Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A first,

Posts

A first,

#1

A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Yesterday I had a student have her first turning class. As usual I started her with the 1 1/4" skew. It took her a while but she made two perfectly even cylinders, so after a brake she went back at it and then I took away the 1 1/4 " skew and gave her the 1", she made another cylinder smooth as glass, so I gave her the 3/4" skew, another smooth cylinder.

My surprise, this young lady did not have a single catch!

I just got this message from her:

"Hi Jorge,

I just want to say thanks for the intro to the lathe yesterday! It was fun and I can see how it can be addictive - in fact, I even had a dream about turning last night! I am brainstorming ideas for next week."

Re: A first,

#2

Re: A first,

john lucas

Jorge Nick Cook told me he is starting people on the skew. He said it's easier for them to understand where the bevel is and how it works. I still wonder where the bevel is on a bowl gouge. :) Of course you know pretty quick when you don't find it.

Re: A first,

#3

Re: A first,

Galen Vetterick

How much for that set of skews? I need to find a set of skews like that! Ones that the catches have LONG ago been used up and can be used by a beginner to look good from the start.

Galen

Who put away an oval skew for good and still working with two rectangular skews with a lot of catches in them yet.

Re: A first,

#4

Re: A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi John,

I think the same, and it is the way I learned from the local HS shop teacher.

I had just a few students so far and only 3 ladies, seems to me that they are a lot more relaxed and better listeners than the guys.

Re: A first,

#5

Re: A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Galen,

Yes, my skews get a lot of use, make me an offer I cannot refuse. They are Thompson's the bigger ones and the 3/4" is, er, an oval Sorby... ;)

Where are you? If you can show up in my shop maybe we can work it out.

Have you ever tried with a really big skew? I used to have a 2" one and at some point a man already a turner came for lessons and after some trouble he got over it. He bought that skew from me...

The bigger the skew the easier it is, give it a try.

Re: A first,

#6

Re: A first,

John K Jordan

Jorge,

Good job!

I always start out people on the skew. A couple of reasons: when I started turning most of the "experienced" turners I new, even an instructor at Woodcraft, told me to avoid the skew. "Stay far away from that evil thing!" But the books I read said said otherwise so I was determined to learn to use it. I found out quickly how easy it really was. Sure, I had a few interesting spiral catches while practicing. Another reason is I think learning on the skew teaches the basic concept of cutting with the sharp edge which applies to gouges, etc.

One thing - after a while, I found it hard to make it catch while planing, even if I tried to demonstrate a catch. I can still catch nicely, thank you, making a large bead with the heal - just give the handle a little twist into the wood! My catchless skew is perfect for beads but it is a crutch.

JKJ

Re: A first,

#7

Re: A first,

john lucas

I agree. The best student I've had so far was a lady who was a nurse and didn't even know what a lathe was. Not sure why she took the class but she did excellent and was very easy to teach.

Re: A first,

#8

Re: A first,

john lucas

Galen I find no difference in ease or difficulty of use in my Oval skew or my other skews. I really think what happens is people have a skew and of course they get catches(we all do) They work with it for a while and finally decide to buy a new skew. This new one works. I think it's 2 things. One is you really want to learn the skew so you put out the effort, and practice, to learn it. The other is that it may have a slightly different grind angle than your original one that simply works better for you.

I have skews from 3" down to .015". I have all sorts of grinds, convex, concave and flat and sharpening angles from 25 degrees to 90 degrees. The larger skews on large work can be hard to use. They simply take a very large bite and want to pull themselves into the wood. 2" and under is a good size.

I find a blunter edge skew is less prone to catches but can be harder to use on beads. This is because the handle must be move further to create the same shape bead. I find 35 degrees as measured from bevel to bevel to be about the best for beginners. It's sharp enough to cut easily but blunt enough not to be as grabby.

I can't see any advantage to a convex grind. Maybe I need to spend a day with Eli Avisara. I find it harder to roll a bead. It's about the same for planing work.

Re: A first,

#9

Re: A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Thanks John,

I still have days when I get catches, specially rolling beads, then I use a spindle gauge or even a bowl gouge.

What is your catchless skew? Wouldn't hurt to have one around.

Re: A first,

#10

Re: A first,

Carol Reed

"...better listeners than the guys. "

When I was teaching, it seemed the guys were focused on getting it done without undo effort on the process. The ladies were interested in the process to get what they wanted. That made for interesting classes from a lecture POV. I found everything had to presented at least two different ways. Fun times. Enjoy your classes.

