Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

No Money, Problem (Take Three)

Posts

No Money, Problem (Take Three)

#1

Don Pencil

No Money, Problem (Take Three)

Don Pencil

Sometimes one must just go with the realities of life.

The facts are:

Want to fly higher and faster? More money.

Want to live higher up the hill in a bigger and better house? More money.

Say you want to turn bigger and better bowls faster and easier? More money.

Very few of the "personally" made tools, rigs, or jigs will work as well as those designed, tested, and manufactured, by the woodturning tool companies.

There are a few exceptions.

Only a very, very few woodturners have the metal working machinery, tools, skill, and experience to do the job. Many of these tools have bends and curves that are hard to make. One must then test the tool for correct angles, hights, lengths, widths, and thicknesses. That is done by sticking it in a piece of wood. This can really be a thrill. Get it wrong and as noted in past comments on the forum the device can really hurt your feelings. At this point, assuming you still have all of your parts and courage, you need to make another one or rebend, grind, adjust that one until it is right. You're doing all of this while you could have been turning something nice.

The best overall rule for safety is: if you can't afford the right tool for the job, them stay with what you can afford until you have the money.

Don

Re: No Money, Problem (Take Three)

#2

Re: No Money, Problem (Take Three)

Dick Coers

Sorry, don't agree with you at all Don. If we were only supposed to buy from suppliers, new design tools may never show up. Of course, I don't know you, so maybe you with speaking satiriaclly. I think you do sell some tools, so were you just kidding? It's almost April 1.

Re: No Money, Problem (Take Three)

#3

Re: No Money, Problem (Take Three) *LINK*

charlie belden

The truth probably lies somewhere between the two - and has to do with scale and mass.

Sure, for hollowing small christmas ornamnets and little stuff an allen wrench modified and ground to make a hollowing tool may make sense. Scale that hollow form up to say 10" in diameter and 10" or more tall - and THAT's a different story.

Let's take Steve's shop made hollowing set up. Ideally, you want the boring bar to be horizontal and paralleling the centerline "between centers". But you want ITs cutting edge to be AT the "between centers" centerline. Have the cutting edge much above that centerline and you've set yourself up for a catch that feeds itself. Have the cutting edge much below that centerline and it may not cut. Now what? Lower the platform? Get a thicker piece of oak and drill a hole a little higher or lower? Why not just raise the tool rest? Well think about that one a bit.

Then there's THE LASER thing. Hollowing systems make controlling the cut easier - to cut right through the sides or bottom. (OK, so I'm the ONLY one who has done THAT).

Then there's the Where Do You Put It When Not In Use thing. I'm sure I'm the only one who has a shop with stuff crammed into every nook and cranny - and covering every above the floor horizontal surface - layers deep. Think of the space needed to store most of the hollowing systems, captured or not. Then have a look at how much space and where I keep the MiniMonster when not in use. BTW - that's a little JET mini/midi in the photos.


Where're You Gonna Keep It?

Re: No Money, Problem (Take Three)

#4

Steven Antonucci

FYI- my cutter is always on centerline

Steven Antonucci

Just to be perfectly clear, Charlie, the platform I show is completely fixed. It does not move up or down at all.

So how do you accomodate bars with different diameters, you might ask?

Easily. I keep it very simple.

When I was trying to figure out how to do this, the answer was to use the lathe to drill the hole that holds the bar. I placed the platform on the ways, clamped a straight edge parallel to the drill bit, and fed the oak board into the drill in the headstock. I know that it is parallel to the ways, and thus my bar will insert parallel to the oak.

It sometimes is more a matter of figuring out how to do something more than having the millions of tools available. At the full length of the extension, my cutter still is within 1mm of centerline 24" from the center point of my spur center. Machinist tolerances are not relevant at that distance, since the tool will flex more than that, and so will the wood you are cutting.

Just remember that the forefathers in turning all had no choice but to do this- since there weren't catalogs full of stuff you don't need...

Steve