Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

Posts

Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

#1

Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

charlie belden

The intent here is to note common newbie mistakes (and there are a "few") in terms of:

- proportions: height to width ratio, lid to box ratio, size of finial to size of box ratio, etc.

- congruity: does the wood and its grain and the shape and all the parts go together - or not

- flow: do changes in the profile of the piece "flow" or are they noticeably interrupted

- crispness: if there are details are they crisp and clean or was all crispness sanded away

- finish: no noticeable tear out, no obvious sanding scratches, no unfinished areas. If

a coating was put on the piece is any "streaking" noticeable or any spots missed

What do YOU see that's "not right" with this piece ( I know, finials are "suppose to be thinner on top")



Re: Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

#2

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

Charlie, I like the concept of the box within a box a lot. My take on this particular piece is that the finial is too heavy and tall and that its details could use some refinement.

I also feel that racetrack (capsule) shapes aren't as intrinsically pleasing as parabolic or elliptical shapes, IMO. You can't emphasize thrust or gravity or visual balance with the capsule shape. For whatever reason, I think our eyes resonate more with pure geometric forms. Differentiated curves have more appeal than fabricated profiles. To me, at least.

Ellis

Re: Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

#3

Re: Yet Another Capsule Box For Critique

Keith T

Hi Charlie, I agree with Ellis. The pill form has little to offer in terms of visual excitement. As you know, one can make pieces that actually move...but, it's not so easy to create a stationary form that suggests movement. Your piece may approximate the golden mean while the break for the lid lies within the rule of thirds, yet the piece still has a static appearance due to straight lines in the sides, and identical appearing curves in the top and base. For the finial, think simple....too many details fighting for attention, and again straight lines give a static feel; the finial just sits there. Think of the finial starting at the base, flowing through the form, and bursting skyward....movement and energy. Or in the words of Bill Luce..POWER. On a brighter note, your workmanship appears flawless.