Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Punky wood

Posts

Punky wood

#1

Punky wood

George Tyler

After knee and hip replacement surgeries, I'm starting to turn again. I'm having a hard time turning a piece of punky maple and remember an article either on Badger Pond or Wood Central on soaking the wood in a solution of Elmer's glue and water, but don't remember the formula. Does anyone remember this or have a better solution? Thanks, George Tyler, Louisa, Va

Re: Punky wood

#2

Re: Punky wood

Cyril Griesbach

George, if memory serves me, and it doesn't always, it's 50-50.

Re: Punky wood

#3

Yes, it isn't too critical a mix

Bill Howatt

Re: Punky wood

#4

George Balock

Re: Punky wood

George Balock

Geore,

I've used acrylic floor polish to harden punky wood. I can't remember the brand, but it cuts and sands well after drying.

George

Re: Punky wood

#5

Re: Punky wood

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Yep, that was my article. First, I agree with John Jordan...Life is too short to turn crappy wood...However, if the wood is something special then it might be worth spending some time to make turning it possible.

I had a number of blanks that were figured and spalted maple and had some punky spots. Just barely able to sucessfully rough them out. I decided to try the glue method. I bought a gallon of white glue, which isn't very expensive, and a small plastic tub. The mix was 50/50. White glue is nearly all water anyway. I soaked the roughouts one at a time for about 24 hours. (longer might be better..I haven't tried it). I had to put a rock on the piece because it wanted to float. You are soaking the piece in water so expect it to warp as it dries. Drying time was a couple of weeks. (The wood was dry before I soaked it.)

The results were from very good to not so good, depending on how punky the wood was, and how large the punky area was. I've done this procedure several times since with varying results.

Wally

Re: Punky wood

#6

Re: Punky wood

John K Jordan

You can get much better penetration if you can put it in a container and pull even a mild vacuum on the wood. Submerge the wood in the liquid, pull the vacuum, hold for a while (air will be bubbling out of the wood), then release the vacuum which will suck the liquid into the pores.

Personally, I soak punky wood with CA glue, as much as it will take. I apply it again if I cut through to where it is soft.

JKJ

Re: Punky wood

#7

Re: Punky wood *LINK*

Fred Holder

I recently turned a very spalted bowl as a part of our collaborative group exchange. I mounted the wood and took a pass with a sharp gouge on the outside. The pick out was awful. I pulled it off the lathe and soaked it for 24 hours in Turner's Choice (aka Cedar Shield). I then let if dry for about a week and remounted it on the lathe. It thencut clean and I was able to finish it without tearout.

I hope this helps. The stuff is made by CedarSide in Texas. I've been using it to make wood turn better for several years. I soak all of the wood to be made into Chinese Balls in this stuff.


More Woodturning magazine

Re: Punky wood

#8

Re: Punky wood

George Tyler

Thanks for all of your replies. I guess I have to agree with John Jordan "why turn crappy wood?" With all of the maple and oak firewood I have, why do I want to turn punky wood. Because it's there. If it were easy, everyone would do it.I do want to try the glue soak method to learn from the experience. Happy Easter, George