Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

How fast is a ball bat

Posts

How fast is a ball bat

#1

How fast is a ball bat

john lucas

In trying to explain the dangers of wood turning I would like to compare getting hit by a piece of wood to being hit by a baseball bat. I'm very match challenged but I know we have some math experts on this site. I'd like to pick a speed, say 1200 to 1500 rpm or so and a bowl about 10". Would that compare at all to a ball bat being swung. I know your talking about a lot longer lever. I'm just wondering if there is a comparison.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#2

Make that "math" challenged 

john lucas

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#3

  I thought that "match" challenged ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

referred to your social life. :D :D

Ed

PS: If you want an answer to bats versus bowls then you must pose your question more carefully. What are you really asking?

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#4

Steven Antonucci

More physics than math...

Steven Antonucci

which makes it math anyway :\

You need to calculate the force that a bat strikes with vs the force a bowl strikes with and find a correlation. (or not)

An average baseball bat weight about 34 oz these days. Acceleration from rest to I've heard about 100 mph usually occurs in a subsecond, or the batter is late and will not hit. it anyhow.

The bowl spinning and accidentialy leaves the lathe will depart in a straight line tangentially outward (i.e. LINE of fire). If will do this proportinate to the rpms, and cover a much shorter distance at whatever speed it is moving.

I suspect that a baseball moves much faster, and a bat outweighs the average bowl substantially, but I wouldn't want to get hit with either. In addition to these things, the bat will also have some of the swinger's mass be part of the mass for the calculation, but the bowl doesn't get any credit for being attached to an 800# Stubby.

Consequently, if you've ever ben hit with a bat and a bowl, you'd take the bowl ever time given the choice...

Steve

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#5

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Dave Belser

An interesting question. You need a Physics major for your answer. From my own experience and limited knowledge of physics/mechanics, I don't think the comparison is accurate. You don't say if are considering the case where the work comes apart or just dismounts.

If the work comes off with out breaking up then the considerable momentum / inertia is almost entirely rotational and hence not the same as being hit by a bat. When I was a young turner, I had a bowling ball size chunk of oak that was badly mounted come loose. Fortunately I was wearing a face shield and able to react a little and bring my arm up slightly. The wood ran up my arm into my face shield and over my head landing on the floor behind me, still spinning! While I was rather surprised and shaken, I didn't suffer much more than a small bruise or scrape on my forearm and a sore nose where the face shield banged me.

If the work splits up and launches then it would be a different story. You might try google-ing for a description of the physics of a sling. It seems to me that it would be a common physics problem. Work flying apart is not much different that putting a rock in a sling.

- Dave

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#6

Re: More physics than math...

Dave Belser

Steve you beat me to it! Yes it's physics.

I think that there are really two different cases that have to be considered - Work that dismounts and work that comes apart. A large piece that falls off doesn't just launch itself in a straight line.

I guess it would be a question of how much of the angular momentum (when on the lathe) gets converted to linear (?) momentum. At one extream you have a top the other a sling.

Which reminds me of the time when I was a kid and my neighbor was swinging a sock full of quarters around his head as fast as he could. Well the toe of the sock let loose and we all hit the deck fast. There were quarters stuck in the sheetrock!

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Rob Wallace

Interesting question John!

I just spent nearly 3 hours yesterday doing Little League skill assessments for about 200 kids....... batting skills among them. A lot depends on technique and bat speed achieved by the batter.

Google is your friend:

Have a look at this - Physics of batting:

http://paws.kettering.edu/~drussell/bats-new/impulse.htm

More on batting and bat structure vs. forces developed:

http://www.bostonbaseball.com/whitesox/baseball_extras/physics.html

The amount of force exerted is directly proportional to the mass of the object and the rate of change of speed (acceleration or deceleration) [ F = ma]

Obviously the weight [mass under gravity effects] and rotational speed of a bowl blank flying from a lathe will determine how much force it is capable of achieving. I agree with Steve that under 'normal' woodturning conditions where blanks or bowls fly from the lathe (if you consider this 'normal'), I think less force would likely be imparted on a flying blank than from a baseball bat being swung; particularly given the force per unit area of contact upon impact. The force of a "flying turned/hollowed object" (with considerably less mass than an unturned blank) would clearly have even less force than an unturned blank, and probably much less force than baseball bat when swung at maximum velocity.

Since it is very difficult to calculate the force imparted to a "generic bowl blank" or turned form given the wide range of sizes, turning speeds, etc. in order to determine a value to compare to the approximation of 6000 to 8000 pounds of force on a baseball that a bat imparts, I think it sufficient to say that getting hit by a bat at full swing is likely more forceful than getting hit by a flying bowl or bowl blank encountered by the vast majority of woodturners (unless, of course, the blank is massive, quite literally!).

