Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

Posts

Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#1

Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

Barbara Gill

Within the last year I have been amazed to hear about the amount of blatent copying of different tools and other woodturning products. It has affected my buying practices right down to the different companies that knowingly carry these products. Molly mentioned one. If you get a chance spend some time talking to some of the "old timers". You will most likely be as amazed as I.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#2

Re: This is certainly not a unique .......

JamieDonaldson

...situation in the world and societies today. So many people (and even countries!) are trying to make a fast buck without having to work for an honest dollar. The most unfortunate thing is that I don't see any reason to expect it to change for the better any time in the future.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#3

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

brian.mcinturff

Barbara,

The one I see most often and seems like everyone and their brother is trying to market on internet forums is Craigs Easy Rougher. Then there was the Elbo tool fiasco, and then the rumblings from I think it was Cryogenics or something like. I know PSI was really causing a stink over some of their practices. Until I read about Bonnie and the threading jig below I hadn't really heard about there being a problem with Baxter. Care to enlighten us on some others?

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#4

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

Barbara Gill

Nope. It is not something that should be detailed by me or any one else here other than as a direct response as was done below.

Since all my knowledge is second hand I would not be inclined to give specifics.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#5

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

brian.mcinturff

Understood Barbara. I don't know why I even asked as it would just open up all kinds of bad conversation. I've been away for awhile so I wasn't really think smart. Thanks for actually not saying!

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#6

A contrary opinion--slightly OT

Dinyar Chavda

With due respect, Barbara, and without knowing the specifics of what you are referring to, I have to say that, in general, I disagree with your basic premise that, if I understand it correctly, implies that copying is necessarily a bad thing. I agree that copying something may be harmful to the original maker, but, as Jamie points out, that is the way things are in almost any industry. What seems to be missing from the current discussion is the benefit to the consumer of copying, even blatant copying. Think about the original IBM PC that legitimized the PC business. I believe that the original IBM PCs with a basic usable configuration sold for over $3000. However, within a short time, largely because of the business acumen of Bill Gates, the IBM clones flooded the market, driving down the price of the machines. Some of them were nothing more than reverse-engineered products. Others made improvements, like the Compaq luggable. The net result was that the consumer benefitted tremendously, but IBM lost its dominance.

The same thing happened in cars with the Japanese originally copying our products (remember the snide comments about the lawn-mower engines in Honda cars?), and then constant improving them (as the Japanese have done through the centuries in so many areas).

Competition is a harsh reality in the business world (and the selling of turning tools and equipment is a business). To expect that just because you invented something means that no one else can make it is naive. Even with the strongest of legal protection, competitors reverse-engineer your products and the only way to stay ahead is to follow the practice of eating your young (before the competition eats them). There are very few companies who have constantly made their own products obsolete, and thereby stayed ahead of the competition--Sony in the 80s and 90s, Intel, and Apple come to mind.

I am not saying that copying is morally or ethically right--that is the subject of another discussion. But the reality of business is that someone somewhere is going to look at your products and think that they can make a profit by either selling the same item for less, and then, over time, possibly improving it. Evolution is a harsh process.

Don't want to start an argument---just stating a different viewpoint.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#7

Patented?

John K Jordan

I didn't see mentioned anywhere one basic principle: any person or company who invents and disseminates (sells, publishes, demonstrates, describes) a product or intellectual property without the protection of a patent is basically giving it away to the world.

If the design is a good one, it is almost guaranteed and expected that it will be copied and possibly improved, and sold.

If you have a great design and want exclusive rights, patent it before releasing it, be prepared to to defend it vigorously, and hit the market fast and hope to make some money before the market is flooded by the imported knockoffs. Understand that the process to patent and defend is overwhelmingly time-consuming and impossibly expensive except for the wealthy. It may be better for the little guy to just give away the design from the start and settle for basking in glory. I don't like this either, but I believe this is the way it is.

Note: I claim no knowledge of the law other than what I was told by our own corporate lawyers. (I hold multiple patents that took years and a small fortune to obtain. So far this year I've earned just over eight dollars.)

JKJ

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#8

Old Folks

Bill -- Jacsonville NC

Yes, there is both knock-offs and simultaneous designed tools and equipment for woodturning. You will find threading jigs traced back to ornamental wood lathes. Most of today�s threading jigs adapted from those used on metal working lathes.

