Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

skews...

Posts

skews...

#1

skews...

GaryG in MD

I know that whole books and lengthy DVDs are devoted to the design and use of skews. What I would like here are some short, simple opinions on one particular aspect of the topic. Given that I am interested only in skews with rectangular cross sections, I would like to know what the practical difference is between the ones with a straight cutting edge and the ones with a slightly curved cutting edge. Who likes which and why? Is the curved one "safer" for a beginner? If so, what are its drawbacks? Thanks, Gary

Re: skews...

#2

Re: skews...

john lucas

Gary We do have different belief and argue over this about once or twice a year. For all practical purposes there really isn't any difference. I think the one you practice with the most is the one you will like. I have tried all the grinds and still have several ground different ways that I play with from time to time. I can do the same cuts with all of them but tend to favor the 2 I use the most.

Personally I don't see how a curved edge is any safer. If you let the cut get above the 1/2 way point on the edge you risk getting a catch with either one. The reason is that you are simply further away from the supporting edge and leverage takes over. The point, curve or straight is really not that much further away.

The main reason I stay with the straight or at least very slightly curved edge is that it's either for me to regrind on those occasions where the hand held diamond hones take too long to sharpen and you have to refresh the edge.

These are my opinions only and you will probably get more that sometimes lead to good discussions.

Re: skews...

#3

Re: skews...

Lance Kanaby

Alan Lacer has two excellent videos on the use of skews. These videos should answer all of your questions in a very professional way. He is also an excellent instructor.

Re: skews...

#4

Steven Antonucci

If you learn the skew, you'll have all of them

steve antonucci

I have 4, and they are all a little bit different...learned with a curved edge, so I think it's a little bit more forgiving...

S

Re: skews...

#5

Re: skews... *LINK*

Fred Holder

Gary,

I use the Hamlet skews with the rounded edges that will not dig into my tool rest. I use them with a straight grind. I've never found the curved skew to be better than the straight grind.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: skews...

#6

Re: skews...

John K Jordan

I've ground and used them both straight and curved. The biggest difference I've found is the curved cutting edge is harder to sharpen.

JKJ

Re: skews...

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: skews...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Gary,

I would argue that the curved skew is more forgiving for some cuts, especially when turning large diameter pieces. Imagine if you will that the work piece has a diameter many times the width of the skew. If you attempt a planing cut with a straight skew you will find that the shaving spans the whole width of the skew no matter how light a cut you attempt. This means that much of the downward pressure on the skew is above the middle of the skew edge and tends to suck the skew into the wood. Repeat the same process using a curved skew and you will find that light cuts produce narrower shavings which if kept near the heel of the skew are less likely to cause a catch. For this same reason it is much easier to learn to use a skew with small diameter work pieces than with large ones. Note that slicing cuts with the heel or toe of the skew are not greatly affected by the choice of profile except that curved skews necessarily have blunter angles at the toe or heel or both.

Dennis

Re: skews...

#8

Brad Vietje

I Prefer Curved, or "Radiused"

Brad Vietje

I have both, and like the curved skews better, especially for two cuts:

1. Peeling cuts to size tenons. No way will the straight edged skew do this as well in my hands as the curved edge. Right angle at toe, and smooth curve to the heel.

2. Peel/cut trimming cuts to size and smooth cylinders, with flat sides flat on the rest, and handle angled to the rest to offset the skew angle of the tool. Raffan shows this in rounding up air-dried sock in his box turning video.

I experimented with the "Lacer Two-Step" grind for about a year, and found I liked the smooth curve from toe to heel better. Sharpening is easy with a sand-buff sharpener -- just rotate the tool a bit left & right, and you're done. I would also round the edges of the rectangular stock. Oval skews are awful -- way too flimsy, and no flat reference -- a gimmick in my view.

My 3 cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: skews...

#9

Re: skews...

Russ Fairfield

There are more personal opijnions about the skew than any other tool. Here is mine.

The only important thing about a skew is that it is SHARP. It should be the sharpest tool you own. Everything else is personal preference.

The only exception might be (agreeing with Brad) that a flat peeling cut to make a tenon is easier with the curved edge. I don't see this as a big deal because I have to make a cut across the shoulder regardless of what tool I use.

Re: skews...

#10

Re: skews...

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

Gary, there's another issue which no one has mentioned yet: what about whether or not you prefer a hollow ground or a slightly convex -- yes convex -- ground? You may wish to experiment with both of these. I actually prefer the slightly convex ground for some work.

Re: skews...

#11

more, (sl. long)   ...and thanks everyone....

GaryG in MD

I have read each of your excellent replies carefully, and I believe I understand them. I won't reply to each separately, but I thank you ALL for your on-the-mark responses.

