Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Posts

How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#1

How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Paul Zerjay

I don't notice any significant difference skipping it.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#2

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Ed Moore in SW VA

I skip it, but often I use Don Pencil's PL instead of white diamond. I really like the results I get with PL.

Ed

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

I had wondered about the necessity of the White Diamond, but I am getting such beautiful finishes on my Blackthorn Napkin Rings that I think I shall continue.

Regards, Peter.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#4

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Greg Haugen

I skip it some times, and some times it's the only buff I use. It all depends on what wood and effect I'm intending to get. To clarify something, I don't apply wax on a buff. I don't even have a block of wax in the shop. I don't have a "catalog" buffing system, I have some wheels from the hardware store, one for tripoli and one for white diamond, and some tripoli and white diamond. If I want more of a satin, down to the wood finish, I'll use tripoli. If I want a "buffed" finish, with some more sheen, I'll use white diamond. Almost everything I make is sanded to the 1000-1200 grit range and then the surface intended will dictate what compound I use, if any. Keep in mind, dark or extremely light colored species and if the finish will allow the compound to pack the pores. White diamond in walnut is not any better than tripoli in ash, for example.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#5

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Bill Howatt

I generally feel that white diamond does make a difference but if there might be a color problem with open pore woods I might skip it like I might skip tripoli. The one component of the Beall system I often leave out is the carnuba wax. Nice appearance at first but not so great down the road.

Bill

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#6

Don Pencil

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Don Pencil

Paul,

If you begin buffing after 320 or 400 grit you should see improvement with the tripoli and more after the white diamond. It will depend a little on the wood being buffed.

Also if you have filled in the pores of the grain with sand and seal or with multiple coats of antique oil finish you may get less distinction between the compounds.

If the wood is open pore as Greg and others have noted, do not use the tripoli on light color woods and do not use the white diamond on darker woods.

Ed is right on the "PL" being a finer finish that the white diamond. The tripoli is the most aggressive. On most woods I would not think there would be much of an advantage to using the "PL" as a third stage, the exception being woods that are very tight and hard grained. A wood like that will benefit some from the "PL" compound and wheel.

The carnauba wax can be argued pro/con when compared to other wax finishes on bare wood. End use and personal preference will have something to do with that. Wax applied after another finish has been applied may also have something to do with the afore mentioned preferences.

After pure carnauba wax has been applied, it does offer one lasting benefit. The owner of the object has only to use a natural paste wax in the future to bring it back to its original beauty.

I am not sure how other waxes are to maintain years down the road but I am sure others here can speak to that.

Also you can rebuff the object repeatedly in the future without harming the finish. I have taken turned bowls to demo after demo for display and then rebuffed them before the next showing and found that each time the finish got even better. One coat of the wax cures harder over time and the next coat just adds to it. With a rub on/ rub off wax you may soften and remove the prior coat. Not sure though that it would be true of all of them.

It is true that one should not display near water. Carnauba wax will spot.

Personally I hope that my sold art work is not on display in the bath or kitchen.

I certainly advise my customers not to.

Be Well,

Don

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#7

Mike Stafford

Try dry buffing....you'll like it.

Mike Stafford

I skip it all the time. I have had more bad experiences with it getting in pores and the results with it are no better than when I dry buff with the wheel intended for use with the compound.

I am always amazed at how much difference dry buffing with the soft flannel wheel makes. You can see the transformation as you buff.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#8

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

fgvanatta

It's supposed to clean off the Tripoli; I never skip it.

Frank

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#9

With Walnut Only

Barbara Gill

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#10

Re: With Walnut Only

john lucas

I'm with Barbara. If it's a dark wood with open pores I avoid the white diamond. Other than that I use them.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#11

I skip it just about all the time

jake Niedling

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#12

Can I have your bar of white.   

john lucas

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#13

Re: With Walnut Only

Bernie Weishapl

I only skip it on walnut or a open pore dark wood.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#14

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Greg in Oshkosh

I rarely skip the white diamond but I am careful not to load up the buff or you'll get spots on dark wood. Since the white material is really calcium carbonate nothing will really take it off once it's in a pore. I suppose you could try to soak the piece in acid but I wouldn't recommend it.

I have a big problem with the wax application. After only casual handling I can see fingerprints in the wax. Am I getting too much on or is it just this wax? I can use wax for buffing cars and that seems to work just fine. I can't put up with the look of the carnuba wax on any piece that get handled alot.

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

#15

Don Pencil

Re: How many of you skip White Diamond altogether

Don Pencil

Greg,

Like most things I imagine there will be a trade off regardless of the finish used.

Discoloration (yellowing over time), finger prints, oils collect more dust and other air contaminates.

If the piece is on display to be handled a great deal at a show or demo, then the only way to solve this with carnauba wax is to keep a buffing cloth around and lightly wipe it off occasionally.

If it is a gallery quality piece that is not to be handled, then no problem.

Each finish will have issues depending upon the short or long term application.

The trick I believe is to figure out which one works best for each. I have never heard of one that will do it all.

Be Well,

Don