Has anybody here ever bought a Nova DVR and regretted it? Do you wish you had gone Powermatic or Oneway or Robust or something else? Any trouble with the motor or electronics package? Is there something about it you would change if you could (or did)?
I've had a DVR XP since September 09 and love it. It fits the space I have and power available. The fact that the head swivels but is simple to realign saves my back . I turn bowls up to 15", hollow forms, core with it and turn whatever else I like.
I would rather have a lathe with more mass but can't complain as yet. A knob for variable speed rather than a touch pad and a wired remote would be nice. User setable presets help with speed changes. No problem with electronics but the lathe is fairly new and so am I (to turning).
I've had my DVR since 2005. Other than the lack of mass (which could be overcome if I had the inclination to build a new stand), it generally serves my purposes. The only problem I have had so far was when roughing a big, heavy out of balance piece. When the heavy section was on the upswing, sometimes even a light cut would be interpreted by the electronics as a "catch" and the lathe would stop, then resume after 10 or 15 seconds. This only happened at low speeds. Once I could get the speed over 400 or so rpms, the problem ceased. The problem is exacerbated if the wood around the drive center spurs compresses and allows even a tiny bit of play. Otherwise it has done everything I have asked of it. I do appreciate the swivel headstock and use that feature often...it's much easier on my body when hollowing (all of my hollowing is freehand). I would like it better if it had a remote, a rheostat type speed control and beefier banjo and TS lockdowns. The toolrest and drive center that come with it are a joke.
I've had mine since October, 2008. When I got it on the Woodcraft sale I also bought the cast iron leg set, a bed extension, and the extension hinge. All up it cost about $2500. I originally wanted a Mustard Monster, but the $3k base price was out of range. I have added two of the good, hardened, rests from Robust. I have not found the lack of weight to be a real issue, perhaps because I levelled the machine, then bolted the legs to the concrete floor One of the first mods I did to the machine was to rewire it for 220V, a simple ten minute job. That took the hp up to 2.0, or so the spec sheet says.
The only things I wish the folks at Teknatool would address is a vernier speed control like the 3520B (the technology is readily available), and a start/stop switch that could be moved out of the line of fire.
I had a PM 3520A for 8 years, and my 3 hp Robust for 2. I only did one demo on a Nova DVR. I was pleasantly surprised it had as much torque as it did for such a small lathe. Changing speeds is fine if you want your 5 or so preselected favorites, but for my bowls, just not practical. The swivel head is a nice touch, though I prefer the sliding headstock. You can use the McNaughton coring system on it, in any configuration, but the Oneway and Woodcut will only work if the motor is in line for turning spindles.
I have had mine for about 5 years and don't regret the purchase. I only have room for a short bed lathe and it fitted my space fine. Mine is on a homemade mdf workbench that is filled with sand and the stand alone weighs 300kg so I don't have a problem with it moving. I made my own remote control for a few �'s which allows start stop and speed change anywhere I want to move the control box to. A rotary speed control would be nice but the preset speeds work well particularly as they can be reprogrammed to the speed that you want.
I wouldn't change it as it suits the turning that I do and fits in the space available.
I have had mine since September of 2004 I believe. It is the last model that could be upgraded to the new electronics which was done. This lathe is here for good and I use it as much as my 3520b. The folks at Teknatool have been great and when MSN dropped their groups I took part of the group to the MyFamily site as the Nova Owners Group. I hear far to regularly that there is not much traffic at the site but the site was mainly for problems that came up (I do encourage photos of finished work) and the fact that not many problems do appear is probably a good thing for Teknatool. By far the biggest thing said about the lathe especially from new owners is the speed ramping method the lathe uses. Even myself when I first got it looked for a way to perhaps put a dial type speed adjustment on it. But now it is as common as my left hand and the five presets make it that much easier to use. Would I buy this lathe again with what I know now, most definitely!
I've thought about the 2hp Jet (the Powermatic would be perfect except for the $$$) is it is much more reasonable dollar-wise than my dream lathe (big Robust or similar). The reservation I have is this...I'm in Canada and Jet has no presence here. Should anything go wrong (like the semi-frequent motor-clicking issues I've heard of), I'm toast. There are a couple of Nova dealers here and Tim Geist (service0dude) actually knew Canada existed prior to the Olympics so no worries there.
I'll keep saving and looking for now as there is no big hurry in this move (as I've been saying for about a year).
I have the Nova 3000, and I hated having to cross into the line of fire. I was going to wire another power switch on a dongle to have it be adjustable, but the simple answer hit me at Woodcraft one day.
You can get a power switch box with a magnetic back, and just plug the lathe into it. I leave it at the tailstock end, and I can turn off the lathe when I am turning without having to walk past the work. Cost about $30.
