Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

Posts

Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#1

Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

John Lucas

I have been playing with the new C1 carbide scraper tool. It cuts quick, has no learning curve whatsoever and never needs to be sharpened. It has 4 sides so you rotate it when it gets dull and replace it when all 4 get dull. should take a good while to go through one cutter.

As a strong bowl gouge user I have the experience to use one properly. consequently I don't see any advantage to the carbide scrapers.

I find that I can control the shape to a much finer degree than with a scraper. I can fine tune a shape pretty well with a scraper but I find I get a more flowing curve using a bowl gouge and my body to control the motion of the cut.

We discussed it briefly but I prefer to start sanding as high a grit as I can. The reason is you don't get any sanding lumps. A good example is wood with really hard winter grain and soft summer grain. Or wood with knots. It's very easy to make it lumpy in those areas if you start with really course sandpaper. With a scraper I have to start with 120 or course to get rid of the tearout. Sometimes I can shear scrape a bad area and reduce the need to start so course. With a freshly sharpened bowl gouge that has the right angle on the tip or using a spindle gouge with a sharp angle I can often start with 220.

It does take a few more cuts to do this and since I'm not a production turner of bowls I can get away with it. If I was producing 50 or 100 a week my whole process might change and then I might even like the scrapers.

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#2

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

Greg Haugen

Very interesting post John.

I only use the technique of flat scraping, or maybe "conventional" scraping would be a better term, with my end grain boxes, in a roughing manner or working on a flat bottomed box. The rest of the time I use a scraper with boxes the "grinder burr" is honed off and a new burr is raised with a burnisher (technique learned from Alan Lacer) or I'm using a Hunter tool the same way, at an angle for a shear angle. Another tool that I have used is the Jordan Shear Scraper on the outside of vessels and bowls. Again, no grinder burr,but a honed surfaced and a raised burr by ceramic stone or burnisher. I definately believe that the age-old technique used by cabinet and furniture makers of raising a "keen" burr has value in woodturning.

I learned how to turn bowls from Mahoney's "From the tree to the table" DVD and a conventional scraper was never on the tool list. I've tried using a scraper on a bowl and didn't like the result. The stubby grind, ala Mahoney and Batty, is my preferred method for bowl interiors.

For roughing and shaping I prefer gouges and even for finishing cuts gouges are preferred but there are some cases where an edge like a Hunter tool or a burnished scraper are the sweetest tools.

In my humble opinion, and it doesn't mean much, I don't find much of a purpose to the "flat" carbide scraping tools. There are many ways to do things in turning and many different styles of turners and some do like them. For them, that's great-they're enjoying turning. Just not a tool on my "gotta get list".

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#3

Steven Antonucci

At $140, it should sand the bowl too

Steven Antonucci

I saw a "carbide" miracle tool at the recent woodworking show, and I will admit that it left a far better finish than I would have expected (in the hands of the guy demoing it-YMMV). However, I simply cannot understand how anyone would spend $140 on a steel bar with an $8 generally available cutter. If I wanted to make one, I could probably do it for about $15 and 20 minutes worth of work.

The multitude of these tools now flooding the market leads me to believe that there's more marketing than science involved. Where s Doug Thompson when you need him ? :-)

S

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

Keith Tompkins

HI John, I've found a purpose for my big Sorby bowl scraper..I'm working on a series of winged bowls, where the bowl is gold-leafed while the wings are natural wood. The gold-leaf shows every minute flaw...the big scraper helps to create a smooth, true curved surface that reflects light beautifully. It's hard to attempt to sand an uneven surface to the same level, it always shows. Previous to the gold-leafed bowls, I never used a scraper. Perhaps "real turners don't use scrapers" mentality has affected my attitudes, but in this case the scraper works great. I'll post my latest piece soon. :)

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#5

Don Pencil

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

Don Pencil

John,

I am with you and Greg mostly in that one probably needs a variety of tools to get the job done. I also find that most often there are simple tools and/or techniques to get the job done. Most of them work well and with good speed.

Having said that, I also find that there are those occasions when "ya just gotta have" that other tool. Just seems like ones you have will not quite do the job. When I look at my tool collection I find that I mostly use just a few tools and the rest only come into play on rare occasion.

Many of the tools I already have, as Greg noted, like the cabinet scraper and others will get me where I need to go on those moments.

If I have a tool that does the job fairly well then I will usually pass on the "latest thing" that will only get me a just little more. For the benefit derived from the occasional use I go with most of what you and Greg have posted.

Don

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#6

Don Pencil

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

Don Pencil

Following up on Greg's thinking, you can get an incredible finish from and inexpensive HSS scraper. You really do not have to spend a lot of money. Knowing how to use the tools you have goes a long way.

