Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

My new grinder

Posts

My new grinder

#1

My new grinder

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Much has been written about grinders, wheels, speeds thereof, etc. I just came into possession of a new (to me) Baldor 8107W high speed grinder. I love high speed, so when I discovered that this one is even faster than my Jet - 3600 rpm vs 3450 rpm - I was elated. I do have a small "issue" though.

Last fall, I was anticipating replacing that Jet grinder, as it had started to squeak somewhat from time to time. I had a teaching job in Wellsboro PA, and passed within two miles of the Grizzly distribution center. So I stopped, and in a rare flash of foresight, I bought a DeWalt bench grinder against the day the Jet coughed up blood and died.

The Jet is still running, and the DeWalt is out of the box, but never used. Is anyone here interested in a new but slightly dusty DeWalt grinder? I can make you such a deal! :D

Re: My new grinder

#2

Re: My new grinder

Don Evans

Hi Bill:

I almost hate to tell you this but there is no difference in the motors that state 3600 rpm verse 3450 rpm.

The 3600 rating is done when the motor is under NO load and that same motor will be rated at 3450 rpm when under its rated load.

You can look at it from a marketing aspect and say that when an advertiser states 3450 rpm that is "truth in advertising". Both are really correct.

What makes the difference? It happens inside the motor with no load it runs 3600 rpm but when load is applied the motor "slips" and is only able to maintain the 3450.

This is also true with all motors and the ones you see rated at 1725 rpm are also 1800 rpm when NOT under a load.

So with the motor we in woodworking come across they are 3600 and 1800 rpm motors but when the "slip under load" in taken into consideration they are 3450 and 1725 rpm.

Don

Re: My new grinder

#3

Re: My new grinder

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Don, I appreciate your technical expertise on this, but in the end it makes no matter. Even if the motor really did run at the full 3600 rpm, it would not make much difference. What has me so happy is that it is a high speed grinder. I absolutely detest the 1725 rpm grinders. I use them almost everywhere I go, and it always feels like the tool is bumping and thumping along without really getting sharp. It does not help that often these grinders are not set up properly. And I know, it is not the speed that makes the tool sharp. I have a Tormek too. But, it is the speed that makes the tool sharp faster.

My high speed grinder is smooth and easy to use. A light touch yields a very sharp edge with a minimal amount of metal being removed. And stepping up to the Baldor, while it is expensive, is probably the last grinder I will ever have to buy.

Re: My new grinder

#4

Re: My new grinder

Don Evans

I understand now, it was just when in your excitement you stated "3600 rpm vs 3450 rpm - I was elated" that I misunderstood.

I also agree with using what we call "high speed" is the way to go.

I would also guess that most grinders we use are doing closer to 3600 because grinding a turning tool isn't much of a load.

I've got a Baldor and a Delta which weights in at 100 pounds, the Baldor I have NO idea how old it really is but I got it used from a manufacturer plant and I've had it for 30 years and it's like the Pink rabbit still keeps on going and never needed any work so far.

Don

Re: My new grinder

#5

Re: My new grinder

robo hippy

I whined when I got my Baldor 8 inch grinder (to go with my CBN wheels), but like some one said, "Buy the expensive tool, and cry once. Buy the cheap tool and cry every time you use it."

Now, I think I may need to do more experimenting with grinding wheels, the new Woodriver diamond grinding wheel from Woodcraft, and the green silicone carbide grinding wheels. Is there no end to the things we can buy? Do I really need to ask that question?

robo hippy

Re: My new grinder

#6

Re: My new grinder

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Don, I have a tendency to take poetic license when I describe stuff like this. Those who have listened to me demo will know that every now and then I will embellish just a little, mainly to spice up a story.

When I used to have my Poolewood, I loved the direct readout that told me exactly how fast the spindle was rotating, just because. It became a curse though. With student after student, they would be turning at a given speed, and I would instruct them to change it. For example, the lathe might be spinning at 400 rpm, and I would say, speed it up to about 700 rpm. The next couple of minutes would be consumed while people fiddled with the knob until the lathe was running at 700 rpm - not 695, or 702 - it had to be 700 rpm. I then had to explain that anything with in 25-50 rpm in either direction was close enough for this stuff, unless the lathe was shaking.

Now those engineering guys though... :O

Re: My new grinder

#7

My Grinder is Faster

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Bill,

If you like fast grinders then you can have mine. A couple of years ago my Dad gave me a cheap Delta "variable speed" 8" grinder. Didn't take too long for the variable speed controller to fail and of course the light. It pretty much sticks on 3450 RPM. But every so often, and without warning, it decides to speed up....uncontrollably. I have no idea how fast it gets up to but a wild guess would be 7,000 RPM....plus. The racket and rumbling gets your attention real quick. Generally I hit the off switch and duck for cover. Gotta tell ya....makes turning a little more exciting than I bargain for!

Tom

Re: My new grinder

#8

Re: My Grinder is Faster

Don Evans

I love to take you up on that free offer wish you were close.

I'm confident I could fix it......

Don