Bonnie Klein, introduced her threading jig for mini lathes in 1992. During the same time a full size lathe, had a 12� swing and 1� x 8 TPI spindle. Headstock on that lathe slid along the ways, made in Europe had optional threading jig and ornamental kits. I cannot find that lathe on the internet think made in Belgium. Know could not find a US vendor back then.

Yes, a small change to get around copyright or patent laws done every day. That�s the price of success!

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#9

Re: Patented?

Don at Central Illinois

Just make sure you report that $8 to the IRS, or you could really be in big trouble. :b

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#10

Re: Patented?

Carol Reed

There is the perception that patenting protects the inventor. Nothing could be further from the truth. Patenting provides a legal position from which the lawyers may pursue retribution from those who copy - if you have enough money to pay the lawyers. Will you win? - maybe. Will the lawyers win? - always.

For the little guy, make it, flood the market a quickly as possible, take the money and run. Someone with more money will follow and make more money. That is the reality of the market place. BTDT. Several times. And spent some serious money until I discovered the game.

If the competition has deeper pockets, there is no "winning" for the originator.

$8, huh, John. You've "won!" LOL!

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#11

Re: A contrary opinion--slightly OT

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

But Barbara has a point -- not every company is motivated by a desire to improve the product they offer the public. The almighty dollar often trumps altruism.

Last week the New England Journal of Medicine published an article describing the steps one drug company has taken to capture the marketing of a classic drug used to treat gout. Colchicine has been used for hundreds, if not thousands, of years as an effective therapy to terminate acute gout attacks.

However, this old drug was never formally approved by the FDA back in 1938 when other old drugs were grandfathered in as approved for specific indications.

A long story, but the bottom line is that someone in this drug company found the loophole, applied to the FDA to market colchicine as a drug to treat acute gout and that company has received a three year exclusive marketing award.

Same drug, same therapeutic use, but now this drug will cost the gout patient not 9 cents per tablet, but $4.85 a tablet.

There are many other examples of similar corporate misadventures (to be kind) just in the pharmaceutical industry.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#12

Re: A contrary opinion--slightly OT

Dinyar Chavda

Emmett, I agree completely that Barabara has a point. Nor do I assume that any company is motivated to improve the product that they copy, nor that the consumer always benefits. The laws "governing" the pharmaceutical industry in the US make me scratch my head in wonder!

It's just that if someone can figure out a way to make a product cheaper and still make a profit, they will do so. Is it right? I don't know, particularly when it involves what we consider to be sweatshop labor (Is sweatshop labor in a 3rd world country necessarily wrong? From our viewpoint, yes. From their perspective, it may be the best alternative they have available.) There--I've annoyed both liberals and conservatives with that.

Staying within the computer industry example, Dell and Compaq legitimized the IBM clone business (I remember calling around for clones in the old days prior to the Internet, and encountering only people with Asian accents!) Compaq did it partly with a different product, i.e., a hernia-inducing "portable", and Dell did it with a different manufacturing model. What is interesting is that Compaq no longer exists as an entity, but Dell has managed to fight off cheaper competitors, although the jury is always out.

I think my main point is that just because we are a craft (or art--take your pick) does not render us immune to business practices endemic to other industries.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#13

Steven Antonucci

What has value?

Steven Antonucci

Is it the idea? The manufacturing method? Or the tool?

Clearly, folks have developed better products based upon other people's ideas. Clearly, folks have developed better products based upon others manufacturing methods. Clearly, better products have been developed by evaluating the tool and putting new ideas and manufacturing methods to work.

I agree that ethically, it's somewhat distasteful to me personally to have someone market a direct copy with no innovation for the sake of profit. The legal aspects aside, I'd prefer to buy from someone who thought about problems and solved them rather than just copying. However, copying is how innovation starts.

On another note, it is nearly impossible to innovate in today's uber connected society without "stealing" someone else's ideas, processes, and end results. We are all so incredibly connected compared to prior generations, which were bound by physical location and access to information. To say that something is "my idea" uniquely would be sort of self-centered...

Think it's bad now? Wait until the "folks who have been around" are gone, and replaced by my generation and the one that follows...