Don

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: At $140, it should sand the bowl too

Rob Wallace

Steve A. wrote:

"However, I simply cannot understand how anyone would spend $140 on a steel bar with an $8 generally available cutter. If I wanted to make one, I could probably do it for about $15 and 20 minutes worth of work."

Steve - I did just that - I bought several C3 carbide 12 mm square planer blades (used for spiral cutter heads) and screws from an excellent supplier on eBay for less than $ 16, and spent another $10 on steel bar stock to make my own carbide roughing tools [I made 3, of different configurations] - simply because it is a current "rage" in woodturning tools and we all must have the latest tool, mustn't we? Played with it for a week or two, and I found that I am MUCH more proficient with bowl gouges, cutting faster and in a more 'flowing' manner than I could ever hope to be with the carbide scraper. I really haven't touched it much since then (about 10 months ago) - I use it once in a while to knock bark off of blanks so I don't mess-up my gouges.

Even though I made a few bars to hold the carbide cutters (took about an hour), for as much as I use them, I could have them stolen and never know they were gone. Just my opinion; I still love my gouges. Now if they COULD make the tool sand the pieces too.....Hmmmmm......????

Rob Wallace

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#8

LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) idea.

Craig Daymon

I personally don't the appeal and do agree that if I were to want one I would make it. I'm certain Enco had a fairly diverse collection of carbide inserts that would work for this purpose. Most of the folks I know that have used one say it is fairly unnerving to use. Bowl roughing is usually fun with a gouge. Hate to lose that.

I do have one carbide tool that I bought relatively early on. It has probably a 1" diameter, maybe bigger disk. I get more catches with it than successes. Probably mostly due to the disk size.

All this being said, on the topic of scraping for a good finish, I have one tool that I think will prove useful. (I've been without a shop for some time now and it was made just before my move, so I have to get it out of storage and work with it again to say definitively.)

First, patent-pending copyright, and all that nonsense. Not that I care if you make one, I just don't want to be left out if you try selling them.

After my incident that severed a nerve and an artery in my wrist using a cabinet scraper on the inside of a bowl, I took the offending scraper to work where a friend put it on the mill and cut it into 1.5" (about) disks with a hole in the center so I could mount it on a Sorby multi-tool handle.

This is STRICTLY a shear scraping tool! (The handle will keep my wrist safe and fingers so I can count to 9...OK, still making it to 10.)

As many of you know, properly used a cabinet scraper can get better results than sand paper, so in theory this should prove a very useful tool. Draw a new burr on it and put it to use.

-Craig Daymon

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#9

Re: LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) id

Greg Haugen

Craig, sorry to hear about your accident. Glad your still turning. I don't use the conventional "cabinet scraper" in turning. I use its principle of a "keen" burr raised by a burnisher or some other method to get a better burr on standard turning scrapers than a "grinder" burr, then use them in a shearing action instead of flat. I've heard of a bowl turner that would use a hand held cabinet scraper on the outside of a bowl but never on the inside of bowl for the reason you mentioned.

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#10

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

TomCollins

I bought the C1 because I thought it would compensate for my lack of tool control. Wishful thinking of a beginner. I used it occasionally and it was "ok", but in my hands nothing spectacular. I recently got a 3520B and decided it was time to dig out some large cherry burls that had been aging in the loft of the barn for over 5 years. Every tool I tried just bounced off the burl and I was taking a beating. Then I pulled out the C1. It really did the job on that burl and left an excellent finish. I was able to start sanding at 220 which is unheard of for me. For the run-of-the-mill stuff I'll stick with the gouges but when the going gets really tough I'll pull out the C1.

TomC

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#11

Re: LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) id

Craig Daymon

Thanks Greg.

The accident was about 2 years back now. Almost all the feeling is back and I'd have to point out the scar for anyone to really take notice.

The really odd thing is that I held up my bandaged wrist to my woodturning group in Bucks County, PA (several of whose members are also part of the Lehigh Valley turners in Allentown, PA) , told my tale of horror and then within about 2 months read in Woodworker's Journal about someone in Allentown, PA doing the exact same thing. My only conclusion is that they heard the story, possibly second hand, and thought they could do it safely.

I know a turner back east that turns VERY thin bowls, about 12" in diameter and uses a cabinet scraper on the outside quite effectively to fine tune his wall thickness. It's pretty good for that.

-Craig

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#12

Steve Kubien

A related question

Steve Kubien

Someone brought up the idea of using cabinet scrapers on their bowls. Sounds reasonable enough if care is taken. My question is this... What speed are you spinning your work at when you do this?

Curious.

Steve

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#13

Don Pencil

Re: LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) id

Don Pencil

Greg,

Exactly.

