Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

could this be a new question... (long)

Posts

could this be a new question... (long)

#1

could this be a new question...  (long)

GaryG in MD

...about sanding and finishing? I kinda figure they've all been asked and answered before, but I've been here for several years and can't remember this one, this way.

First the setup, then the question. I'm working on a 11+" silver maple bowl loaded with "features" of all kinds. I want it to look really nice. I generally want a "satin" finish -- with the grain showing through -- shiny but not plasticy.

My normal procedure on smaller pieces is to sand carefully on the lathe to 320 (so as not to burnish), apply a couple soaking coats of Watco Danish (if I don't mind the yellowing and darkening) to pop the grain (or so they say), do an intermediate sanding to, say, 800. Put on a building finish like WOP, and sand it out with abrasive pads to somewhere between Abralon 1000-4000. Voila.

I was working on the intermediate step today on this reasonably large (for me with a 12" lathe) bowl, and found a fair amount of 320 scratches in the heart wood (few in the sap wood). But that's another story. Mind you, it's already had it's couple heavy coats of Watco, so it's well sealed but has little or no build.

Scratches drive me crazy when I'm shooting for a proper shine, so I'm sitting here, outside on a nice day, relaxing and taking them down to 800 (invisible to my eye) by hand off the lathe. This was not such a bad thing (once) -- but enough is enough! I still have the inside to do!

I think I'm overdoing the intermediate step. Hence (finally) the question.

For a given finish from our standard set of same (the answer will be different for different ones), what size/grit/depth of scratches will be hidden/buried/covered up by the given finish? In other words, if I'm going to finish with , say, WOP, can I tolerate scratches at the 400 level and they'll disappear under the finish after, say two coats? What about Waterlox, lacquer, tung oil, blends, etc.? Obviously, thicker or higher-build finishes should cover deeper scratches -- or will they? I'm sure it would take a huge number of coats of lacquer, and they might never disappear. So, is there some kind of "rule of thumb" for this kind of thing?

Thanks for reading. ...Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#2

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Barry Irby

Gary, I am not an expert on finishing and my eyesight is not what it used to be, so I sometimes find scratches much later in the process than I would like.

I don't think the finish hides anything. In fact, I call the first coat The Reveal. I try to carry the piece outside into strong sunlight to look it over before I finish sanding. Or I use a bright incandescent point source of light. Fluorescent lights tend to blur things for me. I have lots of them for general illumination but they are not good for fine work and detecting scratches.

Random orbital sanders and even rotary power sanding tends to not leave straight scratches. Random scratches may show less.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#3

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Ralph

Gary

I'm also not an expert, but I can relate what I think works, for me.

I don't believe there is a fixed grit to sand to, that is always sand to XXX girt. Since the density of the wood, the application, etc, etc, are very too much

So, What I do is keep sanding until I can't see where the current grit made any difference, then go one grit finer.

For soft woods, say like Big Leaf Maple or Alder, that can mean stopping at 400 grit. For a really hard dense tropical wood, I might go to 2000 (body finish) or switch to MicroMesh or other system and go up to near the upper end there.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#4

JL

No real "rule" - entirely finish dependent

JL

In my experience on flat furniture that is. Usually if you get to the 300+ grit range, most of your building finishes will fill your scratches. Jeff Jewitt's finishing book has a good section on this.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#5

Richard Allen

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Richard Allen

Hi Gary,

FINISH WILL NOT HIDE SCRATCHES. FINISH WILL ENHANCE SCRATCHES.

I wouldn't worry much about burnishing. As the grit gets finer and finer on the lathe use a lighter touch and use compressed air to blow off the sand paper and the turned object.

Wet the object with the solvent used in your finish to help you detect scratches.

Once the object is sanded, but still mountable on the lathe dismount the object, examine the object under magnification in strong light.

If there are only a few scratches visible then hand sand those scratches out. If the scratches are all over then re-mount and sand through the necessary grits.

Note that some directions of rotation will promote scratches. Try changing the rotation of the sanding disc..

