Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting
John Lucas
I have been playing with the new C1 carbide scraper tool. It cuts quick, has no learning curve whatsoever and never needs to be sharpened. It has 4 sides so you rotate it when it gets dull and replace it when all 4 get dull. should take a good while to go through one cutter.
As a strong bowl gouge user I have the experience to use one properly. consequently I don't see any advantage to the carbide scrapers.
I find that I can control the shape to a much finer degree than with a scraper. I can fine tune a shape pretty well with a scraper but I find I get a more flowing curve using a bowl gouge and my body to control the motion of the cut.
We discussed it briefly but I prefer to start sanding as high a grit as I can. The reason is you don't get any sanding lumps. A good example is wood with really hard winter grain and soft summer grain. Or wood with knots. It's very easy to make it lumpy in those areas if you start with really course sandpaper. With a scraper I have to start with 120 or course to get rid of the tearout. Sometimes I can shear scrape a bad area and reduce the need to start so course. With a freshly sharpened bowl gouge that has the right angle on the tip or using a spindle gouge with a sharp angle I can often start with 220.
It does take a few more cuts to do this and since I'm not a production turner of bowls I can get away with it. If I was producing 50 or 100 a week my whole process might change and then I might even like the scrapers.

on the inside of a bowl or hollow vessel with a keen burr?


