Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

No Money No Problem!!!

Posts

No Money No Problem!!!

#1

Lyle Jamieson

No Money No Problem!!!

Lyle Jamieson

With all due respect to Steve I have some big problems with the platform system he is so quick to share with everyone. Every word Steve has said about his home built boring system was absolutely true. But here is the BUT, It is not safe. In my opinion it needs to be captured. We work with an unpredictable material, it grows on trees. There could be a hidden flaw or fault in the wood. Many people use junk, punky, cracked wood that you can not predict if and when it will come apart. If the forces on the cutter are pushing down the handle has to have equal or more forces down to prevent the handle board from coming up and slapping you in the head or worse. Maybe Steve has the strength to hold the handle down but not all turners are young strong hunks. Even a strong MAN would have a hard time holding down on the handle while reaching way out over the platform to undercut a shoulder through a small mouth opening. True the forces with small boring bars and small vessels is minimal. But I didnt hear any disclaimer that said "dont do this at home on bigger(Where do you draw the line??) pieces" People will push the envelop and exceed its limitations. The mass and inertia of big heavy wood spinning around on a stronger lathe will not just stop in a heartbeat when something goes wrong. I would never turn without a top safety bar capturing the handle, any more then I would ride that wooden motorcycle. It would likely drive down the road just fine, but what if I hit a pothole or somebody pulls out in front of me on the bike. There is a simple and necessary fix. Put another strap of wood or any material, pipe, angle iron, 3/4 plywood on edge...anything to stop the handle from violently coming at you. Leave a gap so there is no binding in use. It still fits Steves criteria of cheap and quick to make.

Another safety issue is to grind a flat spot on the boring bar where the holding bolt secures it to the handle. With the bold tightened down on a flat spot the bar can not twist in use. You dont want the torque forces twisting the boring bar in its socket while it is in use inside a vessel. The cutter needs to be securely held parallel to the floor to prevent catches.

I have helped hundreds of students make their own boring systems out of almost any imaginable products, and I applaud Steves ingenuity here. Its a great idea, but lets fine tune it a bit and keep it safe for everyone less experienced then us. Lyle Jamieson

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#2

Steven Antonucci

More Physics

Steven Antonucci

So we all know about Archimedes, who said, "Give me a lever long enough and I could life the world" (or similar to that).

So here's what that means, without a lot of technical sciencey babble:

If I have a bar that is 8" over the rest , I probably have 24" of wood and bar on the other side of the rest. If you've ever used a jack to lift a car up, you know that you can jack up a car with very little effort, but you have to move the handle quite a bit to get an inch of lift. You trade distance for lifting power.

What this rig does is the exact opposite of a car jack. It trades lifting power for distance. A force at the short end is negated al the long end via the distance of the lever. With a long enough and heavy enough mass on the other side of the cutting tip, it resists the desire to lift at all. Plus, you have to put your arm somewhere to use the silly thing, so I just as soon add the mass of my arm to the effort. There is no requirement for it to be captured if your wood block is long enough and heavy enough. I would not use balsa for this, and I typically want 3x behind the toolrest, but have hand hollowed for years with 2x or less.

If I was going to be making exceptionally deep (>15") vessels, I'd probably put a bar over it because I'd need to stand so far away anyhow and I wouldn't be worried about it being in the way.

Nothing dangerous about the rig at all, Lyle. Build one and you'll see. It was designed with physics in mind, and albeit an unsophisticated looking contraption, it's got a top flight engineering school pedigree.

Steven

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#3

An Idiot chimes in......

Barry Irby

I (the Idiot) have one of Lyle's captive systems and have only used it a few times. I took a week long class from David Ellsworth at Arrowmont. The first thing we did was to make our own set of tools. The people at Arrowmont were foolish enough to leave ME unattended. I couldnt wait to try this hollowing stuff and so I tried it with David's personal tools the first night. I did not realize how much time you needed to spend cleaning the thing out and I managed to get it jambed full of shavings and may have gotten a catch. It was a powerful lathe and it grabbed that tool with a vengeance. I held on like a teenage boy holding on to the first girl who ever took her clothes off for him. The cutter snapped off and I managed to extract the bar. The next morning I had to confess to David that I broke it. He took it well, turned it into a teachable moment, and showed us how to change the cutter.

