could this be a new question... (long)
GaryG in MD
...about sanding and finishing? I kinda figure they've all been asked and answered before, but I've been here for several years and can't remember this one, this way.
First the setup, then the question. I'm working on a 11+" silver maple bowl loaded with "features" of all kinds. I want it to look really nice. I generally want a "satin" finish -- with the grain showing through -- shiny but not plasticy.
My normal procedure on smaller pieces is to sand carefully on the lathe to 320 (so as not to burnish), apply a couple soaking coats of Watco Danish (if I don't mind the yellowing and darkening) to pop the grain (or so they say), do an intermediate sanding to, say, 800. Put on a building finish like WOP, and sand it out with abrasive pads to somewhere between Abralon 1000-4000. Voila.
I was working on the intermediate step today on this reasonably large (for me with a 12" lathe) bowl, and found a fair amount of 320 scratches in the heart wood (few in the sap wood). But that's another story. Mind you, it's already had it's couple heavy coats of Watco, so it's well sealed but has little or no build.
Scratches drive me crazy when I'm shooting for a proper shine, so I'm sitting here, outside on a nice day, relaxing and taking them down to 800 (invisible to my eye) by hand off the lathe. This was not such a bad thing (once) -- but enough is enough! I still have the inside to do!
I think I'm overdoing the intermediate step. Hence (finally) the question.
For a given finish from our standard set of same (the answer will be different for different ones), what size/grit/depth of scratches will be hidden/buried/covered up by the given finish? In other words, if I'm going to finish with , say, WOP, can I tolerate scratches at the 400 level and they'll disappear under the finish after, say two coats? What about Waterlox, lacquer, tung oil, blends, etc.? Obviously, thicker or higher-build finishes should cover deeper scratches -- or will they? I'm sure it would take a huge number of coats of lacquer, and they might never disappear. So, is there some kind of "rule of thumb" for this kind of thing?
Thanks for reading. ...Gary



