Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What's this worth?

Posts

What's this worth?

#1

Ellis Walentine

What's this worth?

Ellis Walentine

Here's a picture of a 1500# maple burl a guy in the Seattle area is trying to sell. He wants to know what it's worth. Any ballpark ideas?

Ellis


Re: What's this worth?

#2

Re: What's this worth?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I'd say it's worth no more than $100...tops. But I'm a giver...so let him know I'll pay $110.00.

Thanks

T.

Re: What's this worth?

#3

Re: What's this worth?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Contact Johannes Michelsen he would have a idea. They are sold by the pound so that's the starting point.

Re: What's this worth?

#4

Don Pencil

OOOODLES

Don Pencil

Re: What's this worth?

#5

Re: What's this worth?

Barbara Gill

Burl that has been opened is worth more a pound than one that has not. I don't remember what Dick and I paid per pound for our last shipment of Big Leaf Maple burl. Maybe he does.

Re: What's this worth?

#6

Re: What's this worth?

Don at Central Illinois

It's worthless! Just ship it to me and I'll get rid of it for him. heh heh

Re: What's this worth?

#7

Ballpark

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

$2.50/lb. Best move it soon while you can still sell water.

Re: What's this worth?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Tough one

Steven Antonucci

First, I know a couple of folks that sell between $2-3/#, but they aren't anywhere near that scale. I think it would be hard to "get it in bulk" without some kind of discount, and finding one buyer who will pay to ship it is going to be very difficult. Sawing it may be his best option, and then I think you could get back towards $2-3/#, but you have to "carry inventory" and deal with processing costs.

Don't know if it's a cow/steak situation...but sure looks like one!

S

Re: What's this worth?

#9

Mike Stafford

At least 1000 words....

Mike Stafford

Re: What's this worth?

#10

Re: What's this worth? *LINK*

charlie belden

A former Silicon Valley Woodturners member, Tony Brayhan, was commissioned to turn a 600 pound maple burl - into a home theater speaker cone. The burl cost the the guy $3000 - and then paid at least that to have Tony turn it.

I suspect that a veneer maker might pay more for it than someone looking to use it as a single piece or even sawn boards.

Global Wood Source (www.globalwoodsource.com) here in San Jose, CA has had LARGE (we're talking 8' tall or taller by 8' diameter) burls on their warehouse floor. Might find a price for something similar on their site.


600 pound burl - on a lathe!

Re: What's this worth?

#11

Re: What's this worth?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I wouldn't even consider buying a burl of that type unless it was cut so that I could see what's inside. I've had some unpleasant surprises with rot and large bark inclusions.

Burl is usually sold by the pound. Nobody has yet convinced me that a wet burl is worth more than a dry burl.

Prices in the NW can vary a lot. I can buy it at $2 a lb. or $10. I've shopped around in Washington and Oregon.

Wally

Re: What's this worth?

#12

Don in central washington

Re: What's this worth?

don in central washington

Sliced first! Could be just punk/dull inside.Buyers want birdseye.I don't see the classic points a birdsyes burl has. Cost wise I purchase whole logs/stumps

for .70cents a lb in 3k lots. plus shipping! others we haul home @ .35 /lb

and use 75% of that for heat.

the delivery guys want an additional 65.oo for lift gate and another fee

for residental delivery. have him contact the local aaw group(s)

am sure they will help him.

Don

Re: What's this worth?

#13

Steve Kubien

Re: What's this worth?

Steve Kubien

Until it is opened and one can really judge the quality of the wood, it is only worth the going rate for fire wood.

Re: What's this worth?

#14

Re: What's this worth?

Russ Fairfield

$0.25 a pound "as is", and I would walk away from it at that price. I would most likely offer the guy $100 for his effort, and not be disappointed if he doesn't take it.

There are 3 things wrong with this one.

1st is that the only thing I know about it is there is no evidence of any birds-eye figuring. This type of growth is rather common on Big Leaf Maple, and it may or may not have some interesting growth figuring. The way to know is to cut it open.

2nd problem is that the color tells me that it is getting old, and hasn't been given any care or protection to keep it from deteriorating.

3rd is that I see a lot of cracks starting because #2 wasn't taken care of. Cracks in this wood are usually quite deep by the time they show on the surface. Those cracks tell me that the best I can do is cut it up into smaller pieces, and I don't know hopw many and how small until I start sawing.

Re: What's this worth?

#15

Don Pencil

Re: What's this worth?

Don Pencil

If it is in good shape the veneer guys will pay a lot of money for a big one.

Much more that turners.

Don Pencil

WWW.DONPENCIL.COM

Re: What's this worth?

#16

Steven Antonucci

who is going to split it? ;-) (not me)

Steven Antonucci

Re: What's this worth?

#17

Steve Kubien

Good point

Steve Kubien

You are right Steve. So, I guess it is worth even less than that.

Re: What's this worth?

#18

Re: Good point

fgvanatta

Listen to what Russ said. He has experience with these things.

Frank

Re: What's this worth?

#19

Re: What's this worth?

Tery Scott

Sorry but I think this is a lemon by the looks of it

I think you will find that the grain in this will be a curve or bend each way from center or a swirling grain no birds eye

As there are no bud protrusions evident

It would have to be cut in half before Id even consider offering a price .It may well be punky dosy wood.

Maybe Auctioning it would get a better price

Or offer to take it off his hands in exchange for making something out of a portion of the wood in return (thats if its any good )

Re: What's this worth?

#20

Not to be cynical, but...

wilbur

Are we sure this burl was obtained legally? There have been reports of people going into, say, public lands, finding a burl on a tree, and poaching it by cutting the tree down illegaly, or even just cutting the burl off the tree.

Re: What's this worth?

#21

Steven Antonucci

Good point

Steven Antonucci

There is an enormous burl growing on a tree by me, and I noticed that someone had chainsawed off one face of it. Since it is growing on State land, I assume this was a drive by hit from someone who knew what it was, as they also needed a ladder to do it.

I know where a few good burls are, but I'll wait for the trees to die before I get them (if ever).

s

Re: What's this worth?

#22

Dick Hines

Re: What's this worth?

Dick Hines

$1.15 per pound Barbara.

Re: What's this worth?

#23

Re: What's this worth?

fgvanatta

Terry is another knowledgeable person about burls. Between his comments and Russ's I think you'll find everything you need to know about this burl.

Frank

Re: What's this worth?

#24

Ellis Walentine

Thanks

Ellis Walentine

I'll pass your advice along to the fellow.

Ellis