Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Coring

Posts

Coring

#1

Coring

Jorge Casta�eda

Hello there,

I've been serious about roughing bowls, and this is the method I am using:

As you see I have the tail stock snug, these are quite big, 16" - 18" blanks and I rather don't see them unmounted in case of a catch. With the TS in there, I have to start the cut with my hands as there is no room for the handle, after a little while I can use the handle and towards the end, have to remove it so as to push the blade in as far as possible and still does not go far enough, so have to pry a little with the cutter and brake the core.

The core stays in there too, it does not fall, so I am happy with this system, obviously I need bigger knives. The thing I would like to improve is: The rough bowls are way too thick, 1 1/4" at the rim, but then they get thicker in a hurry, so, how to get, lets say an even inch? right now is more than 2 in th ewidest spot.

Thanks for comments and suggestions

Jorge

Re: Coring

#2

Re: Coring

fgvanatta

If the bowls are getting thicker as you progress you either need to get a larger (radius) set of knives or widen the gap as you near the bottom - either by "fishtailing" the cutter or repositioning the tool mount slightly inboard to change the effective radius of the cut. If possible, I would suggest practicing either of the last two options on a less desirable piece of wood to make sure you are getting the radius you want and aren't inadvertently creating a funnel. A laser guide (easily made) helps considerably.

Re: Coring

#3

Ken Vaughan

Re: Coring with Mcnaughton

ken Vaughan

I am a coring newbie -- and "invested" in one of Randy's laser pointers.

http://monster-lathe-tools.com/cart.php?target=category&category_id=67

There is alwasy another tool. Randy sells a clamp that fits onto the McNaughton handle nicely. The laser does help me know where the tip is at and that keeps me better aligned.

The laser may be a crutch, but I find it a good one as I work my way through the learning curve. Knowing where the tip is at lets me be more predicticable and my eye is certainly not yet tuned to good estimates.

Re: Coring

#4

Re: Coring

robo hippy

Mike Mahoney cuts his handles in half. This would give you a bit better access when coring with the tailstock in place. If you are using the flatter blades, the tailstock isn't in the way. If you are using the more curved blades, then the tailstock is in the way no matter what you do.

As to aiming, you will get better with more practice. The laser does help you to know when your aim is off. I will hold the blade I am coring with up against the outside of the bowl I am coring, and over the top of it in the position I want it to end up in when I core. These 2 visual references help me a lot. Most of the time when you core, you will have a thinner rim, and be a lot thicker around the transition area of the bowl. A lot depends on bowl shape and blade choice. I use the standard, or medium curve blade for almost all of the coring that I do.

robo hippy

Re: Coring

#5

Re: Coring

Jorge Casta�eda

fgvanatta,

Thanks for the suggestions, yes I need a different radius, I am using th emiddle blade because it matches the outside of the bowls, but it seems that it drifts in, so I en with very thick bottoms iand walln the largest bowl

I will try repositioning, something I have not tried

Thank you

Jorge

Re: Coring

#6

Re: Coring with Mcnaughton

Jorge Casta�eda

Ken,

I was not aware of the existence of the adapters, good ide, I'll give Randy a call

Thank you.

Jorge

Alaska, wow...

Re: Coring

#7

Re: Coring

Jorge Casta�eda

Reed,

I am using the middle blade too, most of the time, the one with the largest diameter, drifts out wicked, and the other two drift in. I am playing with the idea of bending the straight blade, that I never use to a radius between the largest and the middle.

Yes I need to practice a lot more

Thank you

Jorge

Re: Coring

#8

Re: Coring

Barry Irby

Jorge,

I would suggest you buy Reed's video and watch it a few times.

and Mike Mahoney's.

I don't have a laser on mine. I don't wave 5% the experience Reed and Mike do, but here is what I do.

I have a piece of clear plexiglass About 14 by 6". It has a center line drawn on it the short way. (making two 7 X 6" rectangles.

After I cut the outside of my blank, I take it out of the chuck and clamp the piece of plastic in the chuck so that the is centered in the chuck. Then, with a dry erase marker I draw the profile of the bowl on the plastic. I put the tool post for the McNaughton system of the Banjo and slide the knife through the gate. The knife will slide right under the piece of plastic and you can watch its path. I twist the post so that the third post on it rubs against the blade and serves as a guide. If you lock the post in that position, the knife will follow that path. Then put the blank back in and make the cut. On more thing, You can put a line perpendicular to the centerline whatever distance out from the chuck you want bottom thickness to be.

Re: Coring

#9

Re: Coring

robo hippy

Jorge,

Chances are that the small curved blade isn't bent properly, and is out of whack. I can't remember what the radius is supposed, but I had one that did that as well, and it was a bad bend. I have one of the clear plastic templates from Craft supplies, but haven't unpacked it yet. I will be checking all my blades and fine tuning them eventually. Minor tweaking of the blades should be no problem, but to bend the straight one, you should heat it and bend it. For me, that means a trade with a black smith friend as I don't really know anything about metal other than grinding it. Bending one that much though could cause fractures in the blade so it might break as you are bending it, or worse, as you are coring.

robo hippy

Re: Coring

#10

Re: Coring

Jorge Casta�eda

Barry,

I do have both dvds but I am deaf, on both ears, so words go by me, only what I can see.

I have some clear plastic, I will try your system, I need both more experience, and as Reed points out, maybe my cutters have bad bends.

Gracias!

Re: Coring

#11

Re: Coring

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Reed,

I am going to start my day making a circle template with some clear acrylic I have, (storm window replacement from the hardware store), then I can check the curvatures and tweak accordingly, I think you are right.

And you are also right about bending the straight blade, I had metal work experience in the trades school, over half a century ago, so is long gone, but have a friend who is a wizard as a last resort.

Thank you

Re: Coring

#12

Re: Coring

Barry Irby

Jorge, When my knives came they were poorly bent. This has come up over and over here, but I insist they must be a segment of a circle.

Take a big piece of paper and draw some concentric circles on it on about half inch increments. Lay your knives on the pattern and see if the blades will line up and run between the lines. Mine were more like ovals. I had a friend help me re-bend mine to fit the circles. It was a huge improvement. They should sit on a flat surface and ft the circles. The were not nearly as hard to bend as I thought they would be.

If the knives are not cutting a circle you must "Fishtail" to cut out a path big enough to let the knife enter. That strikes me as undesirable. If you could cut a 3/8" kerf if everything were working perfectly, but you must cut a 3/4" kerf to get the knife into the wood, you just ground away about the equivalent of a bowl. We do the coring to save the wood, not to grind it up with a curved knife.

Try the thing with the plexiglass and it will help you visualize where the knife it.

Re: Coring

#13

Right you are!

Jorge Casta�eda

Reed, Barry,

not a single blade was a fair curve, all of them had kinks, as I don't have a metal vise, I dropped 'em at my friend the metal head and they will be ready by wed.

So, time to grind my teeth and do taxes... >(

Thank you guys