Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Lathe Longevity

Posts

Lathe Longevity

#1

Lathe Longevity

john lucas

Todd Nebel brings up a good point in his post about the Delta 16" lathe. I thought it would be good to discuss the life of a lathe.

The early lathes (powered that is) had single speed motors with step pulley and maybe a jackshaft with step pulleys. About the only thing that goes bad on those is the belt, motor, and pulleys. All easily replaceable with after market pieces for the most part. Easily repairable by anyone handy with tools.

Then the Reeves drive came along. Ah ha, variable speed. What a great idea. However you had to be pretty good about cleaning and lubing this thing. Maybe even disassemble, clean and lube. If one of the moveable pulleys broke you had to really scrounge to find a replacement if you could at all. They might be common or they might be one of a kind. If the company was out of business you were SOL. The good news is that anyone with good mechanical skills could repair it once they obtained the parts.

Then DC motors and controllers came along. Even finer speed adjustment although you gave up quite a bit of power at the slower speeds so you still had step pulleys to help get you over the hump. If the motor or controller failed you could still buy after market but they are quite expensive. Although you could replace these parts yourself the odds are you couldn't repair the controller unless you are really sharp electrically and have the schematic. However these lathes can usually be restored with aftermarket parts unless the bearings are unusual.

Now we have Variable Frequency drives. Fine speed control with lots of power over the whole range. Not much more expensive than the DC motor and controller. On many of the lathe these can be replaced with aftermarket part. The controller definitely isn't repairable for most people. The bigger lathes may have proprietary bearings but the whole thing could be modified by a good machinist so basically these lathes are still restorable.

Then we have the Nova DVR with a very special motor, spindle all in one kind of configuration with their own controller. Nice lathes, plenty of power and seem to run well. However what happens down the line when the controller or motor dies and the company no longer makes them. I doubt you will find aftermarket parts for these.

Now looking 10 years down the line we will probably have CNC or just plain robotic lathes. How hard will it be to get parts and keep these things running. What happens when the company doesn't support the software anymore?

The reason I brought this up and want your input is I've seen a lot of lathes come and go and I've only been in the business 20+ years. I don't like the throw away society we seem to be headed towards. I love old iron and the fact that with some skill you can resurrect these old beasts and still use them.

I do love my lathe but the reason I picked the powermatic over some others was the possible long term replacement of part. I plan on keeping this thing running forever unless I win the lottery and can buy something bigger.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#2

Re: Lathe Longevity

bill crommett

John: Not only are we going to enter the throw-away lathe era, but it looks like we will soon be entering the throw-away money era, too.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#3

Re: Lathe Longevity

Bill Howatt

I'd say we are already into the throw away society. Yes, there are things that can be repaired but when you see the cost compared to a new one the item is usually junked.

There are 2 problems causing this. One is the cost of labor including the various overheads not just the hourly wage. The second one is the cost of labor means that a lot of parts are sold as assemblies which are machine assembled. This is particularly true of electronic components. A large-screen TV may have all its parts on 2 or 3 boards and very few of the components can be fixed in a normal shop. Soldering in a new chip or other components by hand is impossible. You may want to add in the third cause - the companies know you can't fix it and can keep the cost of parts high.

When I bought my General 26020 the Nova DVRs had recently come out and seemed like a good bang for the buck but the very things you mentioned steered me away from it. For the General I can get a new motor, fix the bearings and buy a new electronic VFD box. The parts can be obtained from many sources whereas the DVR motor/headstock and electonics are sole-sourced. If anything happens to Teknatool who knows what'll happen.

Bill

Re: Lathe Longevity

#4

Re: Lathe Longevity

Keith T

HI John, I run a General as well. Old school but with modern VS. I like the fact that I can turn outboard, plus in case of a disaster, I could install a standard 220v. 2-3 HP motor, bypass the electronics, and run it directly off the four-speed pulleys. Man, did General miss the boat on coming up with a new competitive machine, or even updating the existing model...this machine will easily outlive me, and with a few updates would be very competitive in the market.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#5

Re: Lathe Longevity

Dave Moore

I'm with you, I hate this throwaway fashion we've got ourselves into.

