Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

Posts

Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#1

Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

wilbur

I was looking at the Thompson Lathe Tools website, and noticed they had detail gouges and shallow detail gouges. Having never seen one of these in person, it looks like they are mainly spindle gouges with shallower flutes.

My question is, what kind of cuts would you use either the detail or shallow detail gouge for? And how would you know which of those two tools to use?

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#2

Steven Antonucci

A good detail gouge

Steven Antonucci

will be rigid and come to a fine edge. I have one of Doug's detail gouges, but I couldn't tell you if it was A or B. I use it every time I turn.

You probably don't need to worry about the differences as much as the similarities. You want a stout, rigid piece of steel with a fine edge. How deep the flute is isn't important. I use mine to cut details, hollow, turn tenons, and so much more...

Either way, you've made a wise choice.

Steve

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#3

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

Ed Moore in SW VA

Wilbur,

I recommend the 3/8" Thompson detail gouge for most spindle work. Since I make a lot of ornaments with detailed icicles I strongly recommend the Thompson 1/4" detail gouge for that sort of work. It is REALLY a go-to tool.

Folks who make boxes and like to make a back-cut might choose the 1/2" spindle or detail gouge, and probably the latter.

I have never felt the need for a shallow detail gouge.

Ed

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

Keith Tompkins

Hi Wilbur, The shallow detail gouge has a LOT of metal supporting the cutting edge. That can create a problem, because that creates a very long bevel. The long bevel can really interfere with some cuts, such as coves. The back of the bevel touches the turning, and acts like a lever or pivot point, which tends to lift the cutting edge out of the cut while bruising the wood at the rear of the bevel. A lot of metal has to be ground away to alleviate this problem. The only advantage I see with the shallow gouge is when using the tool to hollow end-grain or working far over the tool rest, where the added rigidity is required.

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#5

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

nick

I do a lot of end-grain hollowing and the Thompson shallow detail gouge was recommended to me by people at this site. I've been using the 1/2" shallow ever since pretty much every day. It is very stout (rigid, I mean, as noted above). The 3/8" s.d.g. is also useful for light cuts but much more flexible and prone to chatter. I haven't used the deeper detail gouges so I can't compare them but it seems reasonable to suppose that they would be more flexible than the s.d.g.

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#6

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

John K Jordan

Wilber,

I use some of both in different sizes, and as noted the shallow gouge is stiffer and if used with the same jig setting as other spindle gouges it will have a narrow tip and a very long bevel on the bottom. I use this to work on small detail, especially when forced to work further from the rest. With the narrow tip and sturdy cross-section I like to use it for smaller things for which I previously used a smaller diameter gouge.

I like the deeper gouge for most other spindle work.

JKJ

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#7

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

john lucas

I have both. The detail gouge is my go to tool for almost everything I don't use a bowl gouge for. The one dissadvantage of the detail gouge is the long bevel. You can't get the tool rest as close to the work. However this isn't really a disadvantage because the thickness of the tool compensates nicely for the overhang over the tool rest. In fact you can hang it so far over the tool rest I use it for cleaning up bowl bottoms with a straight tool rest instead of the curved one.

I grind away most of the bevel so I can turn any cove with this that i can with the spindle gouge. I bought the 1/2" spindle gouge so I could learn the difference but I like the detail gouge so much I almost never use the spindle gouge.

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#8

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

adrien

'Sfunny. I have lots of difficulties with a detail gouge, especially when working large coves or beads. My first spindle gouges were all shallow, the details seem to be a more recent arrival. Given my klutzy skills at the lathe, this may be a reflection of lack of skill. I rather suspect, though that it's what one gets used to. Some people even know how to use a skew. ;)

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#9

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

Gordon Seto

The width of the shallow detail gouge flute is narrower. There is so much steel underneath, the bevel is very long. It has obvious hollow ground. You will have to round off the heel in order to avoid bruising. The tool is more difficult to control on long flowing curve. It is essential for off center turning where the tool rest can't be kept close.

If I don't have a lot of tool overhang over the rest, I would use the detail gouge.

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#10

Bill Blasic

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

Bill Blasic

As mentioned by Ed above the Thompson 1/4" detail gouge has become my go to tool for finials and icicles. I have 6" and 8" handles for them and tool control is super.

Bill

Re: Detail gouge vs. shallow detail gouge vs. ???

#11

Thanks!

wilbur

Thanks for the input, everyone! I have a better idea of these tools now.