Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Posts

Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#1

Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Dave (PacNW)

Not being satisfied with the lighting around my lathe, I looked at the track lights and thought it would be easiest to change them to florescent flood lights. I modified the cans (cut them down) to fit the floodlights. Boy do three floods over your lathe make a lot of light. Yesterday, I was roughing down laminated blank for a peppermill. I had just gotten the blank down to round when i received a phone call, I thought I had hit the stop switch. The blank was 3" in diameter and had 4, 1/2 inch wide maple stripes running length wise. When I returned to the lathe was still running at 1800 rpm. the blank looked like it was dead stopped! I had heard of the strobe effect with florescent lights, this was the first time I had ever seen it. Would you change the lighting to incandescents or somthing else. Should i worry about it or not?

Dave (PacNW)

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#2

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Scott in Falcon

While I haven't actually seen a blank look frozen, I do get very strange rippling colors moving back and forth across the piece I am working on. I intend to switch the incandescent light around my lathe as soon as possible due to this (it drives me nuts).

Scott

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#3

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Donna Banfield

Dave, I use more than a couple different sources of light in my shop. I have the 8 ft. tubes on the ceiling, but also use the Moffat/Saunders lamps at the lathe. My lathe is also right near a very large window for natural light, as well. I'm planning on installing some track lighting just above the lathe this year as well. The reason -- exactly what you describe -- strobing. I'm prone to motion sickness, and it doesn't take more than a few minutes and I'm done for the day. A few years back I was at Totally Turning in NY, watching Nick Cooke turn inside out ornaments. I made the mistake of glancing at the TV monitor showing the close-up of the work. I had to leave not just the demo, but the Symposium for the remainder of the day. It would have been really embarassing to 'hurl' all over Nick's shavings :D

One other thing that is very important as we get older -- our vision stinks. Most of us are working in a basement or garage and the walls are whatever they were before we took over the space. When my new barn was built, I painted the ceiling and walls bright white. I've had a lot of guys in the shop comment on how well they can see what they're working on.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#4

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Barry Irby

Don't run the lathe at any multiple of 60. Try 1820.

Half kidding.

I use a mix of lights around my lathe and have not noticed strobing.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#5

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

john lucas

Dave I never noticed any problems with Flourescent lights other than when I hit one trying to flip a 2x4. I have seen my lathe look like it's running backwards. I use incandescent light on the lathe because they show up scratches better when sanding.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#6

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The shop lights that turn on at the door are incandescent above the lathe. This provides a minimum for safety and walking. There are two 2-bulb florescents above the lathe on pull chains. Then there is the 100 watt Moffat with incandescent. Use the flourescent for coolness and operating cost. If any light is on, there is no strobe.

The lights are on a clean...no equioment breaker. When you overlosd the saw, trip its breaker, it sure is nice to be able to know where your fingers are.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#7

Looking for cool lights!

Jerry Klug

I use a couple of flourscent tube lights that buzz in the winter, four 150 watt incandcscent shop corner lights and a Moffett with a 100 watt at the lathe. Not enough for these old eyes. My local machinist had a nifty incandescent replacement that had a whole bunch of blue white LEDs. It was a great and bright localized lighting for a working tool. His was on his bandsaw. The only problem is that Costco quit carring them and I cannot find a source of a similar light that is reasonable. Anybody out there know of a LED light source?

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#8

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

John K Jordan

I like to mix incandescents and compact fluorescents, both in reflectors. I like bulbs in the 150-250 watt (equiv) range for plenty of light. Compact fluorescents are cooler than incandescents and operate at a higher frequency than fluorescent tubes and don't give me problems with flicker or strobing.

On the other hand, it seems like a good strobe would be just the thing for turning those crazy-dangerous square and winged pieces.

JKJ

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#9

Re: Looking for cool lights!

Mark Wollschlager

The Earthled Evolux is the only '100 watt comparable' LED bulb I have found so far.

13w for 100w output.

They should be cool, but have an internal cooling fan for the electronics.

Most fall into the '50watt ' range.

Some are flood style, so it makes the best of the lumens.

I have not tried them yet.

Be prepared to pay a lot for the bulb. Evolux is around $70, the others go from the high 20's to the 50's.

Have patience, they were around $100 last summer.

It might be a good place to use some of the HD gift cards I have lying around.

I have a small LED spot style light on a gooseneck from Ikea that works well for illuminating the inside of hollow forms.

That was $30. The electronics are in the plug so the bulb end stays room temp.

If you get more than 18-20" from the object it looses a lot of function.

The are 150w comparable ( 42w ) CFL's which are OK for around $8.

They are a little warm, but nothing like an incandescent or halogen.

Mark.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#10

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Texian

Would not worry about the lights but might avoid turning at exactly 1800. I WOULD worry about the lathe still running when I thought it was off.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#11

Re: Cure for the problem

Don Evans

Remember how kids would put a playing card on their bikes spokes to make noise when moving? Rig up one of those on your lathe so you know it's moving...... :\

Don

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#12

Steven Antonucci

Simple things that might help

Steven Antonucci

I had a buddy come over and he referred to my shop as "the cave". Like many people, I have way too much stuff and not enough space. Here's what I did to make things 100% better.

1.) Flourescent bulbs come in a variety of temperatures. Try the daylight bulbs. It might just be the trick to making you feel brighter.

2.) Reorganize the work area. Clutter is not only visually distracting, but absorbs light and casts shadows.

3.) Paint the area a light color. A lot of shops would benefit from this, since light colors reflect more light, dark colors absorb light.

I would bet that all three of them would give you what you wanted...(I still haven't painted, and I am working my way through #2...

Steve

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#13

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Bill McWhirter

Good light is essential for good turning. When I am doing small finials, hollowing, etc., I use a headlight and it makes a world of difference.

Headlamp price is not a good determinate of quality or appropriateness for turning. If you decide to get one, look for light output. Most are rated at around 60 lumens, if you can even find it listed. I found a relatively cheap ( Coast H7, $44 I think) one that is rated at 160-170 lumens and has a light that can be focused. After a couple of hours, it is noticeably dimmer, but a change of batteries brings it right back.

The head strap may be OK for campers, but was not secure enough to keep it from moving around on my head while turning. I found an old headgear for a welding helmet that I could bring myself to discard several years ago and adapted it to hold the light and batteries.

If you get one, position it as low on your forehead as possible so you are looking down the beam and realize that it will take a while to get comfortable with it learn to use it effectively.

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

#14

Re: Woodturning and Florescent lights!

Pete in Holland, MI

Because of the 60hz AC electricity here in the States, (50 in other places), the electricity goes from positive to negative 60 times a second, thus for a short period between cycles, the electricity is "off". This creates that 60 cycle hum in transformers & ballasts.

With lighting it can creat issues. Fast reacting lights, like floresecent and LED, actually turn off 60 times per second, thus giving rotating objects at intervals of that 60 speed, an opportunity to freeze frame. You won't get this on incadecent lights. It takes a period of time for the element to get hot, and cool off. Thus the on/off that is going on with the power doesn't really show up in an incadecent's light output.

Watch on the road for tail lights of newer semi trailers verses older ones. The new rigs with LED tail lights, the lights do go on & off instantly. Compared to incadecent lights, there is a slight warm up & cool down noted.

I can't watch LED Christmas lights for long, as my eye picks up the on/off going on and bothers my eyes.

Pete