Off-Topic board - my experience
John K Jordan
Buried deep in another long thread, Ruth wrote (in the message "Not and OT board..........."):
"...I don't think there's a need for an OT board. That would only
encourage knock-down, drag-out conversations about all sorts of things"
I disagree; it does not have to be and probably would NOT be that way. For years I was the primary moderator for a world-wide 3D graphics forum and we always had an OT board. There was no more tendency to flame there than anywhere else on our forum - we simply didn't allow it. As here, most people followed the rules and those that did not were gently dealt with.
What the OT board did was keep the specific technology boards more focused on the subjects. It encouraged people to post about interesting things - some people are sensitive about wasting bandwidth on off-topic subjects. With diverse discussions and personal stories and humor I always found the OT board the most interesting place on the webboard. As moderator I always read every post (100s per day) but I always read the OT first.
One important thing a separate OT board did very well: it gave those with different interests a common place for OT discussions. Otherwise, those only interested in Character Animation would likely miss a plumbing discussion brought up on the Lighting board. I think our OT board provided a more unified sense of community in this way.
I see the same issue here at Woodcentral - unless a turner visits the "flat" side and vice-versa, she will never even know about potentially fascinating and valuable discussions that go on there.
BTW, I found it was really no significant effort to click on a link to read the OT posts. It certainly can streamline things for those who might want to browse OT topics tomorrow but today are more focused on the subject.
There may be reasons not to have a separate OT forum on WoodCentral, but concern about threats to civility between members should not be one of them.
JKJ