Thanks for all of the feedback so far. The main complaint seems to to the lack-of-a-dial for speed changes and the crappy toolrest (which I know about and ditched on my 1624). Rumor is Nova is coming up with a solution to the speed changes. One more question....
Has anyone mounted a big bowl blank outboard and what where your thoughts/concerns/opinions? I am talking about something to make a 20-24" bowl, 6-8" deep. Are the bearings and general construction of the headstock up to that kind of punishment occasionally?
I should add, one of the big reasons for me to look at the DVR is that I already have a 1624. I can use the bed of the 1624 to make a longer lathe, already have an extra banjo plus general familiarity. I would probably keep the 1624 headstock and motor as a just-in-case-stuff-hits-the-fan safety net. My coring unit and my hollowing rig (if I keep it) all fit as do my chucks and faceplates.
Steve, I have a DVR as my secondary lathe -- to cart around for demonstrations at clubs and at Lee Valley. It is a great lathe for stuff up to 14 inches in diameter. The cast iron legs Nova sells were well worth the investment as the lathe is very stable with them -- a dramatic difference from DVRs I have used with other bases. I dhave no complaints and a lot of compliments. But, if you are interested in turning anything over 14 inches, consider a Powermatic -- or, if you can afford it, as Oneway, Stubby or Vicmarc. They are made for really heavy duty work and make it a joy. You may be able to turn the bigger pieces, slowly, on the DVR -- but it is no joy And, isn't that what we are after?
Of course, I may be spoiled (as you know) because my main lathe is a big Oneway.
Steve Although I've turned on the DVR I only turned smaller items. I have however turned large items on the Nova3000. It was a pain in the butt trying to get the tool rest where you want it. I bought the outboard tool rest and although it helped in some situations there were times when I had to actually remove the work, move the tool rest, put the the work back on and then turn. That was a hassle. The outboard tool rest also introduced vibration problems. I remedied that by putting a piece of all-thread rod and some nuts to go from the tool rest to the floor. this worked but evertime I needed to move the outboard tool rest I had to loosen the all-thread and readjust it.
It's really hard to beat the Powermatic 3520B with the lowered extension for doing larger work. That is unless you have more money, then you can go with the Robust of Stubby.
I've had mine since before the XP version, about 2003 I think. The electronics on mine went bad soon after I got it and they replaced it with a slightly upgraded version at no cost to me, although I did have to install the package. I also upgraded to 220 volts and think that was worth it.
I don't think the stand was available when I bought mine and I mounted it on a cabinet that includes a column of sand under the head stock. I also found a roll of lead sheathing that weighs about a hundred pounds and laid that on the back of the cabinet behind the lathe. That made a big improvement. I think the leg set would be good because a lot of stuff accumulates on the cabinet and gets buried in the shavings.
I added and extension to the bed and that was worth it. Made my own tip away for the TS, but don't use it as I now have the extended bed.
I agree with the idea that it is no Mustard Monster. Just not the same lathe.
I turn things up to the max I can get over the bed. You can't get a sixteen inch blank on any sixteen inch lathe. I turn the headstock tot he side and cut the blank down to what will go over the ways.
The speed control is a bit of a nuisance, but so much better than a reeves drive or changing belts that it's fine. The newer ones with the presets would be even better.
But I don't know if you can purchase a Jet in Canada.
The Jet 1642 has many similarities with the Powermatic 3520b. It is not as hefty, but the construction is quite similar. It has similar legs - though I think the Powermatic's may have a little bit more "spread". The basic difference is that the Powermatic has a shorter bed and a taller headstock and tailstock. I've turned on both - but I like my Jet. But I'm not turning a lot of larger bowls and platters.
To the best of my knowledge, no Jet in Canada. Some European company has the rights to Jet outside the US and has apparently never heard of Canada. I feel a rant coming on so I will stop here.
Steve, Have you considered the big General VS lathe? Made in Canada, big, heavy, outdated but nearly unbreakable. The VS goes to "zero", and smooth, smooth, smooth. You can turn outboard too! There's a General ad on this page!
Hey Keith, to be honest, no, not seriously. For less money I could get the 3520B, have the benfit of the sliding headstock and greater capacity... And the 3520B isn't even in my budget right now! Believe me I would love to buy Canadian but I can't afford it!
By the end of the weekend I hope to finish up converting my 1624 to variable speed by swapping motors and adding a VFD. Everything is fitting together and looking good - I just need to complete the wiring and should be up and running with a 2HP motor. I transferred the motor sheave so I'll still have the 8 belt locations to set up my speed ranges. Should be able to run down to 50 rpm with lots of power. Motor and VFD cost $379 including shipping. If all goes well I'll put together a FAQ with parts #s and pics.
I have a narrow shop so the swivelling headstock is great because I can't use a sliding headstock. The 1624 is a great lathe. I bought it on sale with chuck and bed extension for $1100, so with this mod I'll have a variable speed for $1500.