Regardless of the magnitude of force found in flying bowls or swinging bats, I intend to get hit by neither for the rest of my life. I don't know anything about the science of force/energy interactions and destructive effects on human bodies, but I am sure there are data out there on this (military and highway safety studies come to mind).....even the Mythbusters have shown relatively small forces can cause major damage on their human stand-in analogs (using pig carcasses) when showing damage due to various forces imparted violently on these 'models".

Have a great day!

Rob Wallace

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#8

Richard Allen

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Richard Allen

63360 inches per mile

A 10" bowl has a circumference of 10 x pi = 31.4"

at 1500 RPM the rim of the bowl is going 44 MPH (faster than the recommended 30MPH top speed for woodturning) at 1200 RPM the rim is traveling as 35 MPH.

So how fast do you swing a baseball bat to move the striking area at 35 MPH?

A professional baseball player get the bat going at about 70 MPH. There are things a trained successful baseball player does with a bat to attain that sort of speed. So an average homeowner should be able to swing a bat at 35 mph if they are focused on the task.

Another way to achieve the effect is to throw an object against wall from a car moving at 30 MPH.

How about dropping an object from a height? 32'/sec/sec

26'. Drop the object out of a 3 story window.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#9

Steven Antonucci

I have a 4" slit in the sheetrock above my lathe

Steven Antonucci

from a platter that split and became a 15" Ninja star!

Now, if you've ever seen a 20# roughed log come off the lathe, that will leave a mark! (usually, there's a Kelton involved in my shop, but I digres... :D )

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#10

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Don Wilcut

I'm glad you guys shared this knowledge with us Business Majors.

Don :b :D

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#11

Re: How fast is a ball bat

John Lucas

I agree with Don. I'm an artist/photographer. I can balance a checkbook, sometimes. that's about as far as my math goes. Physics, I'm more of a hands on kind of guy where that is concerned. I know that an object in motion, hurts when it tries to stop. That's from personal experience.

I asked the question because over the years I've had a few pieces break apart and fly across the room faster than you could possibly react. One put a pretty good dent in the metal side of my jointer. That was a lot of force.

I think it's given that you don't want to get hit in the face with a ball bat or a large chunk of bowl. I just wondered how they would compare so if I use that analogy I don't want to be too far out of line.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#12

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Carol Reed

You said "fast," John, so can I take that to mean how much time I have to duck before the bowl hits me?

Knowing I cannot be fast enough under the best of circumstances, Id be more interested in force - how much will it hurt!

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#13

Energy Contained

Doc Green

As has been stated, there are too many variables to draw a realistic comparison between a spinning bowl and a swinging bat, but it is instructive to consider the energy contained in a spinning blank. I assumed the blank to be a disk.

So, the energy contained in a 10-inch blank turning at 1200 RPM is equivalent to the energy it would have if lifted to a height of 21.5 feet.

If the same blank spins at 1500 RPM, the energy corresponds to a height of 33.6 feet. Yes, a modest change in RPM makes a big difference.

How tall are you, 6 feet, perhaps? For the 1200 RPM case, suppose the blank is lifted 21.5 feet above your head. That would put the blank 27.5 feet above the floor.

The implication is that if the blank comes off the lathe and imparts all its energy to your head, the effect would be the same as having it drop from a height of 27.5 feet and hit you on top of the head.

For the 1500 RPM case, the height would be about 39 feet.

The height (before adding 6 feet) varies as the square of the diameter AND the square of the RPM. That is, double either one, and the height gets multiplied by four.

The height does not depend upon the weight of the blank. It would be the same for a blank of balsa or a blank of green oak. However, having the balsa fall on your head would be much preferred to the oak, if you should have to make a choice.

Here's another tidbit. Someone pointed out that the rim speed is typically on the order of 30 mph. An object traveling at 30 mph has about the same energy as one dropped from a height of 30 feet. Easy to remember: 30-30.

FWIW, ~Doc

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#14

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Russ Fairfield

John, I've been telling them for years that it's like being hit with a 90 MPH fastball, and nobody has argued the specifics with me yet. All you are trying to tell them is that it won't kill anybody. but it will really hurt, and might leave a black spot for a couple weeks.

Having a pair of cracked and mangled safety glasses or a cracked face shield is a good way to convey the message. The photos of the guy in VT with the mangled face and the catchers mask that was in the AAW Journal several years ago will convey the message better than any other comparisons you could make.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#15

Richard Allen

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Richard Allen

That was David Lancaster and the article was in the Spring 2001 issues page 28.

That article is as valid today as it was then.

David did a demo at the KC 2005 symposium. The question of face and eye protection was brought up at the demo I attended. David brushed off the question and when pressed on the topic indicated that he didn't wear face or eye protection because he found that such protections got in his way.

David makes thousands of bowls each year. David may have modified his behavior from the Summer of 2005. David may have a different recollection, which I would suspect is more accurate.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#16

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Barry Irby

I put a wet, spalted oak bank on my lathe. It was an octagon about 7" across and 14" long. Reached with one hand for the switch and the other for the face shield. The shield hand was slow and the blank flew off and hit me right on the forehead. Bled like I was dying. My glasses flew away. Couldn't find them. Called a neighbor for a trip to the emergency room. 27 stitches in three different layers of material.

