OK I know I can't build a better tool than I can buy, but I love doing it anyway. I'll spend half a day working on a measuring tool that I could have bought for $24. Why? I'm not sure. Part of it is the money, I don't have much to throw around. Most of it is I just like making things. I do learn new skills, especially metal working skills. Those have helped me make custom tools that you can't buy.
How many other out there will "waste" an afternoon making a tool they could have bought.
As a person with a strong background in engineering, I like to dissect things into their core design challenges, and then determine if it is worth a build vs. buy decision. If you look in the turning catalogs, there are all kinds of, well, just plain stupid devices aimed at removing hard earned money from your wallet.
I am not suggesting that these devices do not have any value. I just can't picture anyone with enough creativity to stand a lathe not being able to make one.
My quick list of favorites:
A center finder.
A point tool.
An Ellsworth style hollower.
(believe me, the list goes on and on...)
I am far from a machinist. In fact, I am notorious for "just doing things" without any planning really at all. The thought that some of these things are somehow better because someone else drilled a 100% accurate hole vs. my 95% hole is maddening. If you can look at something and know EXACTLY what it is (a metal rod with a hole in it or a point...), how could you not make it?
I will spend a day, a week, a lifetime "wasting" my days to make things that I use, and buying the things that I cannot...
Don I have a Smithy Lathe/mill that I'm learning to use. I've only had it about a year and have had to do a lot of fixing and tune up. That's good because if forced me to learn about metal lathe tolerances. it's still not there as far as serious accuracy but has allowed me to play.
All of my early tools were made by hand with hacksaw and files. I'm reallly good with a file coming from a camera repair background. I also now have a small forge. Many of my curved tools are made with a Mapp gas torch because I don't often have the time to haul the Forge outside and fire it up. I some day hope to have a place to leave it set up so could try making new tools at a moments notice. I'm still a learning blacksmith as well and a long way from knowing what I'm doing but it sure is fun pounding out steel.
Over the years I have personally created a great deal of "scrap" from the protos in getting to what really worked. The time certainly is not a waste if you have the tools, time, and skill to fuss with them.
Forgot to answer what I've made. A little of everything. I've made bowl gouges, a whole set of hollowing tools from 1/4" shafts to 3/4" shafts. Several tools using the Hunter and C1 style carbide cutters. Lots and lots of tool handles. A bunch of skews in all sizes and several scrapers. Hook tools and ring tools.
Several different thickness gauges, faceplates by the dozen, Several different pin chucks, 3 or 4 different captured bar systems.
I'm currently building thread chasers and built a small lathe that uses the router for a headstock to use my Baxter threader. I've built coring tools for the McNaughton system and along with that a custom made bending jig to let me bend stock up to 1/2" without having to heat it, and thicker stock if I do heat it.
I've built a spring pole lathe that I'm converting to a treadle lathe.
Gosh there's so many things over the years I'd have to go through my drawers just to remember what all I've built.
building accessories is as much a hobby as the turning.
I'm with you, John... for the same reasons. Besides the many turning tools I've made, there are two compasses, sharpening station from a belt sander, three different bowl thickness gauges, depth gauges, chucks galore, and bowl and spindle steadies.
Making them is satisfying, and fun... and I'm into fun...
I've made a couple of hollowing tools, one of which I really love! 3 feet of straight boring bar love! I guess it is kind of like a oland tool. I had a welder friend build my favourite toolrest (I have no welding equipment of knowledge).
I'm currently building a burner/vaporizer. I've messed up something and need a volt meter to find where the error is.
Tools and tool parts! I'll spend a couple hours making a shovel handle rather than buy one. I love to make gauges, jigs, and fixtures. And I used to make electronic and computer "tools" all the time - both hard and soft.