My point is, Its hard to make things idiot proof.

I like Steve's rig and it would work really well until things went really badly. I would suggest a capture bar and perhaps a long handle of the top of the bar.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#4

Steven Antonucci

No substitute for proper technique

Steven Antonucci

Captured, supported or freehand- don't think of any of them as a cure all for bad technique. Knowing how often to clear the shavings, what a bad piece of wood looks like, and how to use whatever equipment we are using safely and properly matters more than whose name is on it.

I also want to be clear that I would not recommend this for very large vessels because it is not scaled for that kind of work. If someone was interested in what a big hollowing rig looks like, check out this video:

object width="425" height="344">

Notice that the speed of the lathe is proportional to the sizeof the block being turned...

Steve

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#5

Speed of lathe...

John K Jordan

>...Notice that the speed of the lathe is proportional to the sizeof the block being turned...

I suspect you mean "inversely proportional", where a large block is turned with a slower speed.

JKJ

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#6

Re: No substitute for proper technique

Barry Irby

My concern is that on this forum we have Turners of all skill levels, ranging from none to people with consummate skills and huge experience. I personally would probably make a device like yours and use it for small projects and probably wouldn't get into too much trouble. Its just that we can't count on the next person to assess the quality of the wood, the heaviness of the cut, the speed of the lathe etc etc and keep themselves safe. You have to right every time and wrong only once. Come to think of it, I have been wrong many times.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#7

no-risk woodturning

John K Jordan

The issue of keeping things safe for the lowest common denominator came up here at least once before. Some took issue with discussing how the fingers can be used as steady rest for turning long, thin spindles. The worry was this might "cause" an accident for someone with little experience.

My take was that nearly anything associated with woodturning (and woodworking) has a certain risk and if the goal of WC was to promote absolute minimal risk we might all just give it up and take up scrapbooking. (Someone then pointed out the potential danger from paper cuts so maybe there's a safer hobby - stamp collecting?)

JKJ

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: More Physics

Lyle Jamieson

I prefer to error on the side of safety. I will trust the turning experience and math of Dr. Dale Nish. His formula to be in control of the turning process has a 5 to 1 ratio. For every inch you hang over the tool rest you need 5 inches of handle to stay in control. So let me do some math. If I have a 8 inch tall hollow form I need a 40 inch handle. Why do they make long handles on bowl gouges? You can take as much or as little risk while you turn as your fortitude allows. What is the risk of a capture support?

I knew from passed posts that I would get in a pi$$ing match here. I just wanted to give folks some dynamics to think about. The whole idea to me is to have fun at the lathe. If danger is your idea of fun...go for it. If making your own tools is fun...go for it, I will even help, with some perspective, maybe a different perspective. There is no right or wrong here just a different tolerance for risk. There is no turning police looking over your shoulder.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#9

Re: More Physics

John Lucas

I don't want to get an argument started either and I agree with Lyle. Bad things happen very fast in turning so it's best to be on the safe side.

One of the advantages of the captured bar system is that it keeps the tool cutting on the center line or where ever you set it. This reduces catches to a minimum so the captured part of the system doesn't have to do much work if any. I demonstrate this when doing demo's at my house by sliding the bar in and letting go. The tool hits the wood and just kicks. If there is any catch you can't tell it.

When I built my first system I made the bars very wide to help arrest any twisting. When I started to understand how the system works I realized that as long as everything was lined up properly there simply aren't any catches so the captured system is just a safeguard. A very good safe guard because like I said, bad things happen faster than you can respond.

My first system was on a mini lathe and the secondary tool rest was made out of wood and sat on the floor. It worked fine.

