Steve's pic of the trembleur he turned after a class with Escoulen got me wondering why there isn't a tail center that would put the piece being turned "between centers" in tension - assuming the other end was in a chuck, scroll, jacobs or collet?
When turning down to small diameters "between centers", the wood is being compressed, even if the drive end is in a chuck, the tail center is pushing into the end of the piece. And compressing the wood AND applying a side force to it makes it bend when you turn it small enough.
JFE shows how to make a string rest that fits in the tailstock. Very little tension could be applied against the underside of the first egg. With the string rest every couple of inches, the thin turning is a non issue.
One of these: www.pennstateind.com/store/LTCA18.html with a Beall collet chuck works right well to put tension on a spindle piece. Unfortunately this item is not tapped for a draw bar. I drilled and tapped mine for a home made 1/4 x 20 allthread drawbar.
The C-shaped string steadies work well - IF you have the room for one, or two. On the JET mini, the banjo and the stock steady rest don't don't give you much working room. String steadies work.
Yes, there's a potential problem with the tension on the tail stock end - torqueing the thinned turned area on start up and stopping. That issue might be taken care of with "soft start" motor like in today's routers, but with a longer Up To Speed time. And you'd have to let the lathe wind down slowly - no motor break.
There is another potential problem to address - preventing the morse taper on the tail stock from pulling out as you tension the piece. Tapping the end of the tail stock device and AllThread as noted could solve that problem.
I have a friend that wraps masking tape around the tailstock nose cone and the piece he's turning. Then backs off the tailstock slightly. It put enough tension on the turning so it won't flex but not so much that the morse taper pulls out.
I looked into this many years ago but didn't have the tools or skills to do anything about it. I've broken a trembleur simply by turning the lathe on. I was turning at higher speeds on a single speed lathe. The force of start up twisted it off when one of the heavier elements apparently couldn't keep up. You would multiply the problem 10 fold if it was tied to the mass of a live center.
What I wanted to do was put a small chuck on the tailstock using the Oneway live center and the chuck adaptor. Then rig up a draw bar to keep it in the tailstock. Install a gear on the back side of the chuck so the headstock and tailstock would drive together with a connecting rod.
I don't think it has a lot of practical uses because you still have a lot of whip in the middle and will probably still have to use the a steady rest of some sort.
I don't see where this would be an answer to the problem there is for example one variable aside from all the others trying to be over come that would make this only help is some cases.
What are these variables: length of piece vs thinness vs type wood vs parts of it larger than the thin and the list goes on.
The one thing however that this method doesn't address in which the "C" strings do is the balance of the wood itself in any given part of the length. This is general created by the rings in the wood, void pockets, pitch pockets and other things.
For example suppose your turning is 24" long, you are pulling on the tail end but unseen is the bulb almost in the center (left to right) that is a bulb and it has one side twice as heavy than the bulb 180 deg around it.
Probably would never be able to tension enough to keep it running smooth and it would probably pull it apart before balance point could be forced. That word "force" is what is wrong here, not good way to engineer something by trying to force it into submission.
Tensioning spindle turnings to make them not vibrate is a myth that refuses to die. It doesn't work, never has, and never will, and the reason is easilly explained.
A fact of life is that tension causes vibration, and compression doesn't vibrate at all. What do you do to a guitar string to make a sound? You put it in tension. Without tension, or in compression, the guitar string will just lie there and make no sound when plucked. Add tension, and there is vibration and sound. It is the same with wood. Add tension to a spindle turning, and you are making it act like a guitar string, and there will be vibration. Put the wood in compression and there will be none.
The rim of a bowl dries faster than the rest of the wood, putting the wood around the rim in tension, and making it vibrate when we try to cut it. Anyone who has turned a bowl has experienced this. You can add a bowl-steady and the rubber wheel will act as vibration dampers. You could also do the same thing with a little water to expand the wood at the rim, releasing the tension. A sharper or less aggressive cut will always help, and sometimes a change is speed makes the vibration go away.
It occurred to me that I started having more vibration problems with spindles when I started using a live-center in the tail-stock to replace the old dead-centers I had been using.
A quick look at what is happening told me why. The old ring center added a friction force at the tail-stock, and the result was a slight twist in the piece of wood that resulted in putting it in a slight compression, and the cause of most vibration was eliminated.
When we use a live canter, there is no restraining or compressive force and the wood is free to vibrate and chatter of its own free will. The normal solution is to add more pressure, often to the point of putting a slight bend in the wood. That only makes the condition worse because the bent wood is in compression on the underside of the curve, and in tension on the top-side, and we have just induced a vibration.
The best solution is still a dead-center in the tail stock. Most of my vibration problems went away when I went back to a lubricated ring-center.
A sharp skew will always cut with less vibration than a sharp spindle gouge because there is less cutting force to start any vibration.
The wood species is also a factor to vibration. Oak and Ash are difficult because of the hard grain lines. A more uniform wood like Mahogany, Maple or Walnut will have less vibration because of the more uniform densith and the absence of hard grain lines.
We can use a steady-rest, multiple string rests, etc. to dampen vibration and support the wood. A rest that slides on the wood is better than one that rolls because the friction puts the wood in compression and reduces vibration. A free wheeling rest adds nothing other than support to the wood, and any vibration damping effect is that we are using rubber wheels.
Argue if you will. That's my story and I sticking to it.