Sanding with the grain will "hide the scratches in straight grain wood but bowl sanding is mostly cross grain sanding. So we need to sand to much higher grits. The key is to sand. Fine sandpaper fills with sanding dust very quickly so a light touch and cleaning the paper and object becomes more and more important as grit gets finer.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#6

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

John K Jordan

(oops, I wrote this yesterday and forgot to send it)

I try not to rely on the hope that any clear finish will hide scratches. Sometimes it will, but usually not. I see many otherwise nice pieces that are "ruined" by visible scratches. To me, the most offensive scratches are concentric. I see this so often on pieces from certain people that I wonder if the person just can't see the scratches due to vision problems, hasn't learned how to look closely, or sees them perhaps at the end and simply doesn't care, maybe out of laziness because of the effort it would take to go back and fix things. I guess another reason may be that one person's tolerance for scratches is different than another's.

The grits I use depend somewhat on the wood. A dark, dense wood will often show more and need finer grits, as will end grain vs side grain.

While I use sanding disks as needed on larger work, I like to do most of my sanding by hand. Scratches with the grain/figure, especially fine scratches, are more difficult to see than scratches across the grain. I sand with the grain (or figure on end grain) until the previous scratches are gone. Then before moving to the next grit, I sand across the grain OR move to the next grit and power sand with a disk - this puts scratches every which way which I then remove by hand with the grain/figure. This puts down visible scratches to be removed with the next finer grit.

In addition to examining under a good point source light, wetting the wood with something that evaporates quickly such as naptha will help reveal otherwise invisible scratches.

Related to removing scratches, of course, is removing every trace of tearout at the coarsest grit. When fibers tear out there is often sub-surface damage so it is best to sand a little past the point where the tearout is no longer visible, otherwise it can come back to haunt you. This is where a coarse grit sanding disk works well. I often use small curved cabinet scrapers instead of sandpaper, especially on softer wood, since they are aggressive at removing material and finer than coarse paper and don't tend to make an uneven surface by removing more material in the softer areas.

JKJ

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#7

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Russ Fairfield

Lighting is important for seeing scratches. Fluorescent lighting makes scratches more difficult to see because there are no shadows. The harsher incandescent light bulb creates shadows that make scratches more visible. You will always leave scratches on the surface of the wood if you use fluorescent lighting in your shop, and you will always be able to see them if you take the piece outside or into the house where the lighting is different.

Your Government is in the process of improving your finishes by forcing all inside lighting to be fluorescent. When all lighting is fluorescent, you won't be able to see those scratches unless you take the piece outside in sunlight.

Scratches are all about perception, how closely we inspect, and what we are willing to let get by. When was the last time you picked up a table and inspected the surface under different lighting sources and directions like you are doing with your woodturning?? When was the last time you looked at the table top with a magnifying glass, like some do with their turned wood?? You look at a table top from 3' away. Do the same with your woodturning and the they will start looking better. Start looking at the table-top with the same critical eye, and you will be haveing the same problems with scratches.

The table-top finisher has an advantage in that all of the grain is in the same direction, they always finish each sanding step by sanding with the grain, and the only end grain is on the ends where nobody looks. Turned wood has all grain directions visible at the same time, and we make things worse by using lathe power to hand-sand; and worse yet, we use sanding discs that leave circular scratches that cannot be hidden by any of the wood grain.

End-grain absorbs more finish than flat-grain, and it will always look darker if we use a finish; and the more color the finish add to the wood, the darker will be the end-grain. When it looks good, we call these color varriations an "enhancement", or "chatoyance" when it looks really good. When it doesn't look good, we call it "blotch". We can somewhat solve the difference by sanding the end-grain areas to at least 2 sandpaper grit gtades finer than the flat-grain areas. Furniture folks do this all the time to keep the ends of the table-top from being darker than the top. A woodturner can do the same thing by sanding everywhere to the finer grit, and than going back ove the flat-grain areas with a coarser grit sandpaper.

End grain is always harder to sand and it will unually be easier to leave scratches behind as we move on to finer abrasives.