It would be very simple to put a captured system on Steve's system. I know that it works, and mine did also but it's simply not worth taking the risk.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#10

Trying to educate myself here then...

Randy Gleckler

To keep up the healthy debate and education;

So then why is Steve's dangerous but the hollowing system that Trent Bosch or John Jordan sell not? or are you saying they are? Neither of those are any more captured than Steve's and he has something to press to to make sure you don't go above center? Just asking so I make sure I understand both sides here.

And please note, I'm just using those two names as examples, not asking your to question their tool making... just getting an understanding here.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Trying to educate myself here then...

Lyle Jamieson

Well Here we go again with more controversy. Turners have been successfully hollowing out hollow forms for decades with hand held tools. I went through the long learning curve because there were no captured or supported tools back when I started. Of course Im a slow learner. I learned from David Ellsworth who uses his boring bars with round, home made handles. Would I ever say David is doing something unsafe...no way. He has decades of practice perfecting his techniques and I would venture to guess he never gets a catch in there. Why did Dennis Stuart Develop the arm brace to do hollowing?? The stresses are so severe that it is very hard to hang onto a round handle and control a hand held boring bar. The arm brace and pistol grip was revolutionary. Hand hollowing is really hard work, even when you get good at it, and the arm brace lowered the strength needed. Now we could get our whole body in the action for more leverage to the cuts. Then the boring bars and vessels got bigger and bigger and the larger boring bars were just too heavy to hang onto, so the grand masters like Clay Foster used counter balance weights to hold the handle end of large boring bars. Clay actually used a stack of bricks on a plywood pad with pulleys going up to the ceiling and back down to the end of the handle. Hugh Mc Kay developed a platform, back in the '80s, not unlike Steves (only with a capture) that Binh Pho uses today. Frank Sudol pioneered the torque arrest with captured back rest system. There are copy cat systems of my supported system in all shapes and colors now. Thats some quick history.

In an experts hands the risk is minimal. Could I do something stupid and blow a vessel up, absolutely. But I dont put myself in a place to get hurt. I guess it was ingrained into me by my Dad as a young kid in the shop. On every tool in your shop, lightning speed, bad things can happen. The trick is not to put any part of your body in the way when it does. Do you put your hand behind the board to support it when you use a nailing gun?? I remember the hole in the wall of the shop, my Dad never repaired, behind the table saw where a piece of wood went right through the wall. The wood hit the wall without any body parts attached. Pretty simple, just dont stand there. I see people doing pretty stupid things in shops all over the country. Most of the time they are lucky and dont get hurt. When there is a quick and easy fix to make a tool safer why in the world would you take any more risk then necessary. An interesting benefit to safety in hollowing is, the safer your tool system is the shorter the learning curve is to having fun with it. Instead of brute force of yesteryear we can use fingertip control today.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Trying to educate myself here then...

Steve Kubien

Randy, I would like to add something to what Lyle said... With a captured rig like the one he sells (or Kelton's, Oneway's, Monster's etc), if it is set up correctly (and that's not rocket science), you cannot get a catch. When I use my captured rig (which I will add is a Jamieson for reasons of full-disclosure) I can ram the cutter into the side of a vessel and it will not catch. It is really thin then I can go through it but that's not the same thing.

I hollowed my first vessels with the Jamieson system. Recently I have been playing with handheld cutters like the Keltons. While I enjoy using the Keltons, I feel a lot safer using the captured rig. I will continue to use both depending on the size of work and how I feel that day.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#13

Steven Antonucci

The issue is the word "unsafe"

Steven Antonucci

I am not against putting the capturing bar over the back of the tool. It adds another factor of safety, which is fine. Safe is good.

If you look at the Elmer Adams video below, you will notice that his system is gated at the front, but not captured at the back. Is gated safer? Probably. The designs of all of the systems are far from 100% guaranteed, but they all lower risk substantially. Some have short handles that are compensated by being captured. Others have long handles that have enough mass to arrest most situations. Some are gated. And so on...

