craftsmanship-a little long
john lucas
I'm going to delve into Charlies question a little bit but remove it from the turn and burn post because that's been answered.
I was on the board of the Tennessee Arts and Crafts Association to represent the photographers in a debate over digital vs chemical photographs. As in Charlies example the digital people stated that in was what's in the photographers eye not how it was achieved that counts. (I agree on that one). Imagination and being in the right place at the right time is what should count.
The chemical people said, all they do is push a button on the computer. Sound familiar. The funny part of this was the guy with the loudest voice was using a print machine to process his prints so the only difference between him and guy using a digital printer was putting the negative in the enlarger and sizing and maybe some dodging and burning (which is an art in itself).
In short the board decided that in the charter it says "must be hand made" so they ruled out digital. That's was 6 years ago. I visited the same fair last year and digital prints ruled the roost. I suppose it was pressure from the photographers because you almost can't get chemicals anymore and in truth digital has many advantages to a creative mind.
So here's my question. I think laser engraving right now looks like factory made crap. That doesn't mean an artist can't sit at the computer and manipulate it to the point that the engraving would be some thing special. It will come some day. Let's face it, there are carvers out there who can produce the most incredible work, you and I will probably never achieve that. However if you really want to make a piece that you've designed and it's beyond your hand skill, but you have the computer skills and can borrow an engraver, would you do it. I think I would. How do you feel about this.
Again, for me it's about the final product, not how I get there. It's for you to decide if you like the piece, possibly tempered by how it's made. If we compare that incredible carver with my piece, the public in general will decide based on the design and whether the like it or not. The collectors and wood art officianado's will decide based on skill and technique as well as design and will probably pick the carver.




