Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Posts

FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#1

FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Craig Daymon

I was extremely disappointed in the FWW article, especially after the excellent article in American Woodturner on the subject. This article sounded more like something sponsored by a (or multiple) chuck manufacturers. And, to me, badly written.

On the first page he mentions using a smaller chuck on a larger lathe, stating that you would have to use an adapter to do so and that that would add vibration. Well, what is his definition of a smaller chuck? I used a Talon and a Stronghold on my PM3520, both had the proper adapter. I know he meant adding a secondary adapter, something that does seem foolish, but this has NOTHING to do with the size of the chuck.

Certainly a chuck adds convenience over a faceplate, but his trashing of a faceplate seemed rather one sided. I really don't see a 3" faceplate restricting my access to the bottom of a bowl much over what a chuck would do. I'm certainly not going to turn a 10" bowl using spigot jaws and the screws aren't reaching that much further than the required tenon for the chuck. (McDonnell jaws might be the exception here, but only one chuck manufacturer sells them and as far as I know not in the U.S.)

So, obviously I didn't like the article. What did you think (especially in comparing it to the American Woodturner article).

-Craig

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#2

Re: As so often happens with FWW.....

JamieDonaldson

...articles, the author/article has limited real world information. They often seem to be written for a generic audience rather than specific info for experienced turners, another reason I have been debating whether I would continue my charter subscription. I do occasionally gain useful information from a finish/finishing article, just enough to keep me reading when it arrives.

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#3

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

john lucas

I just reread it. I don't know what he's talking about when he refers to chucks only fitting 2 sizes. I checked and you can get inserts for the better chucks that fit, 5/8" not thread, 3/4x16, 1/x8, 1 1/4/x8 and M33. There are not any vibration issues. I'm guessing he meant buying an adaptor such as 1 1/4x8 to m33 that actually extends the chuck out. That's not necessary for most chucks anymore.

I found his comment about cutting the dovetail for chucks to be tedious. I've never used one of the special dovetail cutters. I just use whatever tool is in my hand, parting tool, skew, spindle gouge etc. Make an educated guess at the shape of the dovetail and cut it. I've never had any problems and it only takes a few seconds to cut.

As someone who grew up with faceplates I don't have a problem with them at all other than being slower to use. They are definitely more solid as long as the wood is sound.

I will second his opinion, you get what you pay for. I've never had a single problem with the top brand chucks. I've had several problems with the lesser brands.

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#4

Re: Another chuck article *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

Take a look at this one. It was written by a woodturner (me) for woodturners. It is an honest opinion (mine), names are mentioned and evaluated, and it is everything I can say about chucks. It was revised in October, 2009.


Chucks - buying and using them

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#5

Bill Blasic

Re: Another chuck article

Bill Blasic

Russ,

I won't argue any of your points as everyone has their opinions. The Titan chuck does accept all the jaws in the Nova line. The Titan Power Grip Jaws only fit the Titan chuck as they have three holes. When I got my Titan it came with the two hole Power Grip jaws. I don't know why anyone would want to use all the other jaws on the Titan chuck but they do fit.

Bill

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#6

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Doug Wolf

I must be lucky because I had a NOVA G3 chuck with a 3/4" x 16 insert that I used on my old lathe that I now use on my 3520B with a JET 3/4" x 16 to 1 1/4" x 8 extension adaptor. I honest can't tell the difference between my 2 SN2's with the 1 1/4" x 8 inserts and the G3 with the extension.

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#7

Re: Another chuck article

Gordon Seto

Here is the picture of a Titan with 75 mm bowl jaws, Titan Power Grip (3 screws) and regular Power Grip (2 screws).

The Titan has 3 screws per slide, but it is backward compatible with all other Nova Jaws that use 2 screws.


img

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#8

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Jim Sebring

The range of adjustment on the G3 and the SN2 is identical. The biggest difference between these two chucks is the diameter.

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#9

Author of article?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Craig,

Can you tell me the authors name? I gave up my subscription a few years ago and could not find it on the FWW site.

I may have to check out my favorite book store to check it out.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#10

Bill Blasic

Re: Another chuck article

Bill Blasic

Gordon,

Three of my most favorite jaws!

