Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

circular cutters...

Posts

circular cutters...

#1

circular cutters...

GaryG in MD

I'm planning to make some balls, and I've purchased a pipe to grind. I'm also interested in working on a bowl with a spherical bottom. Yes, I know I can just learn to cut it, but I like the idea in the latest issue of American Woodturner that uses a ground-down hole saw.

My question is, when using the circular cutter, does one use only the bottom part right off the tool rest, or is it safe to apply the full circumference of the cutter to the wood. I'm a little nervous about full contact until I hear that it's safe. Thanks, Gary

Re: circular cutters...

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: circular cutters...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I use the whole tool. I don't think that you would get the desired rounding action any other way. Work into it gently and you should have no trouble. Dennis

Re: circular cutters...

#3

Re: circular cutters...

John K Jordan

You have to use the full diameter, however I had better luck if the sharp edge was rounded a little on one side. Experiment.

Re: circular cutters...

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: circular cutters...

Mike Stafford

I have never used a pipe to create a round bottom or a round anything and had not seen it done until Thursday night at our club meeting.

Lan Brady from Greensboro did a terrific multiaxis ladle demonstration and showed how a sharpened section of iron pipe could be used to help refine the spherical shape of the ladle before it was mounted in a jig for hollowing.

A very well done demo and interesting technique.

Re: circular cutters...

#5

Re: circular cutters... *LINK*

Fred Holder

I've been using a one inch hole saw with the teeth ground off and mounted on a threaded rod mounted in a handle to help in the rounding of a spherical object (i.e., a ball). Today, I normally use a swinging jig to round balls, but often use the tool to help round off the ends of the ball after turning away the tenons.

One of my swinging jigs came from England's Craft Supplies, one from Vermec in Australia, and one from Fred Lindsay, using a Lindsay/Hunter Tool Assembly, from Hendersonville, North Carolina.

The hole saw needs a sharp cutting edge inside. I sharpen mine by thrusting it against a rotating disk sander. I generally rotate the tool to make sure I have a good sharp edge inside. The full face of the cutter needs to be applied to the surface of the spherical surface.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: circular cutters...

#6

How often on WoodCentral...

GaryG in MD

does one get the same answer from everyone? Not very often!

It's clear that I will be using the entire circumference of the cutter.

Thanks to everyone for the nice clear answer. ...Gary

Re: circular cutters...

#7

further explanation?

GaryG in MD

John, I would appreciate it if you would explain a little more geometrically what you mean when you say that "...if the sharp edge was rounded a little on one side." I'm having a hard time picturing exactly where the "rounded" area is. Perhaps you could give it to me in terms of pretending the circumference of the cutter were flattened and laid out like the business end of a skew. Thanks, Gary

Re: circular cutters...

#8

What if you don't want to go that route

john lucas

This is for those who don't want to regrind a hole cutter. I don't turn a lot of spheres and when I do they are all different sizes from small to large. I learned to turn spheres using a scraper and a round ring. It's more or less the same procedure. I move the ring around the sphere to find the high spots. You can see light underneath which of course highlights the low areas and makes it easy to find the high spots. Then you just cut these off with the scraper.

You can also use a flashlight with the lens removed if the front ring is round and smooth. It does the same thing as the ring but it's much easier to see the light around the low spots.

Before that I simply used the shadow method. You rotate the ball on a bunch of different axis and turn away the shadow, which is the high spot. This isn't perfect but makes a very acceptable sphere.

All in all Fred's method with the jig is the best. I have about 3 or 4 jigs I found on the web and plan to build one of them some day with some modifications of my own of course.

Re: circular cutters...

#9

Re: What if you don't want to go that route

Bill-- Jacksonville NC

Got information and made a cutter from hole saw reading Ray Hopper�s book Multi-Center Turning. Never did get it to cut.

Also made the sphere-cutting jig shown in Adventures in Woodturning by David Springett.

What worked best for me, spindle gouges and skew chisels, and lots of sandpaper.

Re: circular cutters...

#10

Re: What if you don't want to go that route

GaryG in MD

Can you expand on that a bit, Bill. Why do you think it wouldn't cut?

What was your experience with the jig shown in Adventures in Woodturning by David Springett? Good? Bad? Indifferent?

