Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

craftsmanship-a little long

Posts

craftsmanship-a little long

#1

craftsmanship-a little long

john lucas

I'm going to delve into Charlies question a little bit but remove it from the turn and burn post because that's been answered.

I was on the board of the Tennessee Arts and Crafts Association to represent the photographers in a debate over digital vs chemical photographs. As in Charlies example the digital people stated that in was what's in the photographers eye not how it was achieved that counts. (I agree on that one). Imagination and being in the right place at the right time is what should count.

The chemical people said, all they do is push a button on the computer. Sound familiar. The funny part of this was the guy with the loudest voice was using a print machine to process his prints so the only difference between him and guy using a digital printer was putting the negative in the enlarger and sizing and maybe some dodging and burning (which is an art in itself).

In short the board decided that in the charter it says "must be hand made" so they ruled out digital. That's was 6 years ago. I visited the same fair last year and digital prints ruled the roost. I suppose it was pressure from the photographers because you almost can't get chemicals anymore and in truth digital has many advantages to a creative mind.

So here's my question. I think laser engraving right now looks like factory made crap. That doesn't mean an artist can't sit at the computer and manipulate it to the point that the engraving would be some thing special. It will come some day. Let's face it, there are carvers out there who can produce the most incredible work, you and I will probably never achieve that. However if you really want to make a piece that you've designed and it's beyond your hand skill, but you have the computer skills and can borrow an engraver, would you do it. I think I would. How do you feel about this.

Again, for me it's about the final product, not how I get there. It's for you to decide if you like the piece, possibly tempered by how it's made. If we compare that incredible carver with my piece, the public in general will decide based on the design and whether the like it or not. The collectors and wood art officianado's will decide based on skill and technique as well as design and will probably pick the carver.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#2

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

Don Wilcut

Well put John

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#3

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

Peter Hyde

John you missed out one important factor, price. Price mostly decides whether the craftsmanship or the CNC made piece ends up on the mantle piece. Another is notoriety or fame. Once a name is famous then there is nothing to stop that famous person resorting to all the tricks and mechanised aids necessary to produce at a certain price level to maintain market position and increase profit.

Craftsmanship and "hand made" are really of no importance in today's economics.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#4

Steven Antonucci

To expand upon the photo analogy

Steven Antonucci

I was a "death before digital" guy many moons ago. Digital was a transformative technology for photography- it actually changed the way people viewed and used cameras. We now almost all have a digital camera on our person at all times (in our cell phones, which was another...I digress).

People today can still point and shoot the way that they did with their disposables, Nikons, Canons and Hasselblads. Does digital make you a better photographer? I would argue no. In fact, because it is easier, I think it encourages laziness. Miss a shot? Hit the button again. With film, you didn't know until you got a print back. It forced you to pay attention to everything, just to get a negative.

Printing was another art. Think of it like the difference between a hobbiest and a serious hobbiest. A casual turner vs. that guy at your club that you want to be like. If you printed your own work, you had even more control over the outcome- good or bad. I have a box full of really, really bad prints to support this. It could easily be replaced by the shelf full of bad forms, mistakes, and prototypes in my wood shop.

As a culture, we like to replace hard with easy. We like instant results. We like to be good without trying. I think it's very dangerous to commoditize talent and put it out there to the masses. Can a machine work more efficiently than I can? If you were with me at the forge yesterday, you know the answer to that question already.

John Henry was a lesson written over a hundred years ago, and we still are learning it.

Steve

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#5

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

John K Jordan

Excellent points. I didn't read the other thread yet so this may have been addressed, but to me the term "laser" doesn't rule out a hand-held laser used just as chisel or a brush or a wood "vaporizer". Imagine the possibilities. Of course, talk about dangerous tools! This would require exceptional care and eye and skin protection and interlocks on the doors to othe shop - a laser beam momentarily glancing off an incidental reflective surface has permanently damaged many eyes in laboratory situations - I know a guy who has a permanent streak across his vision from a shiny wrench falling through the beam.

Another point - when I was in the 3D graphics business I had a digitizer arm that let me sculpture on a digital computer model - push, pull, deform, sculpt, cut, paste. My attempts were pitiful, but if I created a digital masterpiece then turned a block of wood into the shape with a computer-driven machine, would it not be my hand work? In that case, the CNC machine would function as my rotary carver. (I heard an old woodcarver once complain about the new-fangled rotary carvers which did not require true skill.)

What about machine-made copies of an original? I have paid good money for for prints, both in ink and photo paper, that were produced by a press or machine from an original. These are often signed and numbered and the artist sometimes supposedly destroys the original after the run. How would that differ from an original work "printed" in wood some other substance?

To me, the art is in the result, not the process the artist uses. The value of the art work, of course, is up to the buyer who today, at least, perceives a higher value in something unique made by a human who touches it directly.