David Wade in Orange County California showed me how to use them some years ago. You should see the results this guy gets with them (on the outside).

Would you use a Sorby teardrop style scraper HSS (or something like it nod, nod, wink, wink) ;) on the inside of a bowl or hollow vessel with a keen burr?

Don Pencil

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#14

Re: LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) id

john lucas

Craig I use cabinet scrapers often, but only with the lathe off, never on. Oops I lied. I have used one on the outside of a hollow vessel. The lathe was running extremely slow. Once I got the John Jordan shear scraping tool I don't use the cabinet scraper on the outside anymore.

If I have really bad tearout or notice that I'm getting the uneven areas around a knot from sanding, then I pull out the curved cabinet scraper. I can work out the torn grain and then feather that area into the rest of the bowl. YOu can feel the dip but it's very hard to see and non turners don't even know it's there.

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#15

Re: A related question

john lucas

Steve I answered it above but never use a cabinet scraper on the inside with the lathe turning. It's just too dangerous. On the outside you can but you better have the lathe running really slow. It heats up the scraper really rapidly.

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#16

Re: LONG rambling response.  Includes useful(?) id

Greg Haugen

Would I use one? Probably not. But that's just me. I prefer gouges for the interior work of bowls. I like the stubby/conventional ground bowl gouge for the interior. I have used a Hunter tool, in the same manner that John Lucas showed in his youtube video, to clean up a "highly figured" area around a knot in an "artistic" bowl. If it were to be done, the key to when your working in "confined areas", like a bowl's interior or a vessel, is to have a small cutter and take very little off. Concentrating more on getting the "tight curled" shavings than "removing wood". Often times when someone gets into trouble too much of the edge was engaged, if it was from an edge that's too large (large tool in a small bowl) or a bad angle (too horizontal and the burr self fed). Most hollowing systems have a tear drop of some sort in their arsenal. I know Don Derry sells a burnisher for the small tips for hollowing systems-which is something I'd like to try.

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#17

Steven Antonucci

Agree with John

Steven Antonucci

I've done it before, and aside from the burning finger tips, a spinning lathe kills the burr so quickly that it's pretty useless. I will often use them to take out tool marks if I missed them while the work was mounted, and I feather in the scraped surface from other areas while sitting in a folding chair in my shop.

If the surface require a lot of scraping, I either recut it or scrap the piece...

S

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#18

Don Pencil

FIRST, FULL DISCLOSURE......

Don Pencil

.....before my next comment and question.

For those who may not be aware, I am the manufacture of the Scorpion and Stinger Systems. They are tools that fit into the catagories we are discussing. I would sincerly like to know what you the woodturners think about this line of thought. It helps in the developement of the tools. Dennis Stewart and Sorby tools are simular.

Personally, I use the 1/4" HSS tip in a straight 3/4" bar held by a pistle grip handle and a forearem support. I can safely cut deep enough on the inside or outside of a bowl or vessel to stop a 2 hp lathe. My favorite wood to work with is seasoned Carolina Cherry. That stuff is hard and like a burl. I cannot do this with a bowl gouge. I use a tear drop scraper to clean it up and then sand as needed. Usually 120 to 180 depending on how coopertive the wood grain was.

For the usual bowl work I do use a bowl gouges.

I am curious as to the simular experience, pro or con, other woodturners have had.

Don Pencil

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

#19

Re: Almost hot topic-scraping vs cutting

robo hippy

I use scrapers a lot on bowls. For roughing, I have them flat on the tool rest. Since most of the roughing cuts are scraping cuts, a scraper far out performs a gouge in this aspect. The main reason to use a gouge here is not for efficiency, but for practicing the cuts.

I have tried card scrapers, and do use them on my flat work. I went back to regular heavy scrapers. I can do all the same cuts, at shear angles, and it has a handle on it. You have a choice of sharpening methods. I use the burr straight off my grinder. I have CBN wheels (cubic boric nitride which is a matrix of boron particles that is bonded to an aluminum wheel) and my 80 grit wheel leaves a beautiful burr and I don't think you can get the same type of burr from the aluminum oxide wheels, maybe from the finer wheels. I can burnish a burr as well. It will give as fine of a finish as my gouges most of the time. I would never make a finish cut with a scraper held flat on the tool rest. Especially on the inside rim of the bowl. This will make the wood screech and howl from vibrations, and can cause massive catches which will make your bowls explode. By having the scraper at a 45 or so degree angle, you get a clean cut and much less tool pressure.

The Ci tools are scrapers. Haven't tried them yet, but have the Eliminator tool with the concave discs. Love them for box bottoms and sides. Shear cuts.

robo hippy