Re: A first,

#11

Re: A first,

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Good job with starting her on the skew Jorge! I have been doing a lot of that with new students as well - except for those who want to turn bowls of course.

I also have a couple of oval skews, although they do not get much use anymore. Here is an interesting story about the oval skew. I have a 3/4" Sorby oval. A number of years ago, a student of mine who is local to me bought the exact same tool after learning to use mine. He called me complaining that no matter what he did, the tool gave him trouble. So he brought it out, we sharpened up his tool, and chucked up a piece of wood. No matter what either of us tried, the tool would vibrate and chatter, cutting roughly. I was beginning to wonder about myself there for a while. So we grabbed my skew, and sharpened it the very same way we did his. So, same wood, same lathe, same operators, and identical tool. Mine cut the wood as smooth and as easy could be, for both of us. Back to his tool and we got chatter and tearout.

We tried sharpening it some more, we varied the speed, the angle of the tool, the tool rest position, everything we could think of. No matter what we did, both of us cut well with my skew, and not at all with his. We even put calipers on the tools. The specs were within 0.01" of one another for width and thickness. To this day I have no idea why his tool would not cut while mine would.

Re: A first,

#12

skew modificataion *LINK*

John K Jordan

>...What is your catchless skew?

I've posted about this before. The first time some old timers thought it was a joke but it really does work. (Link to that thread below.)

I made this while experimenting. It's worthless for planing but great for facing with the toe and cutting large beads with the heal. I figured that since you only cut with a very small portion of the edge in those situations and you NEVER want any of the rest of the edge to touch the wood, it wouldn't hurt anything if I removed the sharp edge everywhere but the very tips. After sharpening, I used a narrow diamond file to round over the central part of the edge.

If you get the angle wrong while cutting a bead, the rounded edge just rides on the wood without causing a catch. Of course, as I mentioned, it's a crutch and might prevent really mastering the skew.

The part of the edge marked with blue in the photo is the part I rounded over.


JKJ


catchless skew thread

Re: A first,

#13

Re: A first,

Carole Valentine

I have one of those blasted oval skews buried somewhere in my shop. Must have been from the same batch as your students. >(

Re: A first,

#14

Thanks John

Jorge Casta�eda

Very ingenious and very easy to try. hopefully I'll remember it next time I am in trouble...

Re: A first,

#15

I wonder if ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

one tool was tempered better than the other and if possibly even the steel is different. I have felt that the Sorby oval skews have too much whip in them, which would cause vibrations and mess up the cut. Thompson skews have enough heft that this is not a problem. I use them for lots of peeling cuts and never get around to a planing cut because I am usually after a straight cylinder more than for a burnished final cut.

It would be my wager that the second skew is "whippier" than your original one.

Ed

PS: Have a great time at JCCFS next week. Stop by if your plans change.

Re: A first,

#16

Fantastic!

Jennifer Indy.USA

Jorge, that is wonderful. Often times if somebody hasn't been told how hard or how scary something is, they will take it on like gang busters. Seems your student did just that. I'm so glad to know that you're spreading your knowledge of turning. You have such a patient and gentle way that I know you'll be a really good instructor. Enjoy it....it's a blast!

Jen :)

Re: A first,

#17

Re: A first,

Jennifer Indy.USA

I use my oval skew as an example of what not to buy! Horrid things they are.

Re: A first,

#18

Re: A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Thanks Carol,

I'll keep that in mind, this is one to one, so is easier

I had fun too, to the end of the class, she had a smirk...

I'll have the camera ready next time.

Re: A first,

#19

Re: A first,

Jorge Casta�eda

Thank Bill,

Maybe it was an internal flaw, like carbide crystal or harder or softer that made it vibrate.

Re: A first,

#20

Re: Fantastic!

Jorge Casta�eda

Jen

Thanks for the kind words. I had fun too and she was happy at the end and that was rewarding.

Re: A first,

#21

Re: A first,

John K Jordan

>I use my oval skew as an example of what not to buy!

Did you happen to buy one from a student of Bill's? :)

His story is baffling and makes me wonder - if some are just going to be bad how does a person know if the skew itself is the problem? I can't tell the difference between in function my oval skew and one of my flat skews (except the oval is more of a pain to sharpen).

JKJ