JKJ

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#6

Darn-price is where I always screw up

John Lucas

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#7

Well said John

John Lucas

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#8

Re: To expand upon the photo analogy

John Lucas

Steve I think digital has actually improved photography. Being able to shoot, look at the image and decide how it needs to be improved and then shoot it again is a big boom toward the learning curve.

The same might be with CNC carving in the future. You could draw it until you like it. Make it. Decide if it's as good as you want and then remake it.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#9

Re: To expand upon the photo analogy

John K Jordan

Besides the amazing plummeting cost of memory and LCD displays, I think what finally made digital photography acceptable to professionals was when the sensor technology reached the point where you couldn't see the pixelization in the image and the embedded computer hardware got fast enough.

I remember long discussions on photography forums about what impossible resolution would be needed to equal a slide or print film. At the time, even the digital geeks couldn't predict that we'd all be carrying around tiny 12 megapixel pocket cameras bought in Walmart for less than a good darkroom timer. Just imagine what the image file size would be!!! Who would put up with that many floppy disks to archive?? How many images could you fit on your 15 megabyte camera memory card, and how many hours would they take to transfer to the computer??

Another thing which was often discussed was the narrow latitude in digital compared to negative film. (Forget the fact that slide film is also pretty narrow) Blow out the highlights in digital and they are truely gone - no darkroom burning is going to help. However, with the instant feedback image on the back of the camera, as well as an instant histogram on many, this has not proven to be a huge problem for most photos. For those cases with extreme brightness levels, I'm sure most photographers have learned the (tripod) trick of shooting twice at different exposure settings then combining the two in Photoshop. And when finally sensors go to greater bit depths, digital latitude will be amazing - doubles with every additional bit.

JKJ

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#10

Steven Antonucci

Digital has improved one aspect (IMHO)

Steven Antonucci

There are far fewer "completely worthless" images, because we delete them. A lot of people also edit what makes it to paper, but I think there are quite a few more bad images because it doesn't costs anything to produce them. Quality may appear to be better, but it's a law of averages thing.

In the old days of film, you had 24 chances to get it right. A good hobbiest might get 3-4 really good shots per roll, with a bunch of average stuff and a few duds. Today, maybe they get 10, but they probably took 150 to get those 10 because there are no penalties for doing it wrong.

Turning could easily go this route. Easier is fine, as long as it comes with a quality requirement. I have to go clean up my HDD because of all of the pictures that are clogging it up- most of them are worthless, and I'll just move them to another HDD (because it is easier than deleting them)...

S

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#11

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

charlie belden

I'm certain this question has come up in the world of art going back to the cave paintings in France.

"I DREW my hand. All HE did was chew up some ash from the fire, put his hand on the wall and SPIT - over and over and over again - to outline his hand. Hell, a kid could do THAT."

When small computers began being used as a "word processor" Typists probably saw the writing on the wall and Underwood started looking to diversify. Some writers saw the potential while others stuck with their 2B pencils and pads of paper. Now some may say that the pencil and pad writers were more skilled because they had to really think about the next sentence or the next word, for getting it wrong meant a lot of work to recover from a poor choice later. On the other hand, using a word processor provided a means to quickly and fairly easily try variations of wording and restructuring - without losing what was already done and deemed good. Today word processing is something we take for granted. Has the quality of literature been diminished by the use of word processing? That could be a whole other discussion.

Digital photography and image processing software started out pretty clunky and primitive. The resolution was much lower than that of film and the digital darkroom was rudimentary. I recall when the threshold of equivalence between digital and film was 5 megapixels. Today most Point and Shoot digital cameras have 4 megapixel resolution. And PhotoShop allows even a novice to do things that can't be done with film, and enlarger, photo paper and chemical processing - of both the negative and the print.

Digital photography was a paradigm shift. Composing In Camera is still a useful skill, but not a make or break skill since digital permits for more options to be tried. Where Ansel Adams had to spend time setting up, framing his desired image, calculating exposures, mounting plates, activating the shutter, changing plates . . . AND THEN hours and hours and hours in the darkroom dodging and burning then waiting for the print to dry to see if he got what he was after, today he could do all that and then some in the time it took to set up his tripod, mount the camera and get under the cloth hood to see his upside down image on the back plate of the camera. I can only imagine what he would have created had he had "Sharpen", "Adjust Contrast and Brightness" - and UNDO as well as SAVE AS.

Does digital photography in any way diminish Ansel's accomplishements? Only an ignorant fool would say yes.

I think of computers, computer software and computer controlled devices as Levers and Amplifiers. They provide the ability to lift what I couldn't otherwise lift and to take a small idea and permit me to work with it and amplify it into perhaps an actual real world thing..

Now some would say that reducing the element of risk in the creation of a piece diminishes the aesthetic value of the end result. I see the element of risk as a barrier that often prevents ideas from becoming realities. If the threshold of risk is lowered more ideas can be pursued and more and better pieces will be the result. Will there also be a lot of crap created. Sure. But a room full of horse manure probably means there's actually at least a pony and maybe even a horse somewhere in there or in the vicinity.

