Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

Posts

Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#1

Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

charlie belden

Here's another "capsule" box, with finial to critique for my benefit and maybe others' benefit.

This one's out of pear wood I think. This piece can be seen as bland or very subtle depending on how closely you look. The box I posted earlier was quite short and squat looking. This one's probably a bit tall for its diameter and the "lid to box body" is almost 50-50 rather than a better one third two thirds or maybe 2/5ths-3/5ths.

Unlike the earlier cedar piece, there's a slight foot and a curved bottom on this one that softens the look quite a bit and provides a little "lift" off the surface the piece sits on. If this bottom curve had been taken up a bit more, as done with the lid, the piece would look more capsule like - though perhaps not as stabile looking.

Again, the transition from box to finial is pretty inconguous. Had it been left as a simple bottle it might have worked. If it had been turned down to just a collar it might have worked. As is, it looks sort of like a perfume bottle with a stopper - but a way too large one to work as such.

The base of the finial should have been done to give a more delicate appearance, the beads would look better if they had smaller radiuses (radii?) and a bit more outsweeping arc going up to the top element would have been a better choice. The undercut bead below the top element gives a nice little flare that would have been better if the curve below it were done better.

Still not sure about the "onion" element on the top of the finial.

So what do you see that could use changing - and how'd you change it? Is the claro walnut inlay in the top of the inside lid finial out of place?


Part of the reason for the lid being so tall is to accommodate the inside lid's pull. Smaller pull to get a better proportioned box worth it?


Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#2

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

John K Jordan

Charlie, since you asked, I'm not wild about the finial. It looks a little like a handle for a duster or bell to me. Perhaps it would work better if the onion shape were echoed somehow in the box lid shape itself, but I'd have to make some sketches. Of course, this is only my personal impression and not necessarily that of the management! But perhaps I'm just overly used to seeing and making thinner and more pointed finials.

JKJ

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#3

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

charlie belden

John:

Don't be in anyway concerned about hurting my feelings by noting things you don't like about this piece. The intent is to note what isn't working with this piece and hopefully ideas for improving it.

You note that the finial looks more like a handle than a finial. Finials are "supposed to" be wider at the base and narrower at the top - and this one does the opposite. You also acknowledged that it could just be that's what finials usually do. Anyone who has seen a Cindy Drozda finial is probably going to think of her finials as The Finial standard from then on. She definitely has HER finials down to an art.

Ever wondered WHY wider at the bottom and narrower at the top look better than the other way round? I may have stumbled on an explanation while shooting this piece - The Big Nose Phenomenon. We've all seen a head on shot of a person's face - where the camera got a little too close. The person's nose in the resulting shot looks HUGE and way way out of proportion.

Now think about your vantage point when encountering a box with finial - in the real world - as opposed to the carefully photographed piece. You seldom first see the piece from a low angle. Instead, you're typically looking DOWN on it. THAT's where The Big Nose thing comes in.

Look at this set of shots of the piece and note how the appearance of the finial changes as the vantage point changes.


With a wide at the bottom, narrow at the top finial, looking downward at the piece doesn't cause a Big Nose problem. And looking at the profile of the piece from the side, the wider at the bottom, narrower at the top finial seems to be climbing up into the air - even more so if you're looking up at it. Cathedral designers have been using this perspective trick for a long long time.

Now what ELSE doesn't look right - or flat out wrong?

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#4

Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

kenvalaska

1. I like the box and subtle grain. The lines are apparently intended to be straight. Commonly a bit of accent is put at the junction line to provide emphasis, but I do not find the join line to be a problem or detract from the smooth surface.

2. The finial seems to my eye to be busy in contrast to the simplicity of the box. Less technical ornamention would flow with the box more smoothly. I guess the bumps and lumps on the finial are not consistent with the box.

3. The box and finial feek a bit mis-balanced. The technical execution looks very good, and the lines are crisp.

4. You photo display of perspective is excellent -- thanks for that piece of learning!!!!

I do really like the inner lid with the box -- perhaps less busy would be better, but it works better than the finial for me.

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#5

Ellis Walentine

Expectations

Ellis Walentine

Charlie, I don't know if there are any really objective critiques that can be made about choices such as you've made in this piece. I suspect that any time you defy the eye's expectations, it sets off an alarm, either in the observer's conscious or subconscious mind. Regarding finials, I think we're programmed (or, more properly, conditioned) to expect a spire that tapers to nothing at the top, so anything other than that jangles our expectations, whether we happen to articulate them or not. Who knows what kinds of associations these misplaced expectations set up in the viewer's mind? I think the task for the designer is to control the visual dialog, producing an intended reaction or perception that fulfills the intent of the piece. Maybe the question is, what motivated your decision to turn this finial with this particular complexity and visual balance?