Bill

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#11

....Range of Motion

Ralph

Bill, that Titan as a broader range of motion then the Nova series. In that the Titan will cover a slightly larger range of opening and closing then the Nova

Why this is an issue is the Colejaws. With the Titan, the Colejaws will move more from "closed' to "open" then the spacing between buttons. This is not true with my ol SN2, or midi

Personally I wonder what Teknatool is doing with the Titan, the rumor is they are redesigning it, which is why it's just about impossible to find one right now

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#12

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

robo hippy

The author is Ralph Tursini.

I wrote a letter to the editor. I don't know if it will make the magazine or not. I think the article was fine for flat workers, who know little or nothing about lathes and chucks, but for the dedicated woodturner, not so good. I disagree strongly with his contention that a recess is weak due to compression issues, and the tenon is much better. The wood is compressed in either situation. The wood doesn't care if it is being squeezed, or pressed, compression in both circumstances. I disagree with him stating that a dove tail is more difficult to make. Attaching a bowl to a chuck is basic joinery, just like in furniture, but it is temporary. Fit is important, and there are a number of ways to accomplish the same task.

robo hippy

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#13

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Bill Howatt

No real argument but for internal tenons you must be much more aware of the quantity and quality of the wood surrounding the hole. It is easy to breakout the internal if the wood isn't there but you can tighten all you want on an external tenon.

I never use dovetail jaws since I got rid of my old chuck and I now use Oneway regular jaws but it could be the author read a bunch of those articles usually accompanying special dovetail tool ads that talk about a dramatic reduction in dovetail holding power if the angle isn't right.

I used to just eyball it and didn't have any major holding issues but any dovetail jaw pales in comparison to Oneway's profiled, IMO.

Bill

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#14

Re: Author of article?

Craig Daymon

The author was Ralph Tursini a "professional turner and turning instructor" from Cambridge, VT.

I, personally, was not at all impressed by the article. I don't think it catered very well to either the novice or the professional. The part I mentioned originally about the adapters is exactly something that would confuse a novice. The Oneway Talon and Stronghold both require an adapter, but not the type the author mentions and there is no distinction made between the two. He mentions the screw center and the spur center in the same discussion, but a screw center will hold a blank to the chuck (in much the same manner as a faceplate with screws) and a spur center must be used with a tail center and is only really a convenience to not having to remove the chuck to put in a morse taper spur center. (Though, I've found most spur centers can be inserted into chucks quite securely for going between centers without having to lay out cash for a "special" spur center...at $35!)

-Craig

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#15

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

robo hippy

Any time you use a chuck for mounting a bowl on the lathe, you are using basic mortice and tenon joinery. The chuck can be either a tenon when used in a recess, or a mortice when uses on a tenon/stub/spigot. Just as in furniture joinery, fit is important. Too loose as in a big recess and small jaws, or very small jaws on a large tenon, you don't get a good sound grip on the wood. Too tight, mostly here it is over tightening the jaws, your joint can be under a lot of stress and a catch or any extra stress can cause it to fail. This it true for both recess and tenon. You need a certain amount of wood to take the stress of turning and tightening, and this means a properly sized tenon (about 1/4 the diameter of the bowl) and a properly sized recess with an adequate shoulder to support the expansion pressure. Again, about the foot is about 1/3 to 1/4 the diameter of the bowl with the recess centered and having proper depth. The closer the angles match, the better your grip is. Adequate shoulders should be 1 1/2 inch on larger bowls, and down to 1/4 on smaller ones, depending a lot on how aggressive you turn and size of the material. If depth or length is too short, you lose strength, as well as if it is too deep/long. Any cracks, punky wood, or bark inclusions seriously weaken the hold.

As to jaw holding power, smooth straight jaws have the least holding power. Nothing to really 'hold' the wood. The dovetail is a mechanical joint, and is used extensively in furniture work for that reason. You get slightly more metal on the wood. The angles lock things into place. The Oneway jaws with the ribs/serrations actually puts teeth into the wood, and when the wood compresses, you end up with more metal on the wood.

