Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Posts

Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#1

Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Galen Vetterick

I watched Ray Key's "The Basic Box" video and it is the first time I have seen sanding through the grits with wax on the sandpaper. He noted the use of wet/dry silicone carbide papers but did not say what type of wax was used, It looked like a very soft paste consistancy. Since he said the boxes were turned at 1200 to 1500 rpm he never notes if he slows the lathe to sand so I assume it is at the same speed. He says it reduces heat from friction and cut down on the dust. It looks like he puts on a different type of wax for the final finish but never really says what it is. Sure leaves a newer turner with queations why.

Is sanding with wax a very common practice on boxes or more just Key's method?

For those who do sand with wax what type of wax is used?

What do you put over the piece as a final finish?

Thanks if you can comment

Galen

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#2

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Greg Haugen

This is a technique that I use and learned from watching his DVDs. I've corresponded through email with Ray about this. He uses a "Supreme Wax" that's made by Fiddes. It is available in the US from finewoodfinishes.com ("light" is their "natural"). In the DVDs he uses Briwax as the final finish. As he also recommends, DO NOT USE BRIWAX TO SAND. The thinner, toulene, is very reactive and can burn your skin. He uses the Supreme Wax in his shop as a sanding wax and finish wax. It has a "cooler" thinner in it, and as a final finish wax he applies it and waits a while to buff it. I'll wait 20-40 minutes and then buff. I sand my boxes at approx. 600 rpms. Some do clean off the box between grits, removing the wax. I don't. I'm sanding and adding wax anyways, there's no harm in it. On softer woods, a thinned lacquer sealer is used, then wax. On dense exotic woods, just wax.

Ray does like the black wet/dry paper, I use Norton 3X since I have it already and really like it as well.

Though I've never met him personally, Ray is a great guy and easily corresponds back and forth through email. If he doesn't like something about a product, he'll tell ya.

I'm very proud to have a Ray Key box in my collection.

Any other questions, please ask.

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#3

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca

Galen,

As is often the case, there are variables which render your questions difficult to satisfy. In this case, (wax-sanding boxes, the big variable might be whether this is a "one-off" piece or a run of production pieces aimed at a lower end market.

If you do not demand a durable and deep finish, the wax-as-a-finish may be just what you want. Any paste wax will likely work, with Briwax or Trewax being a favorite among turners. You can use a bit of 0000 steel wool with your wax as a starting point if the surface of the wood is adequately prepared for it. Use the same wax applied with soft lint-free cloth to top it up, finally polishing out with clean towelling.

If your project is a 'one-off' destined for the love of your life, or for gallery/museum, I would NEVER EVER wet sand a project with wax, water, oil, or finish of any sort, UNLESS IT HAS BEEN THOROUGHLY SEALED FIRST. Many turners on this foum disagree, but if your intention is to maximize the grain contrasts and colors, don't fill open grain or pores with a slurry colored slurry.

Try the wax/wet sanding method and see if you like the results. If not, remove it with mineral spirits, and try something else...learning is half the fun!

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Mike Stafford

I "wax" sand all my exotic hardwood boxes such as cocobolo, Santos rosewood, tulipwood, kingwood etc. using Johnson's paste wax and Klingspor gold. I clean the wood between grits using a mineral spirits dampened piece of paper towel followed by a dry towel to friction polish the MS dry. I go through all the grits and move up to around 1200 or until I can no longer see scratches with a raking bright light. I give the wood a final MS cleaning and let it dry for at least 24 hours before applying a final coat of wax for the finish which I apply with 6/0 steel wool, paper towels and a soft lint free cloth. I sometimes repeat this step as many as three times.

Final top coat is some microcrystalline wax to bring up the shine a bit.

The other benefit is that the toxic dust from these exotics does not permeate the air and is contained in the wax residue.

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#5

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Russ Fairfield

The devil is in the thinner that is used for the finish and whether the wax is soluble in that thinner. That means making sure the thinners that are in the wax have totally evaporated and there is nothing on the wood other than the pure wax before applying the finish. The thinners in the wax and the finish may not be compatible, and most paste waxes contain some water which isn't compatible with anything. Trying to do this with a waterborne finish creates a mess because waxes are water-resistant.