Two things, I'm certain a baseball bat would have killed me. And I think if I had gotten the face shield on I would have not been hurt or only slightly. Does not pay to work when you are tired.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#17

Tablesaw comparison

Pete in Holland, MI

I use my tablesaw to show un-knowing woodworkers the speed of the tools they are dealing with.

Example: 10" tablesaw at 3450 rpm

10" X 3.14phi / 12in/ft = 2.616 feet circumfrence of the blade.

2.616 x 3450rpm x 60min/hour / 5280ft/mile = 102mph !

Thus, with a long enough extension cord, flip your tablesaw upside down and let scream down the street at 102mph!

Makes a great demonstration by dropping a small piece of wood directly on top of a spinning blade and watching it launch into the wall.

I'm all about live demonstrations when possible.

Pete

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Keith Tompkins

John, I can tell you this...I someone were standing in front of me, and I hit them in the forehead with a bat while I was swinging for the bleachers, their skull would be fractured into small pieces. There was a TV show recently comparing a martial artist with weapons against a mafia member with a bat. No contest. Get hit squarely in the head with a bat, you'll be pushing up daiseys. :)

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#19

Re: Energy Contained

charlie belden

Doc:

I've tried all sorts of ways to convey the effect of a kickback on a table saw

and that of an inside catch when turning. I know how to calculate the angular

momentum and know that it's the velocity SQUARED that's the big multiplier

in the E=mV^2 equation. Your How High Would It Go - and - have it fall from

that height and hit you explanation is the best one I've heard - or thought of.

You any relation to Mr. Wizard?

Sure would be nice if kids watched someone like Mr. Wizard instead of playing

video games - or "texting". (Hi. What are you doing? - Nothing. What are

you doing? - Nothing. - Wadda you want to do? - I don't know. Wadda you

want to do? - Nothin'. - See ya. - See ya.)

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#20

You mean like this-Power tool racing  *LINK*

John Lucas


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tG5kWmJKoos

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#21

Thank you, Charlie . . .

Doc Green

. . . for the kind words. Mr. Wizard (Don Herbert) was my hero when I was a young kid, and I wanted to grow up to be like him. But, I didn't quite make it.

~Doc

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#22

Re: Tablesaw comparison

Guy Bratt

I have a table saw nearly 57 years old still works great. 0 safety devices though.

One day I was cutting against the fence. That little voice said " your doing this wrong". But did I listen? Well I did step aside the line of kickback. It happened in an instant. The piece kicked out, left the garage, flew over the pickup and down the drive. I measured it 85 feet from the blade.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#23

Brad Vietje

More Baseball Math

Brad Vietje

Thanks, Doc -- I like the 30-30 rule of thumb; that's easy to remember.

Now, remembering back about 25 years to when I played on a lot of softball teams, I learned an important lesson in baseball math...

I used to be a lab researcher at the University of Vermont medical school, and played on the Pathology and Anatomy teams for a few years. One of the residents came into medicine via a degree in Physics, and that fellow could really hit a softball. Lots of people -- all smart people who were MD's or PhD's (or both) would grab a heavier bat to try to hit the ball further. So this fellow shows up at a game one day with his own bat in a velvet bag... like Paul Newman and his pool cue. Painted on the side of it, where you'd expect to see Louisville Slugger or a Hank Aaron autograph was the following:

KE = 1/2 MV ^2 (squared).

That got a lot of laughs until he used it to hit the ball waaaay over the head of the center fielder, and well into a nearby parking lot!

Turns out that hitting a ball with a bat is for the most part an inelastic collision in physics terms, and the equation pretty much sums it up. Kinetic energy is the energy of motion, and to hit a home run, you have to give the ball a lot of it. BUT, KE = 1/2 of the mass (weight) times the velocity squared. So you can hit the ball a LOT further with a fast moving light bat than with a slower moving heavy bat! The greater mass (heavier bat) is discounted by 50%, while the velocity of the bat is multiplied times itself.

A bunch of us went from 40 and 42 oz. ounce bats to lighter bats, and we started winning a lot more games.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#24

Re: How fast is a ball bat

Russ Fairfield

John,

Don't make it more complicated than it has to be. Keep it simple and they will remember it. I always use the analogy of a 90 MPH fast ball, or a kid throwing a rock from 3' away. People can understand that. The weight and speed are similar. It can do damage when it hits you, but probably won't kill you. That's good enough for most people.

Re: How fast is a ball bat

#25

Ha!

John K Jordan

>Painted on the side of it, where you'd expect to see Louisville Slugger or a Hank Aaron

>autograph was the following: KE = 1/2 MV ^2 (squared).

What a great story!!!

JKJ