...GG

Re: circular cutters...

#11

point well taken, John...

GaryG in MD

Just seems to me that it would be easier to use a few pipes of different sizes rather than all that axis changing. I'll have to check out Fred's chucks though. Thanks, ...GG

Re: circular cutters...

#12

Re: circular cutters...

GaryG in MD

Fred, Thanks for your tip on the jigs -- I'll take a look.

When you sharpen the hole saw, you say you rotate it.

Do you mean slowly by hand, or fast in an electric drill? ...GG

Re: circular cutters...

#13

You guys are too automated

Bill Howatt

I do mine (and I don't really do that many) by laying out the dimensions for bevelling and using leather-lined cone chucks for rotating 90 degrees and some free-handing. Perfect spheres, no, but it is amazing how good you can get them with a bit of practice. Most people wouldn't notice the imperfections.

Bill

Re: circular cutters...

#14

Re: circular cutters...

Fred Holder

I place it on the tool rest and rotate it slowly by hand. I generally give it at least two revolutions to ensure that it is ground all around.

Re: circular cutters...

#15

Re: circular cutters... *LINK*

Fred Holder

You are right Bill, it does not take sophisticated tools to make balls; however, to make a specific size ball as I have to do for the Chinese Ball, the swinging jig is the best way to go. I first turn a cylinder the diameter I wish my ball to be. I then mark out and part away everything wider than the planned ball, except for a tenon on each end. I mark the center of the cylinder and align the pivot point of the swinging jig under that center line. I then cut the spherical surface with the swinging jig. Finally, I put the ball in one of my ball chucks and turn away one of the tenons freehand. I rotated the ball and turn away the other tenon. With care you get a very round ball to the planned size at least within a few thousands of an inch.

Mildred, my wife, used my swinging jig to turn the spherical shap in the wooden flask she made and I documented in the March-April 2010 issue of More Woodturning magazine. I also reported on the Lindsay Spere Cutting Jig in that issue.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: circular cutters...

#16

@centurylink.net

Bill-- Jacksonville NC

The hole cutting saw just scrapped, and not very well. I did more damage than good!

The cutting jig designed to use a scrapper. I used an old �� gouge at first, did not accomplish much. So installed a �� scrapper still not pleased with results. Getting the jig to pivot, where it needed to be a big problem for me. I fussed with tightening and loosening jig nut until frustration and called it quits.

A scrapper on the tool rest, good grip and body movement probably lot easier than a jig. I prefer my spindle gouges and skew chisels to scrappers on spheres. The three that completed ended up as dog toys on a rope.

Re: circular cutters...

#17

Re: You guys are too automated

GaryG in MD

I know what you mean, Bill. There's no replacement for practice and skill.

I just think it sounds like something fun new to try. I'm always curious. ...GG

Re: circular cutters...

#18

Re: @centurylink.net

Don Evans

I don't use any jig, just plain turnin and I can make a very good round ball if I do say so myself.

I was wondering it a hole saw would make a passable cutter? All of them I've ever seen are pretty cheap metal. The ones that say they are HSS is only HSS where the teeth are and that is welded onto the cheapest junk they can find to make the rest of it.

I assume you ground off the teeth then tried using the other metal. Opposed to a pipe which isn't good cutting metal for edge either but at least it is thicker. You may have gotten a lot of vibration at the cutting edge that ruined it.

Don

Re: circular cutters...

#19

Re: further explanation?

John K Jordan

Gary, if I sharpened the pipe all the way around, then dulled the sharp edge 1/2 of the way around, it was less "grabby". Also, for some types of wood it worked better for me if I left a burr on the pipe rather than sharpen to a knife edge. I think this made more of a scraping action.

Re: circular cutters...

#20

Re: sperical jigs

Bill-- Jacksonville NC

My lack of success does not mean do not try something!

David Springett shows how to make two types of spherical jigs (swing jig) fig.14.7 and 15.2 in his book Adventures in Woodturning. I have the 1984 edition.

I do not have the computer savvy to scan and post pictures of the two spherical jigs. Not sure, that would be legal anyway.

Just google wooden spherical jig, came up with Michael Toulouzas & David Springett You Tube demos.

Re: circular cutters...

#21

thanks Bill

GaryG in MD

I'll check it out..