Problem is, just about 70% of the whole damn economy now depends on folks buying new or replacement stuff; cars, household appliances, tools, toys, whatever.

Things are designed not to last too long, and if everything did the whole show would go belly up.

I have no clue how we get ourselves out of this trap.

Bought a '56 chevy truck in 1975. Still use it. Still have the original handbook that came with it too. It tells you how to rebuild the generator and a whole bunch of other stuff. Hell, the corporate lawyers wouldn't let them do that now even if they were of a mind to.

It's a mess.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#6

Re: Lathe Longevity

Larry

Absolutely agree. Why I got the 3000 rather than the DVR. Eight speeds is plenty for me and I can repair the machine. It will still be very serviceable long after I'm not. Hell, the lathe I started on, a 1946 Delta Homecraft is still serviceable. I got the 3K because my back was getting to old to bend over the ways.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#7

Re: Lathe Longevity

Barry Irby

I have a DVR that is one of the earlier versions. The control panel went bad and They seemed mystified and pleased that Tim Geist had one "that would work". Not exact, but it worked. I have to admit it gave me pause. I suspect if I get another failure it might be a $2000 boat anchor.

My son gave me his Water Pick. He used it for about two months about two years ago and put it in a drawer. I plugged it in for two days, fiddled with it, nothing, Threw it away. You can get a new one for $35 so its not worth a lot of effort, but it still Gauls me.

I think if you check you will find that there are a lot of somewhat older cars stolen because the on board computer is worth more than the car.

I attended a fine Engineering school. (that was a rough 3 weeks :) ) One of the principles of Engineering they taught us was that it should be reparable. Not any more. In fact one of the new principles is Designed for Disassembly). So you can separated the components to allow for recycling.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#8

Re: Lathe Longevity

Don at Central Illinois

You mentioned being an engineer, I think that all engineers that design ANY machine is that they should have to repair it. Or attempt to. I have tried to fix things in the past and have had bad thoughts and maybe a few bad words at the $%^((*^&%$%() who designed this. My wifes Olds Siloutte gas gauge doesn't work anymore, and they have to drop the gas tank to fix it!! Who thought up such nonsense.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#9

Re: Lathe Longevity

bowlman

In 1985 I purchased a General 260 through Rude Osolnik. Although I ordered a 1.5 HP it came with 1HP. And yes it had the Reeves drive. I also obtained the headstock and tailstock riser kit through David Ellsworth.

That lathe is still in my shop. Problems? replaced one belt (used to much grease and it coated the belt ... belt just slipped, no drive).

Replaced the motor in 2007 (I think) with the assistance of lots of friends. Upgraded to 2 HP with a matched VFD. SO now I have reverse and true variable speed.

These "old irons" as John puts it, have proven to have extremely long lives with only minimal upkeep. Mine has been used extensively for over 25 years and is still going strong. Sure the finish is not new and shiney, and in places is pretty much covered with stuff from finished on the lathe. And the ways have a few dings and dents here and there from overzealous tightening of the tailstock clamping lever. But, would I like a newer lathe, like the Robust, OneWay, Serious or Stubby? Sure I would. It could keep the General company while I'm away ...

Let's hear it for old iron

Re: Lathe Longevity

#10

Re: Lathe Longevity

Texian

Good point Don. As a retired design engineer I frequently have the same complaint. What so-an-so designed this POS? We have a lot of old stuff that I have repaired, including numerous moderately priced items, relatively inexpensive to replace. Saves a few $$ here and there for frivolous things like food and clothing.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#11

Re: Lathe Longevity

Carole Valentine

Dave's comment: "I have no clue how we get ourselves out of this trap."