The residual wax in the wood then goes into solution with whatever thinner is used for the finish, and thereby becomes a part of the finish. Using an oil finish as an example, the polymerized oil with have little islands of wax throughout, and they will make the finish softer than it would have been without them. How soft depends on how much wax was used and the hardness of the wax. This wax in the finish can be a good thing because it adds plasticity to the finish and can keep it from becoming brittle with age.

I use wax for the final sanding under lacquers, and have never had a problem as long as I wait long enough for all of the solvents in the wax to evaporate before starting to aspply the lacquer. If I am spraying the lacquer, the first primer coat is a brush on/wipe off application that cleans off any wax residuals, and seals the wood surface. After that, spraying is not a problem.

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#6

Ken Vaughan

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Ken Vaughan

An alternative to wax as a lubricant is oil. Tried and True polymerized linseed oil or the gun stock finish Tru Oil are the ones I use. (I do not use boiled linseed oil irreversable changes it causes especially change in color to dark muddy over long period of time and the issues handling of oil cloths).

Key from my perspective is the design decisions for the finish should be well formulated and the tradeoffs in outcome made before you start the sanding/finish process. Several finishing outcomes do not support wax or oil sanding very successfully.

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#7

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Galen Vetterick

Thanks all for your replies.

WoodCentral members have been a great help in my learning to turn AND finishing.

Greg: Thanks for identifying the waxes used by Ray. I failed to note he does seem to use a friction polish/lacquer between the wax sandings and final wax.

Mike S: I was surprised Ray did not seem to clean the piece between grits as you noted in your method. He only went to about 600 grit and 4/0 steel wool. Your posted box pictures look like a great finish!

Mike J: I currently have tried several finishes on boxes. Piece quality? Lucky if I can get relatives to take and not hide! ;>)

Russ: Still learning what is good compatible prep and finishes. When I put Mylands on a piece that method yielded smear. I sprayed lacquer over and it leveled everything out!

Ken: Yes I have sanded a walnut piece with oil and got a good finish.

Thanks again all.

Galen

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Mike Stafford

Galen, in Mr. Key's videos he is turning Masur birch which is a much softer wood than the exotics I was describing. He may stop at 400 grit paper but he uses 4/0 steel wool which is also an abrasive and results in a very random scratch pattern when compared to sand paper which has grits of varying sizes which result in non-uniform scratch patterns. Masur birch does not have to be sanded to as fine a grit as cocobolo, tulipwood, kingwood, et al and the steel wool removes/randomizes the scratch pattern so that it is non visible. The finer hard grain of the exotics can show scratches visible to the eye if you stop at 400. You might be able to stop at 600 but usually you can still see the scratch patterns in good light. This is particularly true of the circular scratches which show up in the bottom and lid undersides in boxes.

I like cleaning out the sludge between grits. I feel it results in a better finish. If a grain of a coarser paper is removed from the backing during sanding and is left in the sludge will it not continue to scratch the surface? I have always felt that it was a good idea to remove the sanding dust when dry sanding or sludge when wax sanding between grits.

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#9

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Galen Vetterick

Mike

Thanks for the additional information on differences in finish method on wood types. On pens and bottle stoppers I did go to finer grits on exotics.

I added a Beall buffing system and that has helped on the small bowls and hollow forms I have made since.

You noted that you use 6/0 steel wool and all I have ever seen is 4/0 as the super fine. Where do you find it and or could it be in one of the pad equivalents?

Galen

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Sanding boxes with wax questions.

Mike Stafford

Wal-Mart used to carry 9x11 sheets of braided steel wool in 3 grades 0, 4/0 and 6/0. They also carried peel and stick pads in the same grades for random orbit sanders. I tried this product out and loved it for my flat woodworking when rubbing out a finish.

I am a hoarder so I bought lots of this product and then I bought all I could find when Wal-Mart put it on close-out.

I have my own personal supply and I don't know what I will do when it is gone. It is a wonderful material for rubbing out a finish on the lathe as well.

To my knowledge it is no longer available. I continue to look for another source of it.