Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Off-Topic board - my experience

Posts

Off-Topic board - my experience

#1

Off-Topic board - my experience

John K Jordan

Buried deep in another long thread, Ruth wrote (in the message "Not and OT board..........."):

"...I don't think there's a need for an OT board. That would only

encourage knock-down, drag-out conversations about all sorts of things"

I disagree; it does not have to be and probably would NOT be that way. For years I was the primary moderator for a world-wide 3D graphics forum and we always had an OT board. There was no more tendency to flame there than anywhere else on our forum - we simply didn't allow it. As here, most people followed the rules and those that did not were gently dealt with.

What the OT board did was keep the specific technology boards more focused on the subjects. It encouraged people to post about interesting things - some people are sensitive about wasting bandwidth on off-topic subjects. With diverse discussions and personal stories and humor I always found the OT board the most interesting place on the webboard. As moderator I always read every post (100s per day) but I always read the OT first.

One important thing a separate OT board did very well: it gave those with different interests a common place for OT discussions. Otherwise, those only interested in Character Animation would likely miss a plumbing discussion brought up on the Lighting board. I think our OT board provided a more unified sense of community in this way.

I see the same issue here at Woodcentral - unless a turner visits the "flat" side and vice-versa, she will never even know about potentially fascinating and valuable discussions that go on there.

BTW, I found it was really no significant effort to click on a link to read the OT posts. It certainly can streamline things for those who might want to browse OT topics tomorrow but today are more focused on the subject.

There may be reasons not to have a separate OT forum on WoodCentral, but concern about threats to civility between members should not be one of them.

JKJ

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#2

Steven Antonucci

Let's just use the handtool forum for OT :-)

Steven Antonucci

I agree with the "no voters"- no need. Folks just need to remember that it's OK to disagree... even strongly... as long as we can end the day freinds.

Steve

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#3

I thought handtools was OT?

Ron Sardo

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#4

Steve Kubien

Handtools are not OT

Steve Kubien

Gouges, skews, etc....all handtools. Flatwork on the other hand.....

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#5

Steven Antonucci

Flatwork is what you do before you own a lathe ;-)

Steven Antonucci

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#6

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

Rik in WI

I disagree. Having been one of a number of moderators on a very large forum, my experience is quite different. While the on-topic forums were kept to the gentleman-like conduct the site is known for, we were continually putting out fires in the OT forum. It seemed to attract individuals who had zero interest in the purpose of the forum or positively contributing to the community. There were also times when regular members would lay aside their civility and have at it, which was extremely non-representative of the rest of the forum.

I�ve been very impressed with how the OT discussions have remained cordial even though they may be hot topics. Having them out in the open for all to see, in my opinion, contributes to this civility.

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#7

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

John K Jordan

That sounds like a very different type of forum. Part of the difference may have been in the policies and level of enforcement.

Ours was fairly strict and everyone understood the rules and understood unprofessional behavior would get them locked out very quickly. Personal attacks and hot political and religious threads unceremoniously disappeared. The members were largely working professionals in a technical field. Riff-raff and hot-heads weren't around long.

JKJ

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#8

Let's wash the dirty undos at home!

Jorge Casta�eda

The hand tools forum is a bunch of very dedicated and knowledgeable crafstmen,

why to trash their place?

I visit all tree forums and enjoy all three and cannot think of dumping on another forum the trash we generate here.

We should think twice before posting anything. ..

Jorge

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#9

Steven Antonucci

The smiley face at the end means it was a joke ;-)

Steven Antonucci

I was being a smart a$$- I didn't mean to seriously consider using another part of WC for "active discussions".

I wonder how much misunderstanding is caused by a difference in understanding of Internet etiquette? Usually the smiley indicate something that means confusion, sarcasm, teasing...

Anyhow, I was kidding.

Steve

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#10

I was kidding Steve

Ron Sardo

There was a time when folks here would have thought so too.

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#11

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

Rik in WI

The majority of members are made up of men and women of exceptional character who are there to learn, help others with their hobby, and enjoy the camaraderie of the community. Rules are clearly laid out which individuals must agree to prior to posting and serious offenders are quickly banned. Often offenders would attempt to gain access via a different IP address only to be banned again. One of my responsibilities was to monitor all the forums since I was one of the few at that time that had mod access to the entire site. More often than not any disciplinary action I took was within the OT forums.

You need to understand it is a very active forum of 24K+ members with thousands of posts each day. That being said the OT forums required the attention of the entire mod board whether they were assigned to it or not. When the site was started we had a great deal of discussion about having the OT forums; offenders weren't an issue because there were only a handful of us. As the site grew the necessity of monitoring those forums increased exponentially. As a mod I only visited those forums for the above-mentioned reasons. As a member, I never visit those forums since the topics rarely interest me and I have a low tolerance for individuals who cannot conduct themselves in a civil manner.

I agree with you that the site I moderated was not a technical site supporting a profession but one for serious hobbyist; whereas here there's a very nice mix of professionals and hobbyists.

What I'm trying to convey, is in my experience, having a dedicated OT forum creates more work for the moderators.

Re: Off-Topic board - my experience

#12

Ellis Walentine

I appreciate the feedback, Rik

Ellis Walentine

More grist for the mill.

I've tried very hard over the years to maintain a civil, self-policing atmosphere for discussion here, and I'm not unhappy with the results. I suspect that OT posts, in the context of the regular discussion boards, are less toxic and/or objectionable than they might be off on their own. I certainly don't need more moderating work, that's for sure. :)

Ellis