I have never seen a finisg that will hide scratches when we look at it closely. You will always have to make a judgement call on what is acceptable, and what isn't.

Most scratches are left over fron a coarser grit. You just weren't able to see them until the surface was smoother to make them more visible.

Two other sources of scratches are shop dirt that gets on the finer grits of sandpaper, and using cheap sandpaper where that larger grit may be on the surface. It only takes one particle to ruin a 400 or 600 grit sanded surface.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#8

Re: No real "rule" - entirely finish dependent

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the reference. I'll check it out. ...Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#9

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

GaryG in MD

Thanks Russ. Lots of good info there. Appreciated.

I think one of the reasons the fluorescent shop lights make scratches to see is the fact that they are an "extended source" (i.e., physically long). The CFLs should have pretty much the same characteristics as a standard incandescent bulb -- except for color, etc. ...Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#10

Thanks everyone

GaryG in MD

Thanks to everyone for your excellent comments.

I'll have to read them all carefully a second time and digest all this.

Looks like I'm just going to have to keep sanding until the scratches are gone enough for my personal taste. Unfortunately, that's going to be a lot of sanding. The "branch inclusions" (we used to call them "knots" before art came in), being end grain, really hold the scratches.

Back on my head with the 800, Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#11

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Russ Fairfield

The extended length of the fluorescent has a lot to do with there being no shadows, but their color temperature is also important.

The new lights don't make surfaces and finishes look any better than the fluorescent overhead shop lights for me. The only thing they have to offer is they are brighter and closer; but they don't make seeing sanding scratches any easier to see. Others may have a different experience with them, but I went back to incandescent bulbs for close-up lighting.

The best shop lighting for me has been fluorescents with additional 200 and 300 watt incandescents over the working and finishing area.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#12

Re: Thanks everyone

Ralph

Gary, I find myself, repeatedly, sanding to 320/400, then going back up to 120 to fix something I didn't notice, then going all the way down, again.

As Russ implied, it's usually end-grain that I end up sanding and re-sanding

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#13

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Russ Fairfield

Gary,

Most people try to hurry the sanding and finishing. The truth is that, if it doesn't take as long, or longer, to sand and finish the piece of wood as it took to turn it, you aren't doing it right.

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#14

yup

GaryG in MD

As usual, Russ, you are absolutely correct.

Indeed, a gallery quality finish will probably take twice as long as the turning, depending on the complexity of the shape, of course.

We just have to learn to enjoy it -- that final hand touch. I can dig it.

The outside is done (but not finished); next for the inside. ...Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#15

Sanding time

John K Jordan

Twice the turning time is a good rule-of-thumb, perhaps for a "common" bowl, but I found how long it actually takes depends on things like the type of wood, the type of turning, and the skill in both turning and sanding. Sanding a large roughly-turned piece with a lot of detail in unforgiving wood may take much longer than turning it. Some simpler designs in softer wood such as red cedar may be relatively quick to make smooth (especially if starting with a cabinet scraper). And something small like a finger top in a wood like cocobolo or ebony can be cut so smoothly it can often be done with only the finest grits and take very little time to sand compared to the turning time, even if it has a lot of detail.

When I first started turning wood an experienced turner told me how much he hated sanding, doing as little as "necessary". My first thought was "you might want to take up some other hobby." His work showed his impatience, with concentric gouge marks and lines of visible torn grain covered with finish.

I find sanding a sort of zen thing, comforting and quiet when done by hand with the lathe turned off.

BTW, this entire discussion assumes the perhaps narrow view that pieces should in fact be sanded to perfection. There is plenty of room in woodturning for unsanded pieces with the character of intentional tool marks.

JKJ

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#16

thanks John

GaryG in MD

You have spoken a lot of truths here -- very well said. ...Gary

Re: could this be a new question... (long)

#17

Re: could this be a new question...  (long)

Larry

As I remember, the re-finishers out in Syracuse told me that the finish will magnify scratches, not hide them. They were pretty adamant about it. Over the years I've come to be a believer. You can fill the scratch so that it's level, but it will still show. Sanding is easy and takes less time and effort than the building. Why leave scratches?