I had two small catches with my system last night that resulted in the back edge of the wooden block lifting 1/4". The weight of my arm was more than sufficient to counteract it with no danger to the user. I suspect that Jamieson rig would have done the exact same thing because he's got some travel in the rear above the boring bar.

It is your labeling of something that is 99.9% functionally the same as your own unit that gets the controversy fired up. Nobody has labeled your short handle as dangerous. Conventional wisdom in turning is that long handles are good, right? It is important to understand where the differences are, what any of the potential risks are, and explain them. If the platform needed a capture bar, it would be simple enough to add. It doesn't and it is not dangerous. With your handle being so short compared to the cutting bar, it would be dangerous on a Jamieson hollower.

I would be more worried about using the Jamieson rig without having the eyebolt in place to keep the short handle from accidentally pulling off of the back support. I would also be concerned that the back support is a single point of failure and I would recommend moving to at least two support bars to avoid a catastophic failure. It also appears that the back support is height adjustable, which means that it could be inadvertantly set to the wrong height, taking the cutter off centerline... Limitations, right? Unsafe, probably not...

I was going to let my 12 year old do the demo. He's turned exactly once, and never hollowed, but he had homework. If you listen to the video in the middle, you will hear my twins chatting in the background. They are 4, and were in the shop behind me. Nothing unsafe at all about what I posted.

I agree with your other points about EASE OF USE, STRESS, etc. 100% entirely- but safety is my #1 concern with 4 young kids in the shop almost every day.

Steve

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#14

Re: Trying to educate myself here then...

John Lucas

I think education is a good thing and a lively discussion adds to it. So I'm not trying to stir controversy. There is really not much comparison in a hand held bar (like Jordan, Ellsworth, etc) and a captured bar system. I've used both and still do today. However my skills at hollowing aren't that great because I don't do a lot of hollowing. I've hurt my wrist and shoulder on the one good catch I got. I don't like that. I haven't had many catches because I try to follow the rules however that one bad one has never left my memory. That was about 5 years ago so I've been pretty successful with hand held hollowing.

I have never had a catch with a captured bar system. I have cut through the side, cut the lip of the vessel off and made the bottom to thin but there was no danger involved in any of those.

When you couple a laser to the captured bar system it is almost relaxing to use. I've had small kids and absolute beginners use the system with no problems.

Why would you use one over the other. I don't have a really good place to store my captured bar system so setting it up takes a few minutes. I'm sure Lyle and Steve can get to theirs in a heartbeat. I can pull the hand held system out in seconds. If it's just a small vessel I'll do it hand held. It's also the skew state of mind. People told me the skew was hard to learn so I studied it until I learned it. Hand held hollowing is the same for me. I got catches at first and now I don't nearly as often and they certainly aren't as bad.

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

#15

Don Pencil

Re: No Money No Problem!!!

Don Pencil

This thread appears on some forum every few months. There is always misinformation and information of good value.

I can't see using Steve's rig because I like other setups. Will his work? Is it dangerous? I bet it will work and if used correctly fairly safe. But you would have to know how to set it up properly and use it safely. That includes it's limitations.

If you do not setup or opperate the captured system properly you are no safer than you are with any other tool. You are working with machinery here and if you do it wrong you can certainly have a problem or injury and that does include the captured system.

I know more than little woman (under 5' 5" and 120#)from Leasure World (over 70 years old) in Sothern California who learned how to turn green bowls (among many other things) in the first semester at community college; hollow vessels and segmented in the second semester. They learned this on the hand held Scorpion. No injuries. They just used the tools the tools properly.

There are things you cannot do with a captured and things one cannot do with a hand held.

May I suggest that each of us quit "bad mouthing" and/or putting down the other tools (and promoting the ones sell, manufacture, or personally like) and objectively discuss the value we see in all of these tools.

There are wonderfuf uses for most all tools. There is a right time, a proper usage, and safe way to use them, captured, hand held, gouge, and scraper.

Be Well,

Don Pencil