Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Sincere Request for Assistance

Posts

Sincere Request for Assistance

#1

Don Pencil

Sincere Request for Assistance

Don Pencil

I have been trying to repoduce the finger prints discussed in previous threads concerning carnauba wax.

This is sincerely not a challenge to what has been written here previously. I believe this is happening. But I cannot make it happen here.

Therefore, I would like to find out why it is happening elsewhere.

For example, is it the wax? Maybe it is the wood. Is it the material under the wax used in preparing the wood for wax? Got me, but I would like to know what it is so that I can either correct it or inform those using carnauba wax as to when one cannot.

Would any or all of those who find this to be an issue please do the following:

1. Prepair a small piece of finished wood as you would a vessel or the like in the same way that has produced a finish that gets lots of finger prints from fondling.

2. Send it to me with a note as to how it was finished.

3. Post here on WoodCentral that you have done so. That will be a good way to, shall we say, keep me honest.

I will refund the cost of your postage and extend you an additional $20 credit for products from Don Pencil Woodturning, LLC.

I will post and discuss all of the pieces here in the Woodturners forum on WoodCentral.

I sincerely would like to either help everyone with correct application of carnauba wax or caution all as to its limitations (which I am confident it has).

Those of you who know me will understand that it is my sincere desire to validate the pro and con of all tech issues in woodturning.

Your help in this WILL be published here and your future input graciously welcomed.

Don Pencil

WWW.DONPENCIL.COM

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#2

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Jorge Casta�eda

Don,

Some of the problems I have seen using wax stem not from the wax itself but from some extremely acidic people's sweat, not every person, but there are some that cause problems when they handle the wood before and sometimes after it is finished.

$0.02

jorge

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#3

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Carole Valentine

Don,

Don't have a clue, but I wonder if it make a difference as to how long the underlying finish has been allowed to cure before the wax application? I don't have a problem with fingerprints on C wax, but I always wait until I can no longer smell any solvent from the finish and then add a day. If solvent is trapped under the wax, would it prevent the wax from hardening? I don't know but it seems possible. I also use very little wax on the wheel...if you look at the wheel you really cannot even tell if there is wax on it, but it still does the job.

Just some thoughts...

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#4

Ellis Walentine

Moisture is one problem

Ellis Walentine

I'm not sure if you're referring to pure carnauba, which comes in several grades, or some carnauba preparation, which may have spirits, emulsifiers, oils, even shellac in it; so I don't know that you are controlling enough variables here. If you're talking about solid, pure wax, the only way to put it on is to melt it on with friction, which you won't do with a sample piece of wood, unless it's spinning on the lathe. I used to use that as a quick and dirty finish, but any residual moisture in the wood soon causes the wax to blush and lift. I didn't read the other thread you mentioned, but my feeling is that carnauba wax itself has too high a melting point to take fingerprints unless a) the wax film has some kind of residual oil in it, or b) the fingers have some kind of solvent on them.

Sorry if this confuses the issue.

Ellis

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#5

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Don, I have had similar experiences regarding individual body chemistry to what Jorge reports. Some of it is extreme. Back in the 90s I made thousands of pens. For a while, I had a kid helping me in exchange for learning how to run the machinery in the shop. He would clean up, do some sanding, etc. I gave him a pen set for a Christmas present that year. Within two weeks the gold plating had completely corroded off the metal fittings! :O The base metal looked like it had been dipped in acid. It was pitted and corroded. These were not the cheapie pen kits either. His body chemistry just dissolved metal plating. I have seen it to varying degrees with other people too. Me, I can rust a watch band, no matter what it is made from. So I suspect that the results might generalize to wax and other finishes as well, varying by the person who handles the piece.

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#6

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I used fish for salmon with a guy who had what he called acid hands. If we were using herring for bait he had to have someone else bait his hook. If he handled the herring he simply wouldn't catch any fish. He was a good fisherman too.

Wally

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#7

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Jim Rutten

I played trombone in high school and college bands. I always picked up my trombone with a rag because otherwise the acid in my hands would eat right through the finish. I have seen many other amateurs and professionals who do the same thing. Kinda sounds like an evil villian, doesn't it. Tune into our next episode when Spiderman and the Flash take on Acidic Hands. Here's an excerpt:

Spiderman: Did you see him?

Flash: Yeah, he's just sitting there.

Spiderman: He's just sitting there?

Flash: With his hand on the safe door. He said in 36 years the money in the safe is his, all his.

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#8

Don Pencil

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

Don Pencil

Thank you all. I have not noticed the results in the past that are noted here.

I will now work to see if I can replicate these results from the information and we'll see where that goes.

No need to send samples at this time. Let me work on it using just the suggestions above.

Thanks,

Don

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#9

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

People who have problems with wax are forgetting that wax is the softest finish we can put on a piece of turned wood. It follows that it is also the least durable and the most influenced by exposure to chemicals of any kind.

The following are 4 of the common problems with wax.

1. The wax is applied too soon before any solvents in the finish are still evaporating. If you can smell them thay haven't evaporated yet. This can take weeks to months. These evaporating solvents and thinners will keep the wax soft and easilly damaged by handling or airborne pollutants.

2. Too thick. We almost universally put on too much wax. If it feels like wax, it is too thick.

3. Purity. The only way we can get a thin film of a hard wax like Carnauba is to apply it with a buffing wheel and sparingly, making sure we don't forget No. 1 and put it on too thick. Commercial paste waxes that claim to be Carnauba are always diluted with paraffin or beeswax, and that makes them softer than a pure carnauba, and more suseptable to damage from handling or the atmosphere around it.

4. Body chemistry will influence the life of any finish, and being softer, wax is the most easily damaged by handling and body chemistry. The above problems makes it worse.

Anybody who leaves fingerprints on a waxed surface fits into one or more of the above conditions.


everything I know about using wax on turned wood

Re: Sincere Request for Assistance

#10

Don Pencil

Agreed-That does about cover it.

Don Pencil

Thank you Russ.

That is about how it works with undercoats and peoples hands.

I do not personally usually use other coatings under the carnauba wax.

Tripoli, white diamond, carnauba used on bare wood.

The carnauba like other waxes and finishes also cures and gets harder over time.

If applied over other finishes as an additional protection it may well leave a light film look that, especially when "fondled", will be subject to finger prints. Like the finish on a car it is there as protection for the exsisting gloss finish.

Harder than oil, certainly softer than linear polyurethane.

Also note that pure carnauba wax (as noted in #3 of Russ's post) that is meant to be buffed on comes only in a solid carmel colored very hard bar.

Thanks for the input.

Unless someone has something additional to add I will put this one to bed.

Be Well,

Don