Properly made, they all work fine. I prefer the dove tailed jaws. I can drill a recess on the top of the bowl, and expand into it, turn the outside and cut a recess, then reverse, core, then finish turn. The chuck never has to come off the lathe, no screw center to put in and remove.

robo hippy

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#16

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Russ Fairfield

I think you are all being unfairly critical of the FWW article, and its author. They were two different articles aimed at 2 different audiences.

The FWW article was written for a general audience who are not woodturners, and as a general information article with few specifics, it served its purpose. The article in the AAW Journal was published in a magazine specifically for woodturners and aimed at the beginner and immediate skill levels; and as information for that audience, it served its purpose well.

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#17

The article logically only makes sense FOR turners

Craig Daymon

I disagree Russ. My biggest problem with the article is the way it puts the information together in such a vague manner as to not be clear in its descriptions. It makes a direct comparison to faceplates that is, in my opinion, misleading. Fine Woodworking is always held up as the pinnacle of woodworking magazines. That should mean woodturning as well. Certainly, a simple article on 4 jaw chucks and the convenience they offer, along with the accessories available, could have been written that would not have delved as deeply as the AAW article, but that is NOT what FWW gave us.

The article stated that using a "smaller" chuck on a "larger" lathe requires an adapter. This is just plain wrong. Using a chuck configured for a smaller (or larger) spindle can be used on a lathe with a larger (or smaller) spindle with an adapter. Or simply just saying that if the chuck threads do not match your spindle, adapters are available. That would be accurate without being overly complex.

Although it is possible to turn large (heavier) turnings using a chuck, a faceplate is the safer approach. His statements, "Faceplates leave deep screw holes", well, turn it around and turn off the screw holes in the same manner you would turn off the tenon used to hold the piece in the chuck! The same "overzealous hollowing" that will potentially expose the screws wold also result in a funnel when the tenon is turned off.

If this article was not meant for people that would be turning on a moderately frequent basis, who is it written for? Someone that has $300 lying around to buy a chuck for turning 1 bowl? It only makes sense for turners.

My opinion.

-Craig

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#18

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

Ralph Tursini

HI Folks,

I got an email indicating that there was a bit of chatter here about the chuck article I've written. It's been a while since I've visited this message board and it's good to see that it's still lively.

Your comments are all very detailed and astute. Thank you for the constructive ones, especially. Being a very select group, it is helpful to hear your critical feedback in an open forum like this.

This is the first article like this that I've written for FWW or any outfit with a national distribution so there was some learning happening on the fly. If you haven't had the experience, I'll let you know that it is not unlike other creative endeavors - requiring the balance of expression with constraint. In addition, it is a team that produces the final article so there is a dance that occurs between the writer, the editor, and other publication staff such as the art directors. I would have loved to write a comprehensive treatise on the subject (that's what my first draft looked like!), but the reality is that there is limited space, and it is targeted to a general woodworking audience.

It is exciting to have the opportunity to offer some of my experience to those who are receptive. I did find it challenging though, to balance an introductory survey type article with detailed information on the subject. To the person pointing out the confusing wording/language about a smaller chuck on a larger lathe. You're correct, I could have been more clear.

tenon vs recess: I stand behind my opinion that a tenon is stronger. I also believe it to be more versatile, and easier to turn accurately than a recess - especially one requiring a dovetail. Having taught hundreds of students, poor shaping of this joint is one of the most common oversights in bowl turning beginners. All it takes is a tiny bump between the cheek and shoulder of the tenon to prevent the face of the jaws from contacting the tenon shoulder. No contact increases vibration and holding strength considerably. Sure, there are exceptions depending on the application as we all know. In actual practice, we tap into our breadth of experience and use our best judgment (while standing outside the lathe's firing line!).

To those who seemed to have question about my experience or ability, check out the "about" link on my website vermontwoodturning.com or better yet, stop by some time in person.

Regards,

Ralph Tursini

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

#19

Re: FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted

John Dillbeck

I to think the tenon is stronger and easier to use although no empirical data to back that up. One thing I always do, wasn't mentioned in other replies, when first clamping the tenon on the chuck I will mark with a sharp pencil each side of #1 dovetail and always use that position for all subsequent remounts.