Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Economy of Design

Posts

Economy of Design

#1

Mike Stafford

Economy of Design

Mike Stafford

My wife is a very fine needlepoint artist having received the designation of Master Craftsman in two different disciplines of needlepoint. She is currently working on her third Master Craftsman certification in Embroidery Design.

Since I live with her and get to experience her trials and tribulations as she works through the curricula for these disciplines I learn something about what she is researching and doing. She is required to do several research papers as she accomplishes the various steps required by the program.

Currently she is working on "Economy of Design" and I have learned so much while reading some of her research and reviewing her paper. The principle of economy of design can be explained with the following quote from Antoine de Saint-Exupery who said, "Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away."

This seems to be the perfect description of what we as wood turners strive to do as we remove all the unwanted material to find the good design inside a piece of wood. Our job is to remove all the non-essential or unimportant wood which does not contribute to the essence of the object we are trying to create.

This "visual economy" or simplicity in art also known as minimal design is what we try to do to emphasize what is important. It is about really understanding the design problem, and focusing on the essentials of the object we are trying to create. Much of the beauty in an object and skill of the design (and execution thereof) focuses on what is left out, i.e. what is removed by the chisel, rather than trying to include everything you can. All too frequently many of us are guilty of trying to use as much of a beautiful piece of wood as we can rather than on finding the shape we envision within that piece of wood.

I know I am guilty of that as I design my boxes to fit the piece of wood I have. I turn with a desire to be economical about my use of wood. I think I first became aware of this tendency when I was watching one of the Jimmy Clewes videos where he starts with a very large piece of wood but removes more and more wood until he finds the shape he has envisioned. I don't know if my realization of this will change significantly how my turnings are shaped or whether I will suddenly begin wasting away wood for the sake of some design that I do not have a complete vision of in my head.

I guess good design means as little design as possible. Just because you can turn beautiful finials with detailed beads and coves that does not mean you should embellish everything you turn with beads and coves. I recently saw a minimalist capsule shaped box on one of the web sites that had a very detailed handle/finial on its top. To me that box was over designed. It did not exhibit economy of design. It did not focus on the essentials.

One example of a turner who epitomizes to me the economy of design is Bert Marsh. He is able to pare away all the unnecessary bits and bumps of wood to reveal a most elegant form. There are no other embellishments necessary because he selects beautiful wood and displays it to perfection both in form and finish. I think we all recognize perfect form when we see it. Of course he is not alone in this ability to turn a beautiful object. I am sure we can all name many more.

My purpose in posting this was to share some of what I have learned. I am sure there are many who already know all this and are rolling their eyes at the rube who has just discovered the basics. I know just enough now to be dangerous and will never hold myself up as some kind of expert on design. I don't think I will ever be an expert on anything. But perhaps this newfound understanding of some of the most basic principles of design will enable me to become a better turner.

I look forward to your comments.

Re: Economy of Design

#2

Re: Economy of Design

John Lucas

Mike We teach that in photography, especially when you start editing an image. You remove elements from the image until only the ones that make it work remain. Of course in the old days that simply meant cropping. With today's tools you can also tone down or remove distractions.

I think in woodturning it's more difficult because as you remove wood things change. The figure in the wood may flow in a slightly different direction or a new figure or "defect" in the wood may emerge that becomes a significant eye catching element.

Overall form is especially crucial but so is the negative space outside the form. The negative space helps define the form and probably works hand in hand with economy of design.

Great post, I need to let it sink in more. I do try to tell my students that you don't need to make the biggest bowl you can from a piece of wood. You need to look at all of it and decide what shape it really should be. Don't be afraid to make is smaller if the you can achieve a better shape.

Re: Economy of Design

#3

Re: Economy of Design

Lee Buck

Mike You expressed it very well and in my opinion picked the perfect example in Bert Marsh..

Re: Economy of Design

#4

Re: Economy of Design

Keith T

Good post, Mike. I will be demonstrating in Hartford, one of my demos is titled "Kick it UP!Design for beginners". You mentioned one of my key points..we tend to let a piece of wood dictate how our work appears, not the other way around! How many times does a turner purchase a block of pretty wood that someone else has predetermined its final overall shape? Sometimes cutting that piece of wood in half will yield TWO well proportioned pieces rather that one bad one... I gave a design demo in Canada; one person in the audience sent me a DVD of a music class he had attended. The instructor, well known base player Victor Wootan, had posted a virtually identical outline on the blackboard as I had for my turning demo! Same words used to describe two different art forms. I was as shocked as the person who sent it to me. How about a colaborative with you and your wife?

Re: Economy of Design

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Economy of Design

Mike Stafford

Keith, my wife and I have been collaborating for years. She does needlepoint inserts that I put into the lids of "GASP!!!" flatwork boxes. It is hard to put a piece of needlepoint into a surface that is round. It is very hard to do round in needlepoint.

However she is taking some courses in marquetry. Now there might be some possibilities there....

Re: Economy of Design

#6

Re: The bowl is hidden in the tree, its....

JamieDonaldson

...up to us to set it free! Rude Osolnik, and probably others!

Re: Economy of Design

#7

apparently my tree had a toothpick. 

john lucas

Re: Economy of Design

#8

Re: Economy of Design

John Jordan

That's a good post, Mike. Sometimes, a little restraint can go a long way. The late Dale chaes di a lot of little turned boxes that were simple shapes with no decoration outside-not even a bead or groove. Exquisite shapes, and the inside was decorated with rose engine work.