I think making things to make other things is half the fun. Probably deeply ingrained since we, the human species, are unquestionably tool-makers. There are some pretty prolific members of the species here on WC - I love to read the many tool-making messages.
those of us who would rather spend the time building the tool than just buying it not only gain a better understanding of the tool and how it is made. but we may also come up with a modification or method that makes the tool work better.
don pencil, doug thompson and many others may have not been the creators of the types of tools they sell, but they through there testing and prototypes have given us products that we would gladly buy.
so keep building tools and if you do come up with something great, patent and market it and then retire......maybe not the last part. lol
If we just wanted a wood bowl we could all go to Walmart and get plenty for $10.
Whether it is tools, shop fixtures, jigs, or wood bowls I think there is a certain satisfaction of having a challenge and bringing forth the self reliance and ingenuity to be able to solve the problem myself. agree, I would rather spend half a day to make something that would cost little than buy it. It is the feeling of satisfaction & acomplishment to know I MADE IT.
Count me in. I love to build things for all the reasons (fun, self satifaction, save money, etc.) mentioned here. Some examples: sarpening jugs, Ellworth hollowing tools, wooden thread tapped face plates, remote start/stop lathe, templates to turn spheres. Steve I can not wait to build your hollowing system.
I really enjoy making turning (and other) tools, and don't consider it a waste of time at all (.....and in some cases, it results in a significant savings of money!). Over the past year, our turners group has made group purchases of round carbide cutters and square carbide cutters to make our own clones of the commercially available Hunter Tool and the Easy Rougher tool for a fraction of the cost. We also made boring bars as a group in an assembly-line fashion at two of our turners group meetings. I recently bought a 2.5" diameter rod of UHMW plastic and made a set of different live center adapters of different shapes that thread onto the Oneway live center (from the American Woodturner article a few issues back). I've made my own laser guide for the John Jordan hollowing tools, and have adapted a pneumatic foot switch and flex-arm coolant sprayer for use while hollowing --- just step on the "air-switch" and compressed air is blasted into the opening of the vessel without moving a hand or putting down the tool. This really cuts down on hollowing time.
I also went through a brief period of making several different sized tool handles out of 1" diameter 6061 aluminum rods, a few set screws, and rubberized foam bicycle handlebar covers. Excellent functionality for MUCH less than buying "name" tool handles.
My latest tool-making playtime was to put together a drawbar and 'micro-blank' mounting system centered around using MT-2 collets for mounting and holding very small turnings. Using readily available hardware (various cut-off bolts, masonry screws, epoxy, and glue blocks) from the local store and from MSC, I was able to put this completely functional system together for less than 1/3 the cost of one bought "off the shelf". If I can find the time, I might try to write this one up for one of the turning magazines (Woodturning Design?) if I can convince myself there might be enough interest from other turners.
I think part of the fun of doing this is the satisfaction of being creative in trying to make the tool to resolve a particular problem, refine a technique, or just build a better mousetrap. Or perhaps it's just being "cheap", and wanting to add a particular capability to one's techniques, add to the diversity of the arsenal of one's tools, or simply to add the functionality of the new tool without spending more than necessary.
This adds another personal dimension to one's woodturning by using tools that you made yourself. Not quite a warm fuzzy feeling, but close.
Well actually, it is exactly the opposite. It is a sled & jig for cutting segments that shows mechanically where to set it to produce a cetain diameter ring. It eliminates all that math stuff which I'm not smart enough to figure out anyway
( sine co-sine, tangent ) ( I have to ask my 16 year old daughter for help with that )
Hi John, I make all kinds of tools. I've got strange measuring gauges everywhere...I have one that measures bottom thickness while any turning is on the lathe...comes in handy for some wierd stuff I turn. I've made special tools for auto work...VW patented one of my tools for aligning the front end on their Dasher/Fox models, and supplied it to all their dealers. I can weld and braze well, and learned metal working in school and in the machine shop of the furniture factory where I worked...I had a free hand to make anything I wanted there. I made boring jigs that connected to pnuematic drills for drilling chair seats; the jigs bored all holes at once with a high degree of accuracy. Previously, many holes were drilled with crude jigs or by eye. That was a great job...I had no boss except the company's president. Currently, I might have a solution to the mandatory face mask dilema.... that I'm welding up.