly thing called a tree. Then we humans cut down that tree, disturbing the order. Eventually we restore order (or what we label as order) by making the things we call wood-turned objects. Rather jazzy!

Thanks for the wake-up thought this morning. I'll be pondering these ideas today -- I rather enjoy thinking of my sculptures as making my own jazz. --Betty

Re: Order To Chaos

#3

Ellis Walentine

That's why I...

Ellis Walentine

... always celebrate any tree I cut down on our property by turning a little pot or bowl or something from it, as an ongoing reminder of that tree and an homage to the beauty lurking inside it.

Nice thoughts, Charlie.

Ellis


Re: Order To Chaos

#4

Re: Order To Chaos

Carole Valentine

Don't know that I could ever look at a tree and consider it to be chaos. If anything, maybe we take an intricately ordered piece of nature and turn it into chaos by hacking it up and making it into something that appears symmetrical and pleasing (or not!) to our humanly egotistical eyes. ;)

Re: Order To Chaos

#5

Re: Order To Chaos

Bill Howatt

I certainly do a lot of "improvising" when I turn a piece.

Bill

Re: Order To Chaos

#6

Steven Antonucci

There is order everywhere

steven antonucci

The universe is extremely well ordered. Chaos is a man-made construct. It comes from square peg and round holes...

As a woodturner, my job is to not mess with that order too much to convey the order, not create chaos. I need to understand the order to some degree, and the more in tune with the natural world I am, the easier it is to do it.

If you look at science, we're all made of the same stuff, with the same mathematical formulas governing how things go together. It's everywhere. Follow the rules, and stuff just works...

Steve

Re: Order To Chaos

#7

Re: Order To Chaos, ??????

Russ Fairfield

Let me see if I am understanding what you are saying.

We look at a natural living tree that has beauty in and of itself.

We kill the tree by cutting it down.

We cut it up into little square blocks.

We drain the life blood (water) out of it with what we call drying.

Then we make the dead remains of the tree into something that we see as appealing or useful, but unlike anything that exists in nature.

And you call this "bringing order to chaos".

Sorry Charlie, that may be your definition, but not mine.

Re: Order To Chaos

#8

Steven Antonucci

kind of a morbid perspective?

steven antonucci

A great many woodturners that I know will only work with wood from a tree that was already dead. Even if it is standing, cutting it down doesn't make it any deader...

We cut it into little blocks because our lathes won't handle a tree turnk spinning with branches flailing. not mine at least.

We make it into shapes that don't occur in nature, but use natural proportions. We give it new life and and new purpose. I am sure that the tree doesn't really care, since it was already dead.

Smile. it's a sunny day, and the trees have leaves again.

S

Re: Order To Chaos

#9

Re: That's why I...

Carole Valentine

Ellis, what is that wood? I have a bowl I made from a chunk that was labeled "cherry" but it has a lot of the same colors in it your piece does. Have never seen colors like that in cherry around here. I am beginning to think it was mislabeled and is actually some sort of plum.

Re: Order To Chaos

#10

Re: Order To Chaos

clay foster

Charlie,

The chaos is not in the medium that makers work with, but the cacophony of ideas and images and emotions that are swirling around in our minds. When we bring harmony and organization to those, we have powerful and successful art.

Re: Order To Chaos

#11

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Order To Chaos

Barb Siddiqui

How about this perspective:

Chaos is in the myriad possibilities Clay is describing as the cacophony of ideas.

Order is in the Action of the hands, the Doing.

This is reminiscent of the old adage, "The longest journey begins with a single step" and "Just Begin."

Regardless what is being made, whether it is Art or practice, some kind of order is being made out of the jumble of possibilities leading to nothing unless one is selected.

Re: Order To Chaos

#12

Ellis Walentine

You got it, Carole -- plum

Ellis Walentine

Re: Order To Chaos

#13

Re: Order To Chaos

Barbara Gill

I find nothing at all chaotic about a tree or any part of one.