Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Better not to use any wax?

Posts

Better not to use any wax?

#1

Better not to use any wax?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

We all know that the third step in the Beal buffing system is to buff on a hard wax. But in a recent demonstration at our club by David Ellsworth, he warned against wax, saying that wax absorbs moisture and will eventually attract enough of it to dull the finish. He should know. So what's up here?

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#2

Don Pencil

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Don Pencil

Yes he should know better. I wonder what went wrong?

Don

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#3

JL

I don't believe it will attract moisture..

JL

Most waxes by their nature are hydrophobic. They are water repellent.

They will however attract dirt. I believe dirt and dust will definitely dull a finish.

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#4

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Bill Howatt

Like I mentioned in another thread, I have pretty much abandoned the carnuba wax step in the Beall system. I find it feels great and looks nice at first but over time it dulls for whatever reason.

Bill

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#5

Ken Vaughan

Suspect a mix of myth and truth is involved

Ken Vaughan

There are a lot of different waxes and formulations. Bees wax is likely one of the guilty parties with moisture and is used in a lot of wax and some finish foumulations.

Waxes as most organic products are subject to oxidation and change over time and will slowly dull. So will most other finishes at different rates of change. Oxone is one really active change agent.

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#6

Don Pencil

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Don Pencil

The beauty of a pure hard wax like carnauba is that it can be renewed at will.

The most "bullit proof" finish I know of is linear polyurethane. It will last for many years in the harsh environment of the sea. A little soap and water and it looks like new. No need for waxing it. But even that finish will deteriorate over time. All other finishes will dull and discolor much sooner.

Once a clear finish has dulled and discolored, remove it and go again.

Polishing your shoes is more trouble than freshing up a wood surface that has been buffed with pure carnauba.

Don

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#7

Re: Better not to use any wax?  *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

I think David got it right that wax is not the most durable of finishes, but he got it totally wrong when he says it is the moisture and humidity that does it. Wax is the most water-resistant thing we can put on a piece of wood. Don't believe me, look at the new wax you put on your automobile and how the water beads up on the surface. Depending on the brand, that is a Carnauba or Montan wax. Thes same waxes will last for a year or more when inside, and how long depends on the atmosphere around it.

The damage is done by the airborne chemicals, mold spores, dust particles, and general pollutants. The moisture only acts as the catalyst. These same things will destroy any wood finish, and the only difference is how laong it takes. That is why we use wax as a sacrificial finish to protect other finishes.

Wax by itself is an excellent finish for a piece of wood when it is done right and sparingly. It is true that it doesn't last as long as other finishes, but it is also the easiest and fastest of all wood finishes to renew. Tell me of another that can be wiped on and buffed in about 15 minutes and is then good for another year.

Everything I know about wax as a finish is on my website at the following address


http://www.woodturner-russ.com/Wax/Index.html

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#8

Re: Suspect a mix of myth and truth is involved

Russ Fairfield

Ken,

Yes, organic waxes do degrade over time and exposure to oxygen and ozone, and that is why the mineral waxes such as Microcrystalline and Montan are more durable.

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Keith Tompkins

Personally, I don't consider wax a finish. It may be considered a protective coating over a finish; but as a final finish it's a poor choice. producing a good finish can take up to as long as the piece took to turn and sand, maybe even more. With a good finish beneath, the surface can be waxed and polished with a soft rag, no buffing required.

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#10

Don Pencil

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Don Pencil

Keith,

"With a good finish beneath, the surface can be waxed and polished with a soft rag, no buffing required."

What are these good finishes?

Don

Re: Better not to use any wax?

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Better not to use any wax?

Keith Tompkins

HI Don, I think something that qualifies as a good finish is one that's durable and attractive. Depending on the appearance I want, I use several. For high gloss, lacquer is my choice. Very durable, easily repairable, and really makes the wood pop. Not easy create professional results; I spray many coats, finally wet-sanding between coats with 2500 grit, then buffing by hand with auto compounds. The finish is only as good as the surface prep...over time, sanding marks will telegraph through the finish, and every defect shows. Expect to spend more time on the finish than the turning took to create. I also like tung oil mixed with polyurethane or spar varnish..I've been using this since the 70's, flat work I've finished that way still looks great, and hasn't darkened after 30 some years. No shortcuts here...this takes time to build up a finish, but the results are flawless. Again, it's easy to rejuvinate the finish, just scuff and apply a new coat, wipe dry. I've used shellac based finishes such as french polish previously, but don't find it durable enough for my liking..not water resistant enough, and not easy to get superior results for the average turner. If a piece will be handled, shellac is not my choice. Some new finishes used by the auto industry are great, but too hazardous healthwise to consider for home use. Bill Bush from my area in NY has a proprietary finish I have used, and like; time consuming, but the results are excellent. I really don't think there's a quick AND durable finish out there.