Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

I've started the spindle duplicating

Posts

I've started the spindle duplicating

#1

I've started the spindle duplicating

john lucas

I didn't have much time for turning today. I had lots of other things that had to be done. I made the spindle prototype today and then set up the Vega Duplicator. I made 10 spindles before I had to quit and run errands. I'll make the other 34 tomorrow. The duplicator really speeds this up. This is a simple little spindle and I could have made them without the duplicator but it sure reduces the task to a tolerable level. Using the newer carbide cutter I am able to start sanding with 220 grit. I measured several of them and they are within about .010" of each other. That's closer than your eye can see and I might have caused some of that by sanding on a little different than the next. I'll post a photo tomorrow when I get done.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#2

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

Grant Wilkinson

John

I don't want to hijack your thread, but would you by chance have an electronic copy of the user manual for the duplicator?

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#3

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

John,

I would like to see a picture of the finish from the duplicator before sanding.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#4

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

john lucas

Doug I'll do that next. I just took a break to get a snack and get the camera for a few shots of the process.

I have 20 more to do. They are taking about 5 minutes each which includes sanding to 400 grit and putting a layer of finish.

This carbide cutter produces shavings if you don't feed it too fast. If I make the last cut carefully I could probably sand with 320. I take advantage of the minor amount of flex in the whole setup. I cut the shape and then I apply just a little more pressure for the last pass. That takes off about 3 to 5 thousandths and really cleans it up.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#5

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

john lucas

Grant I don't have an electronic version of the manual. You might send an e-mail to Randy at Vega and see if he has one. He's been very helpful and gave me some good tips after my first round with the machine. My complaints were very minor at that time and they are more positive this time.

He does have a video that really shows how to use the machine. What I find most helpful is always cut downhill with respect to the grain direction and take it slow doing a plunge type cut. If you cut uphill at all it tries to pull the tool into the work and flexes everything just enough to take a deeper cut. You could easily sand out the deep spot with 180 or even 220 but if you avoid it in the first place everything just goes faster.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#6

Unsanded spindle

john lucas

Doug here is the spindle straight off the duplicator. The thin spot on this spindle is 3/16" and the tenons are 3/8" Out of 46 spindles I only had 2 with tenons that were too snug. It was probably me no pushing on the drive arm of the cutter. Randy suggested I remove the spring that pushes the cutter for the small spindles. He was right. It was much easier and I had more control.

These were easily sanded with 220 although this one could have been done with 320 or even 400.


Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#7

cutter in action

john lucas

As you can see from this photo the cutter produces nice shavings which I guess is why it leaves such a clean surface. For the final cut you need a nice smooth feed rate, just like a metal lathe. The slower cut leaves a better finish.


Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#8

table parts

john lucas

I now have all the parts for the table done. A few more days applying finish and I'll be able to assemble this thing. That's when the fun begins. The rings with the spindles will be glued to the bottom of each table top.


Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#9

Re: table parts

Barry Irby

All but two of them are upside down. And a couple are missing.

Looks great other than that. Don't envy you trying to put it together. I did a bed that had 36 spindles and it took many tries to get it together. And they were not glued, they floated. Probably could have used twenty five more fingers.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#10

Re: cutter in action

Galen Vetterick

John

Does the duplicator allow you to change the angle the cutter is presented to make the facing cuts on both ends of the spindal or do you have to clean up by hand? The tenon looks like it has a small radius at the spindal face so is that left and the hole chamfered to allow it to seat?

Never watched one of these duplicators in action and how much detailed they can reproduce.

Galen

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#11

Re: cutter in action

john lucas

Galen The duplicator cutter has a slight angle to it. I'll have to measure to be able to tell you. It will not cut a square shoulder. What I did was to turn all I could with the duplicator. Then I put the lathe in reverse and walked around to the other side to use a parting tool to clean up the shoulders.

I've read about some people putting the duplicator on the backside and either running the lathe in reverse or mounting the cutter upside down. Then you can stand in the traditional side to do any clean up cuts.

The last time I tried a duplicator the cutter left quite a bit of tearout. I used the machine to rough out the piece and then went back over the whole thing with bevel rubbing lathe tools. It was faster than cutting and measureing all the spindles by hand but not anywhere near as good as the Vega with the Carbide cutter.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#12

Re: table parts

john lucas

The smaller ring is going to be cut into 4 pieces. Consequently there will be 4 holes that won't be there. I don't expect the glue up to be to bad unless I do something stupid like put one spindle up side down. I'm going to use slow set epoxy. Put a dab in each hole of the top, insert the spindles and then put the ring on top. Adjust everything so it's true if off and clamp the ring. When it's dry I'll remove the ring, put a dab of epoxy in all the holes and then set it on all the spindles. If you hear some loud foul language you'll know it didn't go as smooth as I think.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#13

Re: cutter in action

bill sams

John, curious....at what height do you have the cutter tip, slightly above spindle center, slightly below or dead center. I find for myself, slightly above center works best for both the carbide and the high speed steel cutter.

I agree that removing the spring helps in refining, especially working tight radius beads and coves.

Nice work!

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#14

Re: cutter in action

john lucas

Bill I put it dead on center. I matched it to my drive center point.

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

#15

Re: I've started the spindle duplicating

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Thanks John, the finish is better than what I expected... I might need to get one.