Here was my experience that generated the question -- I didn't want to bias the replies in the original question. I took the opportunity at a recent CAW Mini-Symposium skew demo to go up and give it a try myself. This was the first time I had ever touched a skew to wood (not owning one myself at that time). The skew I used in my "first contact" situation had an increasingly curved edge at the "short point", and I used the tool for a simple peeling cut on a piece of wet osage orange. The previous person had been quite timid, and the instructor said I could push it as hard as I wanted into the wood with complete safety. I pushed the cut at what I considered to be a firm but safe rate. The result was clean, easy, and without incident, except covering myself with beautiful yellow shavings. It felt really good. I now own a Doug Thompson 3/4" skew -- it comes with a straight edge. When I got it, I took one look at that short point corner and thought "Hmmmm.... it looks like that corner could catch where the curved edge didn't. It appears that many of you like the curve too, although it will definitely be more of a problem to sharpen it that way. Well, I'll now go out and see how it works "as is" and then decide whether or not to alter the grind a bit.

Thanks Eliot for your extra comment about the shape of the bevel -- that's also something I'll have to consider. Right now, it's hollow ground off the grinder stone, and that makes it easy to sharpen on a diamond card by just touching the heel and tip. I'll try that first and talk to you about the convex grind at the next meeting.

Again, thanks to everyone, and please be equally as generous with your replies to my next question about the desired handle length. ...Gary

Re: skews...

#12

Re: more, (sl. long)   ...and thanks everyone....

Bill-- Jacksonville NC

I had trouble using a regular skew chisel. Tried to order a Stabilax that attaches to a skew chisel from Highland Hardware. Told me they were on back order so did not get one. Doubt you can find one for sale today. Rounding the edges on my skew chisels really help me the most. I put a radius on my �� and 3/4� skew chisels after watching a Raffan video.

Today am back to a straight edge on all my skew chisels. I find no difference in cuts you can make. Just keep your skew chisel sharp, and practice.

Re: skews...

#13

Re: more, (so. long)   ...and thanks everyone....

Barry Irby

Attended a Jimmy Clewes Demo yesterday.

He is a strong proponent of a straight edged skew with a convex grind. He brought a 13mm/1/2" one with him as part of his traveling tool kit. He really talked up the convex grind. Also a proponent of the rectangular stock. And that the skew should be really sharp.

Re: skews...

#14

Re: skews...

Russ Fairfield

Anothe fan of the convex bevel. I grind a flat bevel on a disc sander and sharpen the skew with either a flat diamond-stone or hard felt buffing wheel. Over time and repeated sharpenings, it starts to take on a slightly convex shape like a knife blade. I use the skew a lot and renew the flat bevel no more than 3 times a year.

A concave bevel is easier to use if it is sharpened with a flat bench stone or slip-stone across the bevel. This creates a short secondary bevel at the cutting edge that gets wider with repeated sharpenings. I don't regrind the tool until this secondary bevel starts to get over 1/8" wide, and that is only 2 or 3 times a year. .

Re: skews...

#15

thanks for info on convex edge shape

GaryG in MD

That's excellent info, and I'll have to give it a try along the way. ...Gary

Re: skews...

#16

Re: skews...

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

I agree with Russ, the important thing is that your skew needs to be sharp!

Beyond this I think a lot of people are overthinking this. I am a tool fanatic, and I own a number of skews, in all kinds of shapes and sizes. All are quite functional if kept sharp. I keep a diamond hone on the table next to my lathe, and use it to touch up the skew often. My rule is that if I even wonder if it is time to sharpen my skew, then it is too late! Sharpen often!

I think I hated and feared the skew until I saw Stuart Mortimer in a demonstration at the Utah Symposium a number of years ago. There was no stress involved in his use of the skew. It was more about turning, and the skew was secondary. I try to emulate that no-stress attitude with the skew, and it helps greatly. I truly enjoy using the skew now, and it doesn't really matter which of my eight or so skews I am using.

Good Luck!

Scott.

Re: skews...

#17

Re: skews...

GaryG in MD

Thanks Scott -- I'm looking forward to it now with anticipation, not fear. ...GG

Re: skews...

#18

Re: skews...

Russ Fairfield

There will be an article in the June issue of the AAW Journal (it could be Aug) on using the skew chisel. It shows a different way to learn how to use the tool.

Re: skews...

#19

I'll be excited to see it.   

john lucas

Re: skews...

#20

Re: skews...

Keith T

Hi Russ, I'll be looking for the article. I use the skew in unorthodox ways....long point down, on center is a favorite method.

Re: skews...

#21

Re: skews...

GaryG in MD

Looking forward to it. ...Gary