I wonder when a "wood artist" will start using a HiVac system and an Electron Beam Gun to vaporize metals onto the surfaces of a piece?

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#12

I could do that!

John Lucas

"I DREW my hand. All HE did was chew up some ash from the fire, put his hand on the wall and SPIT - over and over and over again - to outline his hand. Hell, a kid could do THAT."

I laughed at that. I hear that same thing often at craft shows. Man looking at $25 item- "I could make that cheaper than that" My best friend has the perfect come back. He says well how much do you think you could make them for. Guy says $10. Randy then says well I'll tell you what. You make all you can for $10 and bring them back and I'll buy them from you because I know I can sell them for $25.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#13

Don Pencil

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

Don Pencil

My opinion.

As well noted here, opinions and/or protests offered on a topic change over time. So it should be. Progress will do that.

Therefore the definition of art or craftmanship at any point is time needs to be defined by the forum.

When, as in the previous debate, art must be made in a certain way, then the forum dictates the craftmanship to be used.

As to what is the definition of craftmanship, like other words, has somewhat evolved over time. Let's not get do deep into minutia of this. Let us just see that the term applies, one way or the another, to those either engaged in a working craft or art. One might be a poor, good, or excellent craftsman. Therefore, being a craftsman in our current age would very well include those who can work in the particular craft with computers.

For the purposes of judging a particular skill within the craft, one may rule out the use of computers or hand tools. A judging of painted landscapes may be limited to water colors only. Another using only oils.

Ladies and gentlemen, the defining of craftsmanship is not the forum.

Be Well,

Don

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#14

Maybe... (IMHO)

Ron Sardo

When I was a shooting pictures for a living, I had no problems burning though 10 rolls of film to get that "One Perfect Shot".

Back then, I never showed anybody the other 200+ images, I just showed them the best one.

The only real difference, now anybody with a digital camera can afford to take as many pictures as they wish... and it doesn't cost them anything.

I've always been a believer it is more the person behind the camera than the camera itself.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#15

Re: craftsmanship-a little long *LINK*

Dick Coers

I think laser engraving right now looks like factory made crap

Sorry, can't agree with you on that John. Once again, it's the artist that is working the software to create the art. Crap in, crap out. The only thing lacking for really wildy utilizing an engraver on our round work, is a 5 axis machine. Here are some fine examples of good laser work on flat work.


engraving on leather

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#16

Don Pencil

There ya go-Good Point

Don Pencil

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

Keith Tompkins

This much I know about digital photography..I can shoot an image of a new piece, and within a few minutes a prospective customer in China or the UK is checking it out on their computer. Many of my sales are made this way.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#18

and they aren't deleting them

John Lucas

I went to a friends house the other day and he wanted to show me a shot of his daughter. He went through about 200 photos that I would have tossed before he found that one good one.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#19

I agree

John Lucas

Obviously I haven't seen all there is out there. Most of what I've seen are nice carvings of a drawing but the vessels they are on both glass and wood didn't fit the drawings or the shapes.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#20

Steven Antonucci

But for a different reason than film

Steven Antonucci

We have boxes of prints that we paid for that SHOULD be tossed, but won't because they are "paid for".

In digital, you already own the storage device, and likely replace the computer before the HDD fills (unless you are me working on this ancient technology I use every day...). I'd probably go through and reorganize my pics someday, but it's such a daunting task, I can always buy a bigger HDD...

I do need to clean up thoug, as I am down to less than 1GB of available space, and wearing out the LED on the HDD while swapping memory....

S

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#21

Machine gun pictures

Jim H

My two kids are in Karate and I use my Nikon in �sports� mode and just hold the button down. I probably only keep 20-25 of the 300-500 I shoot, but the action is so fast I would never get those 20-25 otherwise.

I�m just starting to turn, but hope I can someday have better odds at the lathe.

:D

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#22

Steven Antonucci

I have 4 kids and it takes that many...

Steven Antonucci

just to get one where everyone is smiling and looks good!

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#23

My biggest fear

Ron Sardo

Yes storage is cheap today (I have two 1TB drives on my system at work), I literately have Gigabytes worth of images stored (and backed up multiple times)

But 20 years from now the media will be antiquated. Will there be hardware that will be able to retrieve those images? (Will I really need them?)

How many here can still read 3.5" floopies?

How about 5-1/4" or maybe even 8" floppies?

I have a box fill of zip disks, but no zip drive.

Luckily we can still have 100 year old negatives and we can still make prints.

I hope we can still print today's images 100 years from now.

Sorry, I think I got off track here...

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#24

Same type arguements among digital photographers

Charlie Anderson

JKJ touched on this.

Many of today's photographers dislike HDR (high dynamic range) and think that it's cheating.

Re: craftsmanship-a little long

#25

I feel your pain

Jim H