FWW article on 4 jaw chucks - opinions wanted
Craig Daymon
I was extremely disappointed in the FWW article, especially after the excellent article in American Woodturner on the subject. This article sounded more like something sponsored by a (or multiple) chuck manufacturers. And, to me, badly written.
On the first page he mentions using a smaller chuck on a larger lathe, stating that you would have to use an adapter to do so and that that would add vibration. Well, what is his definition of a smaller chuck? I used a Talon and a Stronghold on my PM3520, both had the proper adapter. I know he meant adding a secondary adapter, something that does seem foolish, but this has NOTHING to do with the size of the chuck.
Certainly a chuck adds convenience over a faceplate, but his trashing of a faceplate seemed rather one sided. I really don't see a 3" faceplate restricting my access to the bottom of a bowl much over what a chuck would do. I'm certainly not going to turn a 10" bowl using spigot jaws and the screws aren't reaching that much further than the required tenon for the chuck. (McDonnell jaws might be the exception here, but only one chuck manufacturer sells them and as far as I know not in the U.S.)
So, obviously I didn't like the article. What did you think (especially in comparing it to the American Woodturner article).
-Craig