Steve

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#14

Make my day, Steve!

Dinyar Chavda

As I head off to get shots in my knees, thanks for reminding me just how old I am, and soon to be replaced!

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#15

Mike Stafford

Shhhh....John, the government will want that $8

Mike Stafford

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#16

We have the same problems, different scale

Russ Fairfield

As individuals with an idea or a product, we don't patent or hire copyright lawyers because the money isn't there. We depend on the morality and good will of the community we serve. As a community, woordturners are no better or no worse than any other group that is held together by a common interest.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#17

Steven Antonucci

none of us are so young that it's not true

Steven Antonucci

or pending...

S

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: We have the same problems, different scale

Lyle Jamieson

I like those words, Russ, morality and community. In the woodturning tool world the market it is much different then computers or pharmaceuticals. We are not talking about millions of products being sold. In the turning world, cheaper is rarely going to be better. I have seen some dangerous applications of tools being made and sold. I have numbers big enough that I could have my tool parts made in China. I have been approached by people that can make that happen for me. Yes, I could save some money and possibly block some of the copy-cats. But, MADE IN USA, means something to me. My tools will always be made in USA.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#19

Re: What has value?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

This is always a good subject... Henry Ford did it without inventing the car so did Thompson and Ellsworth in woodturning. Every product on the market has competition and for a reason... to create a better product and keep prices down. The drug companies are a great example but the same thing happens in our little world. If we only had one manufacture of each product a lathe would cost $20,000 and a bowl gouge $500 but competition between companies keeps the price down. We fight between the different companies here in North America but China has the woodturning market... Powermatic, Jet, Delta, Harbor freight, Benjamin Best.

I don't know anything about this jig from Bonnie and Best Wood but let me relay this directly from Vic (hope he doesn't mind)... Best Wood tools sold Sorby a entire set of tool rests... now Sorby has a entire new line of tool rests.

There are lawyers working right now because a company undercut anothers prices... the American way is to hire a lawyer to keep prices high? If this doesn't stop soon this will be the next mess to hit our world.

Never a dull moment.

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#20

Re: We have the same problems, different scale

Russ Fairfield

Several messages have talked about creativity and innovation.

Those of us who make videos for woodturners are experiencing the same thing as Sony and the big recording companies. The only difference is that our volume isn't big enough to go after the rippers. It takes a lot of time and considerable expense to make a video, but anybody with a computer can sell a video at 1/2 price if they rip someone else's DVD. Where's the creativity and innovation in that??

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#21

Steven Antonucci

It's a different world Russ

Steven Antonucci

First of all, you have to account for the fact that US laws only apply to the US, and not the entire planet. There are many places that simply do not respect Intellectual Property of any kind. They rip, copy, crack and plaigarize willfully.

You have to either make it too hard (read: expensive) for them to do so, via encryption and/or vigorous defense of your IP, or do it in such a way where they cannot be competitive with you. If videos cost a lot to produce, perhaps the bootstrap method is the way to go (A Handycam on a tripod in your garage)? Lower your costs to produce, and you can either improve your margins or pass on the savings.

Conceptually, it is illegal to photocopy a book, install software you didn't pay for, PDF a magazine article for a friend... but most people do, right?

I agree with Doug. Competition is healthy, and it's here to stay. I make my living by figuring out things my competitors are still scratching their heads over. If cost is your only competitive advantage, it won't last for long...

S

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#22

Don Pencil

Re: What has value?

Don Pencil

Doug,

I agree to a point. I certainly can't speak for other manufacturers. I personally have been manufacturing three product lines of which two are now going to be duplicated by others. I do know that it has been an uphill battle to get these lines into the main stream for a host of reasons. There has been a lot of R & D into them and years of giving out samples, attending expensive trade shows, advertising and all the rest that goes with it.

I have not raised the prices very much if at all to the consumer or the distributors who would carry the products in the past eight years. In some cases, without competition, I have even been able to lower the cost to everyone.

Now that the products are proven and catching on, for the first time the market is about to experience the debut simular products just because they can. They will not be lower in cost. One is already out and it will not even be improved. It's quality is not as good and the selection of variables substantially fewer. The consumer will not be the benefactor of the new line. A smaller product line, reduced manufacturing cost, and a higher price will benefit who? This will also split up the market in a place where there is a very limited customer base in the first place.