You are dead on! Planned obsolescence seems to be a driving force of our economy and modern engineering but I too, see no way of reversing that trend.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#12

Re: Lathe Longevity

John Lucas

Larry I bought an old Delta homecrafter for $25. It took me exactly 1 hour to get everything working like it should. I just cleaned and lubed everything and made a new part of the tailstock which took about 15 minutes. It works like it's new. The motor is original and runs so quiet and smooth I thought it was broken when I plugged it in. It runs with absolutely no noise and no vibration whatsoever.

I'm hanging on to it for some kid that is interested in woodturning and needs a lathe. He can buy it really cheap.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#13

Re: Lathe Longevity

John Lucas

Ditto on that. I've repaired machines my whole life and complained about the poor design. I'm sure the bean counters have as much to do with cutting corners as the engineers having to modify the designs.

I remember one adjustment we had to do to copiers that had to be +/- .005". It was done by loosening a 1/2" by13TPI bolt. It move about .020" everytime you snugged up the bolt. It always took about 10 tries trying to estimate the tightening error to get it within tolerance.

Of course I can't tell you how many times I had to to remove a screw that you could not even get to.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#14

Old Iron resale problems

Dave Staeheli

Old iron is great, but the resale on it is terrible! I have an old Yates-American with a Reeves drive made probably back in the 50's that I probably paid too much for. I did everything I could to it to make it better. Bigger motor, paint job, indexing wheel, riser blocks to 16 inch, 15 face plates, 4 tool rests, live center and all the accessories. Finally had to face that it just wasn't big enough for what I was doing with it. Upgraded to a One-way, but do you think I can sell the old Yates-American? Craigslist and notice boarded it on a "make an offer" deal. Not a nibble. Here is a great working lathe and I'm not sure I can give it away!

Re: Lathe Longevity

#15

Re: Lathe Longevity

Doug Turner

John, I turn on a 1980 short bed Woodfast lathe with variable speed. They still use these in the classroom at Craft Supplies USA the last time I looked. Still has the original bearings. I bought this lathe used for $700 and I have turned a lot of wood on it. Quality construction and good design can equal durability.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#16

I think Woodfast is a classic- and great

John Lucas

Re: Lathe Longevity

#17

Re: Lathe Longevity

Bill--Jacksonville NC

Not sure, how long we have been a throwaway society but, know it did not happen yesterday. Service centers and those people servicing consumer products getting smaller every day. Product quality, customer service and warranties can be hit or miss these days.

http://www.alibaba.com/showroom/wood-lathe_4.html

If you do a google search for wood lathe manufactures. Eventually will come across those China websites and see Jet, Powermatic, and other lathes sold in USA and around the world. Notice how many units/pieces per 20� container.

Happy can buy parts for my Jet 16/42 and mini lathes, from Jet. Cost of those parts, not so happy.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#18

Have you tried Old Woodworking Machines? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Linky below.

These folks drool over old iron, and are often willing to drive it long distances because someone else on the forum bought it, and they're headed that way. This is the only seeking/selling/trading board I know of that uses a Monty Python reference as its title.


Bring Out Your Dead, OWWM.ORG

Re: Lathe Longevity

#19

Re: Lathe Longevity

Lee Buck

I've been thinking about my Woodfast as I read this thread. The controller came from Denver Uhlery and can be replaced. I would have to do that if it quit because I know nothing about electronics. Otherwise everything should last for a long time, it already has, and can be repaired if it goes bad. It has the qualities that make us like machinery. It works and it's obvious how.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#20

Re: Lathe Longevity

John Lucas

Lee When I had my DC controller I bought a Bridge Diode and wired it up as back up. It converts AC to DC. I had to use it once when my controller died. You only have one speed, ful, but with the step pulleys it got me by for a week while the repair took place. It was a little harrowing at times. I now have a spare controller but at the current time no DC motors.

Re: Lathe Longevity

#21

Re: Lathe Longevity

Lee Buck

Thanks John. I'll look into it. I've had no problems but a backup would be good.