Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

Posts

Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#1

Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

Jim Rutten

Ok, so during class John got me using my skew as a negative rake scraper and I have to tell you I could get used to the finish it leaves. It got me thinking about applying it to bowls and/or platters. On the outside it is no problem since I can use my current skew to finish the outside, but, because of the shape of the skew I can't finish the inside. So, has anyone ever thought of and/or made a totally rounded skew that you can use on the inside of bowls/platters? Somewhat like a round nose scraper, but a skew. Sharpening is no problem because John was showing us how to use diamond hones to sharpen our skews. :\

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#2

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

Bill Howatt

Google for Negative Rake Scraper and you will get plenty of info on making your own from an old tool or where you can buy one.

Bill

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#3

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

John Lucas

Jim I use a roundnose scraper held at 45 degrees to do a shear scrape on the inside of bowls. I think Sorby sells a negative rake scraper but I haven't been to their website in a long time. You can grind any scraper into a negative rake by simply grinding an angle on the top. If you grind the bottom bevel to a sharper angle and then grind the top of the scraper down then you basically have a skew laying on it's side.

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#4

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

fgvanatta

You can grind any scraper into a negative rake by simply grinding an angle on the top. If you grind the bottom bevel to a sharper angle and then grind the top of the scraper down then you basically have a skew laying on it's side.

Thank you, John. That's so simple I never thought of it. I scrape with the skew on the outside of lots of things and I like the finish. Now, I'll see what it looks like on the inside (or feels like, at least).

Frank

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#5

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

Bernie Weishapl

John at what angle do you grind the bottom bevel if you make a neg rake scraper out of another scraper? Would it be at the same angle as a normal scraper? Thanks.

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#6

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

john lucas

Bernie I don't have a negative rake scraper right now. I did play with them for a while. The bottom angle I used was somewhere around 60 degrees and the top was around 15 I believe. I think Stewart Batty's scraper was much sharper than that. His looked more like a skew with a very sharp angle.

I just looked up Jerry Glaser's article. He recommends a total angle of 50 degrees but says anything from 45 to 70 works. The smaller the angle the larger the burr. I believe larger burr's wear off faster which is why Stewart Batty was making his scrapers from v15 particle metal. That is a very tough steel but about 3 times the price of the steel the Doug Thompson is using and the 2060 steels. If I remember correctly Doug's tools are V11.

I don't turn a lot of exotic hardwoods so I simply don't need a negative rake scraper. I use a my scrapers at a about a 45 degree angle as a shear scraper. For the woods I use this works just fine.

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#7

Katherine Kowalski

Already adjusted... *LINK*

Katherine Kowalski

Hi Jim,

Cindy Drozda has designed just such a tool -- perfect for scraping end-grain on the inside of box lids, getting the nib out of the bottom of a box, and also for general negative-rake scraping of inside-curved surfaces. (See her Arc Tool at link below).

John, Stuart grinds his negative rake scrapers at 40' bottom bevel, 20' top bevel. (Skew is at 40' included angle, parting tools at 45' included angle.)

Using the powdered metal tools, ASP 2060, A-11 (Thompson) will allow your burr to last MUCH longer. (And we all know that negative rake scraping ONLY produces a fine finish using the burr -- after it's gone you have to re-sharpen). Besides exotics, I also like to use negative rake scrapers on troublesome burls that don't seem to want to cut cleanly any other way.

Stuart Batty recently demonstrated for our club, where he told us that negative rake scraping was used as far back as the 1560's...


http://www.cindydrozda.com

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#8

Re: Already adjusted...

Jim Rutten

Thanks, Katherine. That looks like just the ticket! :)

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#9

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

Greg in Oshkosh

John do you have a link to the J glaser article??

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#10

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

john lucas

Only if your an AAW member. If you are you can go to the AAW website and view all of the issues of American Woodturner. You can also do a search. If not I don't know where to find the article. Perhaps someone else will know.

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#11

Re: Already adjusted...

Russ Fairfield

I don't know about 1560, but I wa using a negative rake scraper for finishing cuts in the pattern shop in 1960.

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me John)

#12

Re: Skew adjustment (look what you've done to me J

Greg in Oshkosh

Thanks, John