Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Oval Bowl questions

Posts

Oval Bowl questions

#1

Oval Bowl questions

Barry Irby

Lets say you turn a green bowl 12" in diameter and 5" deep and let it dry. It generally becomes and oval or some irregular shape. My question is does it become longer and narrower, say 12 1/2" by 11 1/2" or does it stay the same length and become narrower?

I know there are many variables including grain orientation species of wood and whether the grain is "regular" or some of the wild stuff we seek out. Just wondering?

Re: Oval Bowl questions

#2

Re: Oval Bowl questions

Jorge Casta�eda

Barry,

More or less it stays the same length, the main change is it becomes narrower, the sides drop.

in other words, the dimension along the grain stays, and the dimension across the grain diminishes, it gives slightly the looks of a viking boat to the bowl.

capito?

Re: Oval Bowl questions

#3

Re: Oval Bowl questions

John K Jordan

The wood shrinks in all three directions, longitudinal, tangential, and radial. The longitudinal shrinkage (along the grain) is close to insignificant. The tangential shrinkage (along the rings) is the most severe and the radial (across the rings) is less. The Tangential/Radial (T/R) shrinkage ratio is a pretty good indicator of the stability of a particular species of wood.

There are tables of typical shrinkage in various species. It is hard to go wrong with the book Understanding Wood by R. Bruce Hoadley:

http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Wood-REV-Bruce-Hoadley/dp/1561583588

However, I understand the shrinkage tables are pretty good for a block or board, but I suspect the geometry of a side-grain turned bowl rim would make calculations difficult since the "poles" of the rim are not supported by continuous wood fibers but by a complex curving structure and different parts of that structure are warping in different ways.

This is interesting:

http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/Tip29%20-%20Moisture%20Content%20and%20Wood%20Shrinkage.pdf

Re: Oval Bowl questions

#4

Re: Oval Bowl questions

John Jordan

All the things John K. told you are true, also: It will become measurably longer to some degree. If the bowl is completely open, it will go more oval than if it has a somewhat "closed" shape. The closed shape has a mechanical strength that will resist the "squeezing" across the width. This squeezing elongates the bowl more than just the shrinkage accounts for. :)

There's an article on my website regarding this if you are interested.

John

Re: Oval Bowl questions

#5

Re: Oval Bowl questions

robo hippy

My answer would be that it moves in all directions. There is little movement up and down the tree as in spindle or long board orientation, but a lot around the tree as in flat grain direction or width of the board direction. Of course, there is a lot of differences between tree species as to how much it will move. I had never heard that they will get longer, but have noticed that wall thickness will vary a lot as well. I have had some that turned into triangles, some where the ends folded in, some that stayed flat and turned into footballs. You just never know.

End grain is different from this. Not as much movement, but more towards the outside of the tree, and less towards the center.

robo hippy