Keith, I would like to see the simple version of your presentation and Victor Wooten's. We love Victor Wooten here in Nashville. :)

John

Re: Economy of Design

#9

Re: Economy of Design

Russ Fairfield

Too many woodturners follow the rule that say you have to use all of the wood in every piece, and then let the chuck determine the diameter of the base. And they're not all beginners.

Re: Economy of Design

#10

Re: Economy of Design

Matt Overton

Mike,

Great post. Are there any of your wife's references on this subject that you can recomend? I'd like to research a little deeper.

Re: Economy of Design

#11

Re: Economy of Design

Carole Valentine

Well said, Mike. So many seem to think that economy of design means using as much as possible of the particular piece of wood in hand when in fact it often requires considerable "waste". As most turners seem to be rather frugal in nature, the mere idea of "waste" can too easily influence the final design if we let it.

Re: Economy of Design

#12

My Garden is not complete.....

Barry Irby

until there is nothing left I am willing to give up.

Years ago I got into Japanese gardens. (The best one in the world outside Japan is in Seattle. Its worth a trip there to visit)

One of the philosophies of Gardening is the Zen Garden. The minimalist garden. Very spare and severe to our western eyes. The very carefully raked stones or gravel are often featured in Zen gardens.

Your post reminded me of that.

I have often wondered if most people start with a piece of wood and turn the biggest thing they can out of it or if they start with a vision and find a piece of wood that suits.

Re: Economy of Design

#13

Steven Antonucci

Afraid to step away from bad...

Steven Antonucci

Good design is not an accident. It takes some careful thought at the begining, and attention to detail throughout. The challenge that a lot of us face (my hand is up) is that we will often finish something that we know isn't very good with the hope of somehow "saving" it by covering up the bad...

If I turn a dog, I know it, and it ends up in my "kennel" in the shop. I use dogs to practice technique, but inevitably, they get burned to destroy the evidence. Don't be afraid to stop working on a dog...

steve

Re: Economy of Design

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Economy of Design

Mike Stafford

Matt, here are a few links to some of the references that I thought were particularly useful to me....

http://creativecurio.com/tag/economy

http://www.graphicdesignbasics.com/principles-of-design

http://www.bluemoonwebdesign.com/art-lessons-5.asp

Re: Economy of Design

#15

Re: Economy of Design

Matt Overton

Thanks, Mike they look like a good place to start.

Re: Economy of Design

#16

Re: Economy of Design

Keith T

Hi John, thanks. Victor is an awesome player. One word he wrote down was FEAR, and how it stopped players from progressing. Fear of hitting the wrong note, etc.. Then, he purposely hit all the wrong notes, even accentuating them while playing with students. By simply sliding a half-step to the next "correct" note, he had created tension and then resolution. Fear and tension were just two words in common...

Re: Economy of Design

#17

Re: Economy of Design

John Jordan

Keith, hopefully I can make your session in Hartford, but I'm doing several rotations, too, and haven't seen the schedule yet. I know about the fear thing-has me pretty stalled out on some things I want to do.

Steve Loar and I used to do a thing about the "myths" of woodturning. Top of the list was "You have to use all the wood." :)

Good thread, Mike.

John

Re: Economy of Design

#18

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Economy of Design

Barb Siddiqui

Very interesting post, Mike, and thank you for the references you posted. This theory also applies to the written word, as in Hemingway's comment when asked if his sentences were so short, what took him so long? "Getting the words right," he replied. And in Flannery O'Connor's observation on planning a story: "The surest way to end in a crash is to not know where you intend to land." Many other examples abound. Perhaps physicists are looking in the wrong places for a solution to The Grand Unified Theory. The true GUT of the Theory of Everything. Maybe it's in the needlepoint design. That's a nice idea!

Re: Economy of Design

#19

Re: Economy of Design

Keith T

That would be quite an honor John. I once took a David Ellsworth class at his home. As David watched me turn I made a smart-ass comment.. "Hey, you think this is easy? YOU try it with David Ellsworth looking over YOUR shoulder!" Fear does funny things...Keith Code talks about motorcyclists entering a corner too fast, and looking at the approaching guardrails in fear. Yep, right into the guardrails, when instead they should have been looking beyond the corner. Thinking you might get a catch? you probably will :)

Re: Economy of Design

#20

Re: Economy of Design

Keith T

Hi Mike, after re-reading your post, there's an alternative to removing material until you come up with a pleasing shape...make a sketch first. Even if you cannot draw, it gets easier and easier with practice. It's a great feeling approaching the lathe with a solid goal in mind, and the wood no longer dictates form. When I go wood shopping, I look for pieces that will fit the sketches I've made. I buy a whole lot less wood that way, too. Sometimes I ask a student WHY did you put a bead or other detail where they did...usually they don't have a reason except something seems lacking.

Re: Economy of Design

#21

Re: Economy of Design

John Jordan

We have several things in common, then. I enjoy reading Keith's columns. I would love to take one of his classes sometime. I could use some productive "target fixation" :)

John

Re: Economy of Design

#22

Mike Stafford

Re: Economy of Design

Mike Stafford

Keith, that is what I have been doing all along. I take the piece of wood in question and draw it to scale on graph paper. Then I plan the shape to use that piece of wood.

I carefully measure the waste cuts etc.

I know I am "Type A" but that is how I think. When I used to build lots of jewelry boxes I did the same thing; sketching the box full size front, top, and end....I still have all those drawings and patterns. When I teach my class in June at JCCFS my students will be gifted measured drawings of some of my boxes. I hope they will be useful.