Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

The absolute best you can do

Posts

The absolute best you can do

#1

The absolute best you can do

Paul Zerjay

I am one of those who says nothing leaves my shop without me thinking it's the best I can do. I try to stick to this as much as possible, although I do admit sometimes on things like stoppers I tend to slip a little on this rule. Anyway how many times have you said to yourself, "That's the best I can do. Stop before you break something." I can think of no better feeling than having pushed yourself, and the piece comes through better than you had hoped. I don't believe I'm the only one who stands there looking at a completed piece thinking,"Wow, I actually pulled that off... And it looks pretty good too."

Re: The absolute best you can do

#2

Re: The absolute best you can do

Carole Valentine

Seems my "best" is never good enough for me...and I usually realize this when it's basically too late to do anything about it. That's what keeps me going back to the lathe: "I'm going to do this piece better..." Sometimes though, I think I just get tired - physically and mentally - of a piece and just want to get it OFF. I have a piece like that mounted now...very dry burl HF that is beating me to death even using a hollowing gate. I just came in to get a drink, but after reading your post, I think I will just leave it for the day and go back at it fresh tomorrow. I surely will do a better job if I do that.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: The absolute best you can do

Steve Kubien

For me, this is akin to finding the perfect curve and getting a piece just thin enough. I don't do freakish thin for piercing and for my bowls, which are 95% functional salad and fruit bowls, this is a fine line. Too thin and folks consider it fragile. Too thick and it doesn't look or feel right. It becomes judgment call.

For that elusive "perfect curve", well, sometimes it works and sometimes, less so. On the 'less so' pieces which are butchered in my eye, I take the time to practise a few different cuts, work on my finishing abilities...or make a future jamb-chuck. If I'm really mad, it goes into 'that corner' of the shop, never to be heard from again.

Steve

BTW, there are a lot of finials in 'that corner'!

Re: The absolute best you can do

#4

Re: The absolute best you can do

George Guadiane

Paul, you're not the only one, but when I'm done, I often say "and it almost looks like what I had in mind."

The "BEST???" Sometimes I take "shortcuts" like buffing a closed grain HARD wood instead of applying a finish, so I can get it done faster... Is that still my best? I'm not sure.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#5

Rob Wallace

Re: The absolute best you can do

Rob Wallace

I tend to be the same, Paul. However there is a point of diminishing returns when you reach a particular stage of completion on a piece, that even considerably more time investment on it will improve the piece by only small, perhaps imperceptible increments - and these small improvements are probably only noticeable by the maker, or by some other turner with a particularly skilled eye.

On the pieces that I KNOW will have very careful examination and comparison to other work (like those pieces submitted for competition in juried shows) I am guilty of spending probably more time on these pieces (relatively speaking) than on those pieces that are destined for the gallery for "normal" artwork sales. To win awards is an important part of the turner's/artist's development, so I think the additional time investment is worth putting into the piece to improve one's chances of receiving an award, or other recognition (...even if the piece is simply accepted for exhibition is worth the extra time/effort).

Does this mean that every piece that leaves my shop is the absolute best I can do? By definition, probably not. However, if you asked me if I am proud of every piece that leaves my shop, and whether I am willing to associate my name with it "for all the World to see"? My unequivocal answer is - YES.

Nothing leaves my shop unless I am proud of what I have done (....especially if I am asking people to spend their money buying the piece!) regardless of what its final destination is.

Good thread!

Rob Wallace

Re: The absolute best you can do

#6

JL

Absolute best is the enemy of "good"..

JL

Do I make everything perfectly - hardly. Am I proud of what I make - yes. If I'm not proud, it goes in the burn pile. There is the law of diminishing returns - sort of like trimming hair - if you keep on trimming until it is "perfect" - you won't have any hair left...

Whenever I make a piece of furniture (or set of chairs) - I make them as good as I can. Are they perfect - no. But you've got to get them out the door.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#7

Re: The absolute best you can do

Guy Bratt

For myself I have trouble leaving well enough alone. Many times I take that one last cut or that one final step to perfection and I end up disappointed.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#8

The absolute best I can do-Today

john lucas

I'd love to say everything that comes out of my shop is the best I can do. In reality it is usually the best I can do that day. Some days everything just goes right and I turn out some pretty good work, some of them are good enough to be accepted into the AAW show. Some days I produce work that simply gets put aside or even tossed. I'm trying to improve the overall quality of the work that comes off my lathe but some I'll be honest, some days it just doesn't work.

The biggest thing to consider is are you having fun. That should be all that really matters. If you are having fun then it usually shows in your work.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#9

Steven Antonucci

Corollary:  Good enough is the enemy of great

Steven Antonucci

Re: The absolute best you can do

#10

Re: The absolute best you can do

Barry Irby

I don't think all my work is the Absolute best I can do. I do many different things in my shop and some of them really don't need to be collector quality or museum quality. I cut a set of stair stringers for a front porch recently. They were perfectly functional but they were no where near the quality of even my worst turning, but there were excellent for that purpose. The miters on deck railings are not the same as picture frames or the joints in segmented turnings. Cutting boards are not the same as finely sanded turnings but still entirely functional.

I think there has to be a standard for my work, but it is not Absolute Best I Can Do.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#11

Re: Corollary:  Good enough is the enemy of great

Texian

Sometimes my absolute best is not good enough. So I try to keep improving.

Re: The absolute best you can do

#12

Re: The absolute best you can do

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca

One of my father's favorites: "...Son, you don't build a barn the same way that you build a piano...and you don't build a piano the same way that you build a barn"

Recently I have been turning projects for sale to some very specific markets. Previously, turning for the high-end gallery market alone produced occasions of nice checks in the mail, but barely covered the cost of sandpaper at the years end.

For these niche markets that I am targeting now. I do not do "the absolute best that I can do", but checks in the mail on a regular basis will change the way you think about your work. (After all, I'm not building a piano now") Thanks Dad!