Ellis

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#6

Charlie, you have designed a ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

contradictory question that does not have a satisfactory answer.

Start by looking at the box with the finial erased. Then ask yourself what finial would look good on this shape? Effectively you are looking at a large propane tank on its end. There is no finial which will look good on the "top". A small flared out finial on a small inset lid would possibly be acceptable. But with the break where you have it, there is no possibly acceptable finial. No matter what is placed there, it will be an imbalance.

My reaction when I looked at the first picture was that I was seeing a mallet and that one should grab it by wrapping their fingers around the "handle" with the thumb pointing at the box.

To a mathematician investigating a problem, proving that there is no solution is a very valuable answer.

Ed

Re: Pear Wood Capsule Box w Finial to Critique

#7

Great Comments and Observations

charlie belden

Thanks for contributing to the discussion

This piece was not �designed�. There was no thought out plan or design - which shows. And it has many of the common mistakes a newbie is likely to make - because there was little if any forethought.

Individually the parts are turned OK and look OK - separately. (Ed: I�d prefer �calsule shaped� to �looks like a large propane tank on its side� - sound more Arty ; ] With some modifications they could be improved. It�s when the parts are put together that things don�t work.

It starts with a newbie tendency to try and get the BIGGEST piece from an already rough to round blank rather than the BEST piece . So there wasn�t ANY consideration of proportions. The main goal was to get the top rounded to almost a hemisphere and getting the lid to fit the box. What the WHOLE piece would look like wasn�t even a consideration - a common mistake for a newbie.

The "neck" of the lid was the spigot for holding the lid in the chuck so the inside could be done. While still in the chuck the hole for the finial was drilled - which then defined the minimum diameter for the space to transition from box lid to finial.

That lack of a plan or vision of the WHOLE affected the finial as well - turned independent of what it would go on. BIG mistake. With the finial, the focus was on getting the tenon / spigot on the end to fit the hole in the neck of the box. Everything after that was Wingin� It.

Unfortunately, like most inexperienced turners, I had limited exposure to WHERE to Wing TO and just a vague idea of possible HOWs since I only knew how to use a skew and a parting tool at the time. Coves weren�t on the menu of possibilities - that would develop later.

Other than fitting on top of the box I had no understanding of what a finial CAN do for a piece - and it shows. If a finial is to be used, it�s not enough to just turn some elements reasonably well - especially it you start at the top and work backwards - without a plan. That way seldom leads to nice proportions nor a finial that goes with the piece under it. This one illustrates that point.

Ed is exactly right about the neck on the lid of the box precluding the use of any finial - as it is. Were it made shorter, and with an in sweepng curve that problem might be solved..

But the better path would be to go with K.I.S.S. - Keep It Simple Stupid - as Ken suggested. The box is plain and simple. And that�s not a bad thing. So keeping it simple would have been a better choice - maybe a simple mushroom pull - the top of the mushroom pull carrying the hemispeherical look of the top of the capsule box up to the top of the piece. In this case, showing off the ability to turn beads and an onion might be fun and challenging - but doesn�t work with this capsule box. The Shakers� Less Is More would have been a better choice.

The surprise of finding another lid inside the box is kind of fun. And if I�d gone with a simple little mushroom pull it would have looked better and go with the overall piece better. 20-20 hindsight is good - and critiqueing each completed piece can make the NEXT piece better.

Now to a point that Ellis raised - preconceived notions of what things SHOULD look like.

If you think of a finial, or a finialedd lidded box, a Drozda type finialed box is what you will probably think of. Cindy�s finials are the gold standard against which - onion finials are measured - and her lidded boxes are perfectly proportioned and executed just as well.

But there are other equally nice finials being done. I�m embarassed not to be able to acknowledge the turner who does the Question Mark finials - but he�s got it down to an art - and to me - the gold standard for that finial form.

While a spiral finial - or a triangular cross section finial are other possibilities, getting one that works with the rest of the piece requires foresight - not a quality of a newbie. That comes with exposure to nice pieces and an understanding of what makes them nice - and - experience playing with proportions and fair curves and learning about transitions and their importance - then actually using that knowledge. THAT�s the tricky part.

Ellis also brought up �the visual dialog� you want the viewer and the piece to have. That is really important - once you get past learning how to use some basic turning tools and how to hold parts so you can turn them - all those things required to MAKE a piece. The aesthetics and all the questions that should be asked - and most answered - before the turning begins - well that comes later - if you work at it. And THAT�s what probably makes a matured, experienced turners pieces stand out from the crowd.