When I think of all the products I could have made that were much like or the same as the others and didn't.

I do wonder where this is all going? There is such a big push on now to get out in many cases what is basically the same tool with just another label.

You ever feel like bangin' your head against the wall. I have bruises on mine today.

I know that it is just the way things are. We are free and the cost of that is very high. I am peronally glad to pay that cost. I do hope that all who are trying hard to make it continue to do so and do it with the highest standards.

Be Well,

Don

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#23

Steven Antonucci

Brand loyalty matters...

Steven Antonucci

You can capture some of the market with price, but you'll never get all of it. There are lots of people that will pay for "Made in the USA" (I'm one) and or quality manufacturers producing small runs of high quality products.

Part of any product manufacturers day to day business HAS to be building brand equity. If you are a commodity supplier, you will always be pressed to produce it cheaper to stay competitive. The name on the tool HAS to matter to the guy holding it, or your just another supplier...

Good products at good prices aren't enough...

Good relationships make the difference.

S

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#24

Re: What has value?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Don, I don't own any of your products but I have examined much of what you sell and am impressed by the quality. I am curious about the Scorpion hollowing tool. It is an obvious copy of the Stewart armbrace tool. Even though it is less in price you have made some improvements. I have been using a Stewart tool for many years but I have recommended your tool to some of my students. Question: Before you started marketing the tool, did you discuss the fact that you would be selling the copy of Dennis's tool with Dennis himself?

Wally

Re: Talk To The People Who Have Been Around

#25

Don Pencil

Re: What has value?

Don Pencil

Wally, thank you for your kind comments. I do not believe I have ever met Mr. Stewart.

First, my personal business rule for manufacturing any product: If I cannot make substantial advances or design improvements in a porduct, while at the same time improving material quality, and providing all of the above at a savings to the consumer then I do not get into it. More on that later.

In that it is a hand held pistle grip system that is about where the simularities end.

The curved tool is very diffent than a Stewart in that the Scorpion was designed as an inboard and outboard tool in one. The tip is the same on the top and bottom so the tool can be reversed. The curve of the tool was designed by me for doing what I believe is the best job for an "all around" hollow vessel tool. I have never acually used or measured a Stewart so that I would not be copying it. I had used "home mades" before making the Scorpion. I do not know how near to the Stewart design those were. The handle is made at a completely different ergonomic angle that the Stewart and puts the wrist a straight rather than a bent angle. The forearm support for the tool is detachable giving the user two tools (pistol grip handle & forearm supported handle) for the price of one. The user can also shorten the length of the support with a hacksaw to accomodate those with smaller arms. I do not know about the Stewart but the Sorby forearm support is rivitted compared to the welded Scorpion. The Scorpion is chrome plated and the Stewart was not. Although the Scorpion can be purchased individual parts it is normally sold as a complete system with all of the tools and a huge variety of bits in the set. The Scorpion comes with four adaptors for the handle making it possible to use any tool from 3/4" down to 3/8" or even less. The Scorpion has an adaptor for the straight tool which allows all bits and tools used on the curved tool to be used on the straight tool. There is a small sharpening jig included that helps with the sharpening of the 3/16" bit and the flat scraper bits.

All of this is available for under $240.00. I hope that I have met the conditions for upgrading, improvement, and value in this. I had always said publicly as late as last month that Stewart was I believe the first in this tool style and one sould remove your hat when speaking his name. The Stewart tool did not advance whereas the Scorpion has been advancing the design of this style tool.

I have always said that the day would come when someone might well take this tool to a level I have not.

I do not make a captured system even though it would have been in my best interest to do so. I used to send customers to Lyle if they wanted a D-bar. I cannot make the same advances to his system for less money to the consumer that I did with the Scorpion so I stayed out. I have done this conserning many products and will continue that policy.

As this was not a "copy" of the Stewart tool and he wasn't advancing the tool design I did not talk to him.

I hope this covers it.

I would be happy to cover how the other tools I make fit the policy if you would like to know.

It has been a while since I've seen you. I look forward to seeing later